Maxwell v The Queen

High Court of Australia · 1996

Criminal Law And ProcedureCriminal Process

Maxwell v The Queen (1996) 184 CLR 501

A prosecutor agreed to accept a guilty plea to a lesser charge in a murder case, and the trial judge refused to accept it. Can a court override a choice the prosecution has made about which charge to proceed with?

What happened?

Mr Maxwell was charged with the murder of his wife. He pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter, and the prosecution accepted that plea in satisfaction of the indictment, as s 394A of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) then allowed (the same power now appears in s 153 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW), in terms that give the Crown the same election to accept the plea or require the trial to proceed), on the basis that he could rely on diminished responsibility.

Psychiatric reports were put before the trial judge, McInerney J, for sentence. He doubted whether he could accept the plea on that basis. A further report from one of the psychiatrists later said that the appellant was not suffering a disorder sufficient to diminish his responsibility, and the prosecutor then submitted that the judge should reject the plea, although he did not seek to withdraw the prosecution’s election to accept it. McInerney J rejected the plea. He then formulated two questions for the Court of Criminal Appeal: whether the prosecution could withdraw its acceptance of the plea, and whether a trial judge who had seen a plea accepted by the Crown in full satisfaction of an indictment had any power to reject it.

The Court of Criminal Appeal answered both questions in the affirmative and dismissed the appeal from the rejection. The appellant then appealed to this Court. (This account follows the reasons of Dawson and McHugh JJ.)

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was allowed. The order of McInerney J rejecting the plea was set aside, and the matter was remitted to him to be decided in accordance with the Court’s reasons.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

Gaudron and Gummow JJ said that certain decisions in the prosecution process are, by their nature, not open to judicial review, because a court should not be concerned with who is prosecuted and for what. Those decisions include whether to prosecute, whether to enter a nolle prosequi, whether to present evidence and which charge to lay. A prosecutor’s decision to accept a plea to a lesser charge under s 394A is also insusceptible of judicial review. A court’s rejection of such a plea is judicial review of that decision, and that is so whether or not the prosecutor invites or acquiesces in the rejection. Their Honours added two qualifications. A court may always reject a plea that is not a genuine confession of guilt, or where there is reason to think the accused is not guilty. A court always keeps its power to prevent an abuse of process.

On the trial judge’s power to reject an accepted plea, the Justices did not agree. Dawson and McHugh JJ answered that the judge may reject it only if the plea is not genuine. Toohey J said that the judge has a power to reject it, to be exercised when the interests of justice require, and he would have dismissed the appeal. Gaudron and Gummow JJ said the power is available only in limited circumstances, and not where rejection would review the prosecutor’s decision under s 394A, abuse of process aside.

Why does this case matter?

Criminal process questions often ask who controls the charge on which an accused is tried, and what a trial judge may do when the judge doubts the basis on which the prosecution has accepted a plea. An examiner expects an answer that identifies the decision the prosecutor made, the step the court took in response, and whose reasons support each point.

Exam and application relevance

For a question about a prosecutor’s decision to accept a plea to a lesser charge, identify the decision made, the statutory power it was made under (the case was decided under s 394A of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW); check the current provision, now s 153 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW)) and what the court is asked to do about it. Then decide which Justices’ reasons you rely on for each point, and state each point as that Justice’s or group of Justices’ reasoning, because the reasons were given in three separate sets. Test your answer against the facts: who asked for the plea to be rejected, and why.

Check your understanding

1. Which decisions in the prosecution process did Gaudron and Gummow JJ say are insusceptible of judicial review?

2. Which Justices said that a trial judge may reject a plea accepted by the prosecutor only if the plea is not genuine?

3. What were the two questions McInerney J formulated, and which of them did the Justices divide over?