R v Davison
R v Davison (1954) 90 CLR 353
A deputy registrar in bankruptcy made an order on a debtor’s own petition on the day it was filed. Could Parliament give that officer the power to make a binding order? What makes a function judicial?
What happened?
Mr Davison presented a debtor’s petition for a sequestration order in the Federal Court of Bankruptcy on 2 May 1952. The same day, a deputy registrar in bankruptcy, appointed as deputy registrar, made the sequestration order, signed “By the Court”. The deputy registrar had been given the powers of the Registrar in Bankruptcy by a direction of the Attorney-General. (Webb J, at pp 371-372)
Later, on an application for discharge, the Federal Judge in Bankruptcy ordered that Mr Davison be charged and tried summarily for offences under the Act. Before he was called on to plead, he asked for a special case to be stated. The questions were whether the deputy registrar was authorised to make the sequestration order, and whether he was a bankrupt. (Webb J, at p 372)
What did the Court decide?
The questions in the special case were answered No and No.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Dixon CJ and McTiernan J, in joint reasons, said that the ascertainment of existing rights by the judicial determination of issues of fact or law falls exclusively within judicial power, so that Parliament cannot confide that function to any person or body but a court constituted under ss 71 and 72 of the Constitution. (pp 369-370) In the same passage they said that there are many functions that are not necessarily of a judicial character but may be performed judicially, whether because they are incidental to the exercise of judicial power or because they are proper subjects of its exercise, and that how the legislature treats a particular act may determine its character. (pp 369-370)
Their reasons held the sequestration order void on a different footing. A judicial order, meaning one that by its nature or description or the character given to it by the legislation involves an exercise of the judicial power of the Commonwealth, can be made only by a court constituted under ss 71 and 72. (p 366) The order was one characteristic of courts, and the registrar was made the substitute for the judge, acting as the court. The Act treated the function of making a sequestration order as judicial and confided it to the registrar in the same character as the court, so the order was an attempt to authorise a person who was not such a court to exercise part of the judicial power of the Commonwealth. (p 371)
Fullagar J agreed generally with the judgment of the Chief Justice and added a few words. Kitto J and Taylor J gave separate reasons and each answered the questions in the negative. Webb J dissented and would have answered both questions Yes.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Classification unresolved · Dixon CJ and McTiernan J
Read judgment: pp 369–370 (opens in a new tab)
The exclusivity statement and the observation that many functions may be performed judicially without being judicial in character are stated in general terms in the course of the joint reasons’ discussion of what judicial power covers. The order was held void for the reasons at pp 366 and 371, which turn on the character the legislation gave the registrar’s order. A binary ratio or obiter label would hide the question how far the general statement was needed for that holding.
Ratio · Dixon CJ and McTiernan J
Read judgment: p 366 (opens in a new tab), p 371 (opens in a new tab)
The joint reasons held that a judicial order, being one that by its nature or description or the character given to it by the legislation involves an exercise of the judicial power of the Commonwealth, could be made only by a court constituted under ss 71 and 72 (p 366). They found that the Act made the registrar the substitute for the judge, acting as the court, and treated the making of the sequestration order as judicial (p 371), so the order was an attempt to authorise a non-court to exercise part of that power and was void (p 371). These steps decide the questions in the special case.
Why does this case matter?
A student who asks only whether an officer had authority under the statute, or whether the order carries the court’s name, misses the constitutional question. The examiner looks for an answer that asks what kind of function the order performs and how the legislation treats it, before asking whether Parliament may give that function to a non-judge.
Exam and application relevance
For a question on whether a body other than a court may make a binding order, identify the function being performed, how the legislation describes the order and who is to make it. Then decide which Justices’ reasons you rely on for each step. Several Justices wrote separately, so do not attribute one Justice’s reasoning to the others, and check each statement of principle against what the order in the case actually was.
Check your understanding
1. Which Justices wrote the joint reasons, and which Justice would have answered both questions Yes?
2. What features of the Bankruptcy Act’s treatment of the registrar’s power to make a sequestration order did the joint reasons rely on in holding the order void?
3. What did Fullagar J say about his relationship to the reasons of the Chief Justice?