The Constitution: legal authority, enforcement and alteration

Where the Constitution’s legal force comes from, how the courts enforce it as a limiting instrument, and how s 128 alters it, with the Work Choices case on referendums and interpretation.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
constitutional-law
Topics
separation-of-powers

Learning outcomes

  • Explain what makes the Constitution binding law and why the courts decide whether a Commonwealth law is within power.
  • Apply each step of s 128 to a proposed alteration, including the double majority and the additional State requirement.
  • Distinguish alteration of the Constitution’s text under s 128 from the development of its application by judgment.

The Australian Constitution is both a statute and the instrument that confers and limits the powers of the Commonwealth Parliament. Three prior questions follow from that, and a student should ask them before arguing about any particular power: what makes the Constitution binding law, who decides whether a Commonwealth law complies with it, and how can it be changed. The answers separate the ways the Constitution is applied, which is the work of the courts, from the way it is altered, which is a process the Constitution itself prescribes. This article states the Commonwealth constitutional position as it appears in the Constitution’s text and in the High Court decisions cited.

The Constitution is not a free-standing document. It sits within the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act (Imp), enacted by the Imperial Parliament as 63 & 64 Vict c 12. The preamble recites that the people of the colonies “have agreed to unite in one indissoluble Federal Commonwealth under the Crown of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and under the Constitution hereby established”. Clause 9 then provides that “The Constitution of the Commonwealth shall be as follows”, and the Constitution itself follows, divided into chapters.

Clause 5 makes the Act and Commonwealth laws binding. The Act, and all laws made by the Parliament of the Commonwealth under the Constitution, “shall be binding on the courts, judges, and people of every State and of every part of the Commonwealth, notwithstanding anything in the laws of any State”.1 The High Court described the instrument in similar terms. In Amalgamated Society of Engineers v Adelaide Steamship Co Ltd (1920) 28 CLR 129 the joint judgment of Knox CJ, Isaacs, Rich and Starke JJ called it “the political compact of the whole of the people of Australia, enacted into binding law by the Imperial Parliament”, and added that, because the Commonwealth and State Parliaments and Executives are themselves bound by the Court’s declarations about their powers, the Court’s “responsibility is so much the greater to give the true effect to the relevant constitutional provisions”.2

A limiting instrument that the courts enforce

A Commonwealth law can be invalid for want of power. In Australian Communist Party v Commonwealth (1951) 83 CLR 1 the High Court held the Communist Party Dissolution Act 1950 (Cth) wholly invalid.3 Fullagar J, in his separate reasons, explained why the question of validity arose. An Act of that kind could clearly be passed by the Parliament of the United Kingdom or of any of the Australian States, and the question whether it is valid arises for the Commonwealth Parliament “only because the legislative power of the Commonwealth Parliament is limited by an instrument emanating from a superior authority”. He added that the principle that the courts finally decide whether an Act of a legislature in a federal system is within power is, in our system, “accepted as axiomatic”, modified in varying degree by the respect the judicial organ must accord to the opinions of the legislative and executive organs.3

Dixon J, in his separate reasons in the same case, described the Constitution as an instrument “framed in accordance with many traditional conceptions”, some of which it gives effect to, as in separating judicial power from other functions of government, and others of which are simply assumed. Among the assumed conceptions, he said, “the rule of law forms an assumption”.3 These are statements of individual Justices, and a student should not present either as the holding of the Court. They are cited for what they say about how the Constitution is understood to work: it limits the Commonwealth Parliament, and the courts’ function of finally deciding whether a Commonwealth law is within those limits is accepted in our system, subject to the respect owed to the other organs of government.

The Engineers’ case adds the working rule for applying it, which is the subject of Interpreting the Constitution: text, structure and history. That article also explains how the structure of the Constitution qualifies the Engineers’ holding about industrial disputes. The source of that qualification is Dixon J’s statement in Melbourne Corporation v Commonwealth (1947) 74 CLR 31 that the Constitution predicates the continued existence of the States as independent entities.7 How Commonwealth laws are tested against particular powers is covered in Characterisation and heads of power, and how a valid Commonwealth law prevails over a State law is covered in Section 109 and inconsistency between Commonwealth and State laws.

Alteration under section 128

The Constitution states its own method of change: “This Constitution shall not be altered except in the following manner”.4 The steps in s 128 are these.

  1. The proposed law must be passed by an absolute majority of each House of the Parliament.
  2. Not less than two nor more than six months after its passage through both Houses, it must be submitted in each State and Territory to the electors qualified to vote for the House of Representatives.
  3. If one House passes the proposed law by an absolute majority and the other rejects or fails to pass it, or amends it in a way the first House will not accept, the first House may pass it again, by an absolute majority, after an interval of three months, in the same or the next session. If the other House again does not agree, the Governor-General may submit the proposed law to the electors.
  4. If a majority of the electors voting in a majority of the States approve the proposed law, and a majority of all the electors voting also approve it, it is presented to the Governor-General for assent.
  5. An alteration that diminishes the proportionate representation of any State in either House, or the minimum number of its representatives in the House of Representatives, or that alters the limits of a State or in any manner affects the Constitution’s provisions in relation to those matters, does not become law unless the majority of the electors voting in that State approve it.

For the purposes of s 128, “Territory” means a territory referred to in s 122 in respect of which a law allows its representation in the House of Representatives.4 The text of s 128 gives no role to the courts in making an alteration. It also does not say what a failed proposal means, which the High Court has addressed.

Alteration and interpretation are different processes

In New South Wales v Commonwealth (2006) 229 CLR 1 (the Work Choices case) the joint reasons of Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Heydon and Crennan JJ dealt with an argument that the repeated failure of referendum proposals to enlarge Commonwealth industrial power was a “powerful aid in construing the Constitution”. The Court rejected it. It said there are “insuperable difficulties in arguing from the failure of a proposal for constitutional amendment to any conclusion about the Constitution’s meaning”, noted that “few referendums have succeeded” and that party politics and the way a proposal is put and debated influence the outcome, and held that the failed referendums gave no assistance. Kirby J and Callinan J dissented in the result.5

The Court tied the two processes together. If a question about the meaning and operation of the Constitution is controversial, “it is for this Court to determine the answer that is to be given”, because Chapter III, particularly s 76(i), commits matters involving the interpretation of the Constitution to the judicial power of the Commonwealth. Such decisions “may also be followed by the passage of a proposed law for the alteration of the text of the Constitution pursuant to s 128”, but the opening words of s 128 “must be read with those of Ch III”. The Court also referred to Alfred Deakin’s comparison, in his 1902 second reading speech on the Judiciary Bill, between the difficulty of amending the Constitution by referendum and the Court’s differing but continuing role in determining its meaning and operation, and it quoted Windeyer J that the Constitution “is not an ordinary statute: it is a fundamental law” whose principles may vary and develop in response to changing circumstances.5 Put shortly, the text of the Constitution is altered only under s 128, while the way it is applied can develop through judgment, as Windeyer J’s observation recognises.

State constitutions

The Constitution addresses the constitutions of the States separately. Section 106 provides that “The Constitution of each State of the Commonwealth shall, subject to this Constitution, continue as at the establishment of the Commonwealth, or as at the admission or establishment of the State, as the case may be, until altered in accordance with the Constitution of the State.”6 A State constitution is therefore altered by the State’s own procedure, and it remains subject to the Commonwealth Constitution. A question about changing a State constitution is not answered by s 128, which concerns the alteration of “this Constitution”.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify what the question asks: whether a Commonwealth law complies with the Constitution, whether a State law is affected by it, or how a constitutional change is made.
  2. For a challenge to a Commonwealth law, treat the Constitution as a limiting instrument and ask first whether the law falls within a granted power, then whether any limitation applies.
  3. State that it is for the courts, and finally the High Court, to determine whether a Commonwealth law is within power, and do not present the separate observations of one Justice in Australian Communist Party v Commonwealth as the holding.
  4. For a change to the text, apply s 128 step by step: both Houses (or the deadlock route), the referendum in each State and Territory, the double majority, and the additional State-by-State requirement where it applies.
  5. Do not argue that a failed referendum shows what the Constitution means.
  6. For a State constitution, apply s 106 and the State’s own procedure.

Self-check

  • Have I separated how the Constitution is applied by the courts from how its text is altered?
  • Have I attributed observations in the Communist Party case to the Justice who made them?
  • Have I stated each step of s 128, including the extra requirement in the paragraph beginning “No alteration diminishing”?
  • Have I kept State constitutions outside s 128?

Where the authority sits

The text of the Constitution and of s 128 is primary. The High Court decisions cited here bind lower Australian courts, and the High Court can reconsider its own decisions. The statements of Fullagar J and Dixon J in the Communist Party case are individual observations, and the statements of the Work Choices case quoted above are from the joint reasons of five Justices.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.