Searching without a warrant: thresholds, scanning and safeguards
Two kinds of warrantless power
Queensland and New South Wales keep two warrantless search powers separate in their statutes. In Queensland, searching a person without a warrant is governed by chapter 2, part 2, division 2 of the Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 (Qld). The hand held scanner scheme sits in a different part, chapter 2, part 3A.
New South Wales splits the same ground differently, between Part 4 and Part 4A of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW).
Calling these powers “suspicion-based” or “place-based” is just a way of organising them. It is not a label used in the statutes themselves.
The two kinds are challenged on different grounds. A suspicion-based search is challenged by looking at the officer’s grounds for suspicion. A place-based power is challenged by looking at the authorisation itself: the place covered, the time left on the authority, and any conditions attached to it.
The suspicion threshold
Each Australian jurisdiction has its own warrantless search power, and the wording differs slightly between them. But each law states what the officer’s suspicion must be about.
In Queensland, s 29(1) needs “reasonable suspicion” of prescribed circumstances. In NSW, s 21(1) needs “reasonable grounds” to suspect one of four listed circumstances; s 23(1) needs reasonable grounds to suspect unlawful possession of a dangerous implement in public or at school.
Victoria’s s 10(1)(a) (Control of Weapons Act) covers an unlawfully carried weapon in public. WA’s s 68(1) (Criminal Investigation Act) covers a thing relevant to an offence. South Australia’s s 68(1) (Summary Offences Act) covers stolen goods, unlawfully possessed items, or evidence of an indictable offence.
The Northern Territory’s s 119AA(1) (Police Administration Act) covers unlawfully possessed explosives, restricted weapons or ammunition. Tasmania’s s 15C(2) (Police Offences Act) covers a dangerous article held without lawful excuse. The ACT’s ss 193(1) and 207(1) (Crimes Act) cover knives and things relevant to serious offences; s 207 also requires that using the power be necessary, and that the circumstances be serious and urgent.
The High Court case George v Rockett explained what “reasonable grounds” means for statutory powers generally. The Court said this phrase requires facts sufficient to create that state of mind in a reasonable person.
The Court distinguished suspicion from belief as different states of mind. Facts that reasonably support a suspicion may not be enough to support a belief, but suspicion still needs some factual basis.
George v Rockett arose from a search warrant under s 679 of the Criminal Code (Qld), not a warrantless power. So it is authority on the meaning of “reasonable grounds” generally, not specifically about warrantless searches. As a High Court decision, it binds lower Australian courts.
Queensland: the prescribed circumstances
This section is about Queensland law only.
Under s 29(1), police can act if they “reasonably suspect” one of the listed circumstances exists. Reasonable suspicion means the officer must have real grounds, not just a hunch.
If that threshold is met, the officer may stop, detain and search the person. The search must relate to the reason the person was detained.
Section 29(2) then allows seizure. Police may seize things that show an offence occurred, that may be used for self-harm or harming others, or an antique firearm where s 30(1)(b) applies.
The suspicion must match one of the specific situations in s 30(1). This is a closed list -- police cannot rely on general unease.
Those listed situations include: unlawful weapons, knives or explosives; unlawful drugs; stolen or tainted property; evidence of a serious offence (carrying seven years’ imprisonment) that might be hidden or destroyed; tools for break-ins, car theft or drug use; and failing to comply with requirements under s 39BA, 39E or 39G.
Queensland’s hand held scanner scheme
This Queensland scheme is called Jack’s Law. Chapter 2, part 3A lets police use hand held scanners without a warrant, to detect or deter knife or weapon offences (s 39AA).
There are two situations. At a “relevant place,” no authorisation is needed. Under s 39BA, police may stop and scan a person in places like licensed premises, public transport, retail premises, safe night precincts, shopping centres, sporting venues, and designated precincts. No suspicion about the person is required, and scanning begun there may continue even if the person moves elsewhere.
Scanning in any other public place needs an authority. A senior officer (inspector or authorised senior sergeant, s 39A) may issue one under s 39C, but only if satisfied scanning there is likely to help detect or deter such an offence. The authority must state start and end times, the place, and reasons, and lasts 12 hours (s 39D). Section 39E then authorises the scan, which may also continue after the person leaves.
“Using” a scanner means passing it close to the person or their belongings (s 39A). Section 39H limits both powers: police must act in the least invasive way practicable, may detain only as long as reasonably necessary, must identify themselves, and must warn that refusal breaches s 30(1)(l).
Section 808C(1) requires annual reporting of how many authorities were issued and people scanned.
How a scan becomes a search
If a scanner shows metal may be present, s 39G lets an officer demand the person produce the item and submit to another scan. Refusing to comply with s 39BA, 39E or 39G is listed as a circumstance under s 30(1)(l).
This matters because of s 29: an officer who reasonably suspects that circumstance exists can then search the person. So the refusal is what opens the door to a search under s 29.
Other States and Territories reach similar results, but word their laws differently. In the Northern Territory, s 116KJ says a refusal without reasonable excuse means the officer “is taken to have reasonable grounds to suspect” an unlawful weapon is present.
In Tasmania, s 15C(4A) says such a refusal “may constitute a reasonable ground for suspicion” of an unlawfully held dangerous article. This is weaker than the Northern Territory version — it is a possible ground, not an automatic one.
New South Wales and Western Australia take a different approach entirely. Under s 45N (NSW) and s 61C(2) (WA), refusing without reasonable excuse is simply made an offence.
How a search must be conducted
These rules come from Queensland’s Police Powers and Responsibilities Act. Other states have their own rules on how searches must be done.
Section 624 sets conduct standards. Officers must minimise embarrassment, protect dignity, and limit public searches to outer clothing, unless a more thorough search is urgently needed.
Section 626 bans detaining someone for a search longer than reasonably necessary.
Section 629 allows officers to require removal of clothing from the upper or lower body during a lawful search.
Section 630 needs care. Its “if reasonably practicable” qualifier applies only to s 630(1): explaining the search, asking for cooperation, and letting the person stay partly clothed.
The later subsections are not qualified this way. Section 630(2) requires reasonable privacy. Section 630(3) requires speed and prompt dressing afterwards. Section 630(4) bans contact with genital and anal areas. Section 630(5) requires officers to leave or give the person suitable clothing if clothes are seized.
This passage doesn’t cover what happens if a search is unlawful. Whether unlawfully obtained evidence can still be used is discussed elsewhere, under the exclusionary discretions. Whether unlawful detention gives a civil claim for false imprisonment is also discussed separately.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the jurisdiction and the exact power relied on. Do this before stating any threshold, since section numbers and thresholds differ between Acts, even where the wording looks similar.
Next, ask whether the power is suspicion-based or place-based. For a suspicion-based power, focus on the officer’s grounds. For a place-based power, focus on the authorisation, the place, the time, and the statutory conditions.
For a suspicion-based power, identify the statutory circumstance suspected. Then test the officer’s information against the Rondo standard: less than a belief but more than a possibility, with some factual basis, judged on what was in the officer’s mind at the time.
In Queensland, name the specific paragraph of s 30(1) relied on. A suspicion of wrongdoing that does not match one of the listed circumstances does not engage s 29.
Where scanning has occurred, use that jurisdiction’s own terms for it. Do not assume scanning and searching are always treated as separate things.
In Queensland they are separate: s 39K says scanning under part 3A gives no power to search a person without a warrant. One route onward is failing to comply, which s 30(1)(l) makes a prescribed circumstance. A search may also follow if the officer reasonably suspects another circumstance under s 30(1).
Elsewhere, the statute may call metal detection a search outright. Tasmania’s s 15CAA(1) defines an “electronic metal detection device search” as passing the device over or near a person’s outer clothing, or requiring them to pass through it. South Australia’s ss 66Z and 66ZA create powers to conduct metal detector searches. Find that jurisdiction’s own provision, and read what it authorises, before deciding whether a further personal search needs separate power.
Finally, check the conduct rules separately from the power itself. Deal with consequences last: admissibility under the exclusionary discretions, and any civil claim.
Self-check
Before moving on, check your answer against four things.
Did you name the actual jurisdiction and provision? Do not state a threshold as if it applies everywhere in Australia.
Did you treat the suspicion-based power and the place-based power separately? Each one needs its own test.
Did you point to the specific statutory circumstance the officer suspected? A general suspicion of wrongdoing is not enough.
Did you keep scanning and searching as separate steps, then find the provision that links them in your jurisdiction?
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.