The Constitution: legal authority, enforcement and alteration
Where the Constitution’s legal force comes from
The Constitution is not stand-alone. It is part of the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act, a British (Imperial) statute. Its preamble says the colonies’ people agreed to unite under the Crown and under this Constitution.
Clause 9 of that Act introduces the Constitution’s text, which then follows in chapters.
Clause 5 of the Act makes it, and valid Commonwealth laws, binding on all courts, judges and people in every State. This applies despite anything in State law.
In Amalgamated Society of Engineers v Adelaide Steamship Co Ltd, the High Court described the Constitution as the people’s political compact, turned into binding law by the Imperial Parliament. The Court also reasoned that because governments are bound by its rulings on their powers, it bears great responsibility to give constitutional provisions their true effect.
A limiting instrument that the courts enforce
A Commonwealth law can be struck down if Parliament had no power to make it. In the Communist Party Case (1951), the High Court held a law dissolving the Communist Party was wholly invalid.
Justice Fullagar explained why this question even arises. The UK Parliament, or a State Parliament, could pass such a law freely. The Commonwealth Parliament cannot, because the Constitution limits its power. He said it is accepted as axiomatic (treated as a basic, unquestioned principle) that courts finally decide whether a law is within power. But courts still show some respect to the views of Parliament and government.
Justice Dixon, in separate reasons in the same case, described the Constitution as built on “traditional conceptions”. Some it states directly, like separating judicial power from other government functions. Others it simply assumes, including what Dixon J called an assumption of the rule of law.
These are views of individual judges, not the Court’s official holding. A student should not treat them as binding law. They show how the Constitution is understood to work: it limits Parliament, and courts enforce that limit, while still respecting the other branches of government.
The Engineers’ Case adds a working rule for applying these limits, covered in a separate article on constitutional interpretation. That article also explains a qualification to the Engineers’ holding on industrial disputes. The qualification comes from Dixon J in Melbourne Corporation v Commonwealth (1947), who said the Constitution assumes the States continue to exist as independent entities.
Alteration under section 128
Section 128 sets out the only way to alter the Constitution. Parliament cannot change it by ordinary legislation; this special process applies instead.
First, an absolute majority of each House must pass the proposed law. Then, between two and six months later, it goes to voters in every State and Territory who can vote for the House of Representatives.
There’s a deadlock rule too. If one House passes the proposal but the other rejects, fails to pass, or unacceptably amends it, the first House may pass it again after three months. If the second House still disagrees, the Governor-General may put it to the electors anyway.
To succeed, the proposal needs a “double majority”: most voters overall, and majorities in most States. Only then does it go to the Governor-General for assent.
Extra protection applies to proposals affecting a State’s representation, its minimum seats in the House of Representatives, or its boundaries. These need majority approval from voters in that specific State as well.
For this process, “Territory” means a s 122 territory given representation in the House of Representatives by law.
Section 128 says nothing about courts having a role in making alterations. It also doesn’t explain what happens if a proposal fails—an issue the High Court has since considered.
Alteration and interpretation are different processes
In New South Wales v Commonwealth (2006) 229 CLR 1 (the Work Choices case), the majority rejected an argument. The argument said failed referendums to expand Commonwealth industrial power should guide how we read the Constitution.
The Court said this reasoning had “insuperable difficulties”. Few referendums ever succeed, and politics affects their outcome. So failed referendums gave no help in interpreting the Constitution. Kirby J and Callinan J dissented.
The Court then linked interpretation and alteration. Where the Constitution’s meaning is disputed, Chapter III (especially s 76(i)) gives the Court, not referendums, the job of deciding it.
A court decision may later be followed by a referendum under s 128 to change the constitutional text. But s 128 must be read together with Chapter III’s provisions.
The Court cited Alfred Deakin, who contrasted the difficulty of amending the Constitution by referendum with the Court’s ongoing role in interpreting it. It also quoted Windeyer J: the Constitution is “a fundamental law”, not an ordinary statute, whose principles can develop as circumstances change.
In short: only s 128 can alter the constitutional text. But how that text applies can still develop through judicial interpretation.
State constitutions
Section 106 deals with State constitutions separately from the rest of the Constitution. It says each State’s constitution continues as it was when the Commonwealth began, or when that State joined.
This continues until the State changes its own constitution, using that State’s own procedure. But this is always subject to the Commonwealth Constitution.
Section 128 does not apply here. Section 128 is about altering the Commonwealth Constitution, not a State’s constitution.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out what the question is really asking. It might ask whether a Commonwealth law complies with the Constitution, whether a State law is affected, or how the Constitution can be changed.
If a Commonwealth law is challenged, treat the Constitution as a limiting instrument. Ask first whether the law fits within a granted power, then check if any limitation applies.
Only courts, and ultimately the High Court, decide whether a Commonwealth law is within power. Do not treat one Justice’s separate comments in Australian Communist Party v Commonwealth as the Court’s actual holding.
For changing the constitutional text, work through s 128 carefully. This means passage by both Houses (or using the deadlock process), a referendum in every State and Territory, achieving the double majority, and meeting the extra State-by-State requirement where it applies.
Do not argue that a failed referendum tells you what the Constitution means. A failed vote does not reveal the Constitution’s meaning.
For a State constitution, apply s 106 along with that State’s own amendment procedure.
Where the authority sits
The Constitution’s text, including section 128, is the primary source of authority.
High Court decisions bind lower Australian courts. The High Court itself can reconsider, and change, its own earlier decisions.
Not all quoted statements carry the same weight. The comments by Fullagar J and Dixon J in the Communist Party case were individual views, not a joint judgment.
By contrast, the Work Choices case statements came from five Justices writing joint reasons together.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.