Searching without a warrant: thresholds, scanning and safeguards
How police may search a person without a warrant in each Australian State and Territory, how that differs from a power to require a person to submit to an electronic scan, and the thresholds, authorisation limits and conduct safeguards that control each.
Learning outcomes
- Distinguish a suspicion-based warrantless search power from a place-based scanning power, and state what each requires before it may be exercised.
- Apply the reasonable suspicion threshold as George v Rockett and R v Rondo state it to facts about what an officer knew at the time.
- Work through the Queensland warrantless search power in ss 29 and 30 of the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 (Qld), naming the prescribed circumstance relied on.
- Explain how Queensland’s hand held scanner scheme is authorised and limited, and why s 39K means a scan is not a search.
- Identify the corresponding provisions in the other States and Territories, and say where Victoria’s designated-area power departs from the scanning model.
Police in each Australian State and Territory may search a person without a warrant, and several jurisdictions have also enacted powers to require a person to submit to an electronic metal-detection scan. Before asking whether a search was lawful, a student has to ask a prior question: which kind of power was being exercised. A suspicion-based search power turns on a threshold about the individual searched that the officer has to hold. A place-based scanning power may be exercised without any suspicion about the person scanned, and is controlled instead by who authorised it, where it operates, how long the authorisation runs and what has to be reported. This article states the Queensland provisions in detail and names the corresponding provisions elsewhere; the Commonwealth warrant-based regime is a separate framework and is not stated here.
Two kinds of warrantless power
The statutes keep the two apart. In Queensland the power to search a person without a warrant sits in chapter 2, part 2, division 2 of the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 (Qld),1 and the hand held scanner scheme sits in chapter 2, part 3A.2 New South Wales divides the same ground between Part 4 and Part 4A of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW).8 Sorting the schemes into suspicion-based and place-based powers is a way of organising the powers, not a statutory label, but the two are challenged differently: a suspicion-based search on the officer’s grounds, a place-based power on the authorisation, the place, the time the authority had left to run and the conditions on its exercise.
The suspicion threshold
The statutory formulations are close without being identical, and each names the subject matter the suspicion has to be about. Queensland’s s 29(1) gives the power to an officer “who reasonably suspects any of the prescribed circumstances for searching a person without a warrant exist”; s 21(1) of the New South Wales Act, to an officer who “suspects on reasonable grounds” that one of four listed circumstances exists, with s 23(1) turning on a suspicion on reasonable grounds “that the person has a dangerous implement unlawfully in the person’s possession or under the person’s control” in a public place or a school. The equivalents are s 10(1)(a) of the Control of Weapons Act 1990 (Vic), on a weapon carried in a public place contrary to that Act;9 s 68(1) of the Criminal Investigation Act 2006 (WA), on a thing relevant to an offence;10 s 68(1) of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA), on stolen goods, an object whose possession is an offence, or evidence of an indictable offence;11 s 119AA(1) of the Police Administration Act 1978 (NT), on an unlawfully possessed explosive, restricted weapon or ammunition;12 s 15C(2) of the Police Offences Act 1935 (Tas), on a dangerous article possessed without lawful excuse;13 and ss 193(1) and 207(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT), on a knife and on a thing relevant to a serious offence, s 207 adding that the power be necessary and the circumstances serious and urgent.14
What a phrase of that kind requires was stated for statutory powers generally in George v Rockett [1990] HCA 26; (1990) 170 CLR 104.6 In joint reasons, the High Court of Australia said that where a statute prescribes that there must be “reasonable grounds” for a state of mind, including suspicion and belief, “it requires the existence of facts which are sufficient to induce that state of mind in a reasonable person”. Suspicion and belief are different states of mind, and “[t]he facts which can reasonably ground a suspicion may be quite insufficient reasonably to ground a belief, yet some factual basis for the suspicion must be shown”. The case concerned a search warrant issued under s 679 of the Criminal Code (Qld), so it is authority on the statutory phrase rather than on any warrantless power; High Court holdings bind lower Australian courts.
R v Rondo [2001] NSWCCA 540 applied that reasoning to a warrantless stop and search.7 Smart AJ, with whom Spigelman CJ and Simpson J agreed, drew three propositions from the authorities. A reasonable suspicion “involves less than a reasonable belief but more than a possibility”, and there must be something that would create in the mind of a reasonable person an apprehension or fear of the state of affairs the provision covers. Reasonable suspicion “is not arbitrary”: some factual basis has to be shown, and the material may be hearsay or otherwise inadmissible so long as it has some probative value. What matters is the information in the officer’s mind at the time, and whether it afforded reasonable grounds for the suspicion formed, having regard to its source and content in the light of the whole of the surrounding circumstances. On the facts, a young man driving a car he said was not his gave the officer no material on which to form the statutory suspicion. Rondo was decided on s 357E of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW), which the note to s 21 of the New South Wales Act identifies as one of that section’s antecedents; the power is now found in ss 21 and 23 of that Act, and the reasonable-suspicion standard Rondo states is the standard those sections apply. As a decision of an intermediate appellate court it binds courts below it in New South Wales and is persuasive elsewhere.
Two Acts say expressly what may be weighed: s 23(3) of the New South Wales Act and s 10(2) of the Victorian Act each provide that a person’s presence in a location with a high incidence of violent crime may be taken into account in deciding whether the grounds exist.
Queensland: the prescribed circumstances
Section 29(1) gives the power to a police officer “who reasonably suspects any of the prescribed circumstances for searching a person without a warrant exist”. That officer may stop and detain the person, and search the person and anything in the person’s possession “for anything relevant to the circumstances for which the person is detained”. Section 29(2) allows seizure of all or part of a thing that may provide evidence of the commission of an offence, that the person intends to use to cause self harm or harm to someone else, or that is an antique firearm where s 30(1)(b) applies.
The suspicion has to attach to one of the circumstances listed in s 30(1), which is a closed list rather than a general licence to act on unease. Those circumstances include that the person has something that may be an unlawfully possessed weapon, knife or explosive, an unlawful dangerous drug, stolen, unlawfully obtained or tainted property, or evidence of a seven year imprisonment offence that may be concealed on the person or destroyed; that the person has an implement of housebreaking, vehicle theft or drug administration; and that the person has failed to comply with a requirement under s 39BA, 39E or 39G.
Queensland’s hand held scanner scheme
Chapter 2, part 3A is headed “Jack’s Law—Use of hand held scanners without warrant”, and s 39AA states the purpose of the part: “to detect or deter the commission of an offence involving the possession or use of a knife or other weapon”. The part authorises a scan in two situations.
In a relevant place, no authorisation is needed. Section 39BA lets a police officer, without a warrant, require a person to stop and submit to the use of a hand held scanner in a public place at, in or on any of eight kinds of place: licensed premises, a public transport station, a public transport vehicle, retail premises, a safe night precinct, a shopping centre, a sporting or entertainment venue, and a designated business and community precinct. Nothing in s 39BA turns on suspicion about the person scanned, and an officer who starts to exercise the power at a relevant place may continue in a public place even if the person leaves it.
For a scan first started anywhere else in a public place, an authority is needed (although a scan lawfully started at a relevant place, or at the place stated in an authority, may continue in a public place after the person leaves: ss 39BA(2), 39E(3)). Under s 39C a senior police officer — an officer of at least the rank of inspector, or a senior sergeant authorised by the commissioner (s 39A) — “may issue an authority only if the senior police officer considers the use of a hand held scanner at, in or on the public place is likely to be effective to detect or deter the commission of an offence involving the possession or use of a knife or other weapon”. The authority has to state the day and time it starts and ends, the place, and the reasons for which it is issued, and it has effect for 12 hours after it starts (s 39D). Section 39E then authorises the scan in the stated public place.
To “use” a scanner is to pass it “in close proximity to the person or the person’s belongings” (s 39A). Section 39H conditions both powers: the officer must exercise the power in the least invasive way that is practicable in the circumstances, may detain the person for so long as is reasonably necessary to exercise it, must produce an identity card unless in uniform and give name, rank and station if asked, and must tell the person that they are required to allow the scan and that failing to comply is a prescribed circumstance under s 30(1)(l). Section 808C(1) requires the police service’s annual report to state the number of hand held scanner authorities issued during the financial year, and then information about the number of people who were required to submit to the use of hand held scanners — which is not the same figure as the number actually scanned — the number of knives or other weapons detected, the number of times a warrantless search power was exercised as a result, and the number and type of charges made as a result. Section 808C(2) then provides that none of that information may include anything “that identifies, or is likely to lead to the identification of, an individual”.
Section 39K keeps the two regimes apart. It declares that the power to use a hand held scanner “does not confer power on a police officer to search a person without a warrant”, and that part 3A does not affect the search power in part 2, division 2.3 A scan is not a search, and an indication of metal is not itself one of the prescribed circumstances.
Part 3A once carried its own expiry provision. The Police Powers and Responsibilities (Making Jack’s Law Permanent) and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2025 (Qld) omitted that provision, inserted s 39BA and amended s 30(1)(l) to pick up the new section; part 3 of the amending Act commenced in July 2025.5
How a scan becomes a search
Where a scanner indicates that metal is, or is likely to be, present, s 39G lets the officer require the person to produce the thing that may be causing the indication and to resubmit to the scan. A failure to comply with a requirement under s 39BA, 39E or 39G is one of the prescribed circumstances in s 30(1)(l). The route from scan to search therefore runs through s 29: the failure supplies the circumstance, and an officer who reasonably suspects that circumstance exists may search under s 29.
Other jurisdictions reach a comparable point by different drafting, which is worth checking rather than assuming. In the Northern Territory, s 116KJ provides that where a person fails to comply without a reasonable excuse, the member “is taken to have reasonable grounds to suspect” that a restricted weapon the person may not lawfully possess is in the person’s possession. In Tasmania, s 15C(4A) provides that such a failure “may constitute a reasonable ground for suspicion” that the person has a dangerous article without lawful excuse. In New South Wales, failing or refusing to comply without reasonable excuse is an offence under s 45N, and in Western Australia s 61C(2) makes it an offence.
Place-based powers elsewhere, and Victoria’s difference
In New South Wales a senior police officer may declare public transport stations, shopping precincts, sporting venues and other prescribed public places to be a designated area, for not more than 12 hours; an officer may then require a person in the area to submit to a hand-held scanner, in the least invasive way practicable and, if reasonably practicable, by an officer of the same sex (ss 45F, 45I, 45K, 45O). The other schemes differ in who authorises, on what grounds and for how long: a designated area in Western Australia, with the detector used in the least invasive way practicable (ss 61C, 61E); a Commissioner’s authorisation for a specified public place for not more than 6 hours in South Australia, on reasonable grounds to believe an incident of violence or disorder may take place there and that the powers are reasonably necessary to prevent it (s 66Z), with s 66ZA adding a trigger about the person rather than the place; an approved member’s authority for not more than 72 hours in the Northern Territory, on the grounds stated in s 116KB; and a prescribed place in Tasmania, where any person within it may be required to undergo an electronic metal detection device search (s 15CAA).
Victoria is where the common position would mislead, because its place-based power is a power to search: Schedule 1 starts the search with an initial electronic device search and then permits a further search of the person and their things where that leads the officer to consider a weapon may be concealed. The Chief Commissioner may declare a designated area where satisfied, among other grounds, that more than one incident of violence or disorder involving weapons has occurred there in the previous 12 months and that it is likely to recur, and a declaration on that ground may not exceed 24 hours (s 10D). Section 10G then lets an officer, without a warrant, stop and search a person and any thing in the person’s possession or under their control for weapons because they are in a public place within the designated area, conducting the least invasive search practicable.
How a search must be conducted
Each Act carries its own rules about the conduct of a personal search; the Queensland rules are stated here.4 Section 624 requires an officer searching a person to ensure, as far as reasonably practicable, that the way the person is searched causes minimal embarrassment, to take reasonable care to protect the person’s dignity, and, unless an immediate and more thorough search is necessary, to restrict a search in public to an examination of outer clothing. Section 626 forbids detaining a person for a search longer than is reasonably necessary. Section 629 permits an officer conducting a lawful search to require removal of all items of clothing, or of outer clothing, from the upper or lower part of the body. Read s 630 for where its qualifier stops. “If reasonably practicable” opens s 630(1) and governs only that subsection: the explanation before the search, the request for cooperation and the opportunity to remain partly clothed. The obligations that follow are not qualified that way — s 630(2) requires the search to be conducted in a way providing reasonable privacy, s 630(3) requires it to be as quick as reasonably practicable with the person allowed to dress as soon as it is finished, s 630(4) prohibits physical contact with the person’s genital and anal areas, and s 630(5) requires an officer who seizes clothing to ensure the person is left with or given reasonably appropriate clothing.
Two consequences of an unlawful search are taught elsewhere and are not restated here. Whether evidence obtained improperly or unlawfully may still be admitted is a question for the exclusionary discretions, treated in The exclusionary discretions. Whether the person detained has a civil claim turns on lawful authority as the answer to false imprisonment, treated in False imprisonment and lawful authority.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the jurisdiction, and then the particular power relied on, before stating any threshold. Section numbers and thresholds differ between these Acts even where the words look alike.
- Ask whether the power is suspicion-based or place-based. If it is suspicion-based, work on the officer’s grounds; if it is place-based, work on the authorisation, the place, the time and the statutory conditions.
- For a suspicion-based power, identify the statutory circumstance suspected, then test the officer’s information against it as Rondo directs: less than a belief but more than a possibility, some factual basis shown, judged on the information in the officer’s mind at the time.
- In Queensland, name the paragraph of s 30(1) relied on. A suspicion of wrongdoing that does not answer one of the listed circumstances does not engage s 29.
- Where a scan has occurred, use the governing jurisdiction’s own words for it, and do not assume that scanning and searching are separate everywhere. In Queensland they are: s 39K says scanning under part 3A confers no power to search a person without a warrant, and one route onward is the failure to comply that s 30(1)(l) makes a prescribed circumstance; a search may also follow where the officer reasonably suspects another circumstance in s 30(1). Elsewhere the statute calls metal detection a search in terms — Tasmania’s s 15CAA(1) defines an “electronic metal detection device search” as a search of a person conducted by passing the device over or close to the person’s outer clothing or requiring the person to pass through it,13 and the South Australian ss 66Z and 66ZA are powers to conduct metal detector searches11 — so find that jurisdiction’s own provision and read what it authorises before deciding whether a further personal search needs its own power.
- Check the conduct rules separately from the power, and take up the consequences last: admissibility under the exclusionary discretions, and any civil claim.
Self-check
- Have I named the jurisdiction and the specific provision, rather than stating a threshold as though it were national?
- Have I separated the suspicion-based power from the place-based power, and tested each on its own terms?
- Have I identified which statutory circumstance the officer suspected, instead of asserting a general suspicion of wrongdoing?
- Have I kept the scan and the search apart, and found the provision that bridges them in the jurisdiction I am applying?