Directors of Public Prosecutions in Australia
How the Commonwealth, State and Territory Directors of Public Prosecutions are established, what they do, the two-stage test for deciding to prosecute, the Attorney-General’s residual power to direct them, and why courts rarely review a decision to prosecute.
Learning outcomes
- Identify the statute establishing the Director of Public Prosecutions in the Commonwealth and in each State and Territory, and locate the section conferring a given function.
- Explain how the statutes secure the Director’s independence from police and the executive, and compare the Attorney-General’s residual power to direct the Director across jurisdictions.
- Apply the two-stage prosecution test (sufficiency of evidence, then public interest), noting how the Commonwealth and New South Wales policies word it differently.
- Explain why decisions whether to prosecute are not ordinarily subject to judicial review, and what supervision the courts retain.
The Commonwealth and each State and self-governing Territory has a Director of Public Prosecutions, a statutory office that decides whether criminal charges are brought and continued, and conducts the prosecutions that are. Before analysing any prosecutorial decision, ask a prior question: whose law was allegedly broken, and so which Director, under which Act, holds the power in issue? The answer matters because the offices share a design but not a text. Their functions, the take-over powers they hold over prosecutions begun by others, and especially the Attorney-General’s residual power to direct them, differ from one Act to the next.
Why the office exists: separating prosecution from police and politics
The office separates the decision to prosecute from two other actors: the police or agency that investigated the offence, and the elected government. The Prosecution Policy of the Commonwealth describes the most significant change made by the Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1983 (Cth) as “the effective removal of the prosecution process from the political arena by affording the Director an independent status in that process”.12 The same Policy says the Act ensured a separation of the investigative and prosecutorial functions.
Comparing the Acts, three statutory techniques for protecting independence recur. The first is security of tenure. The Commonwealth Director is appointed by the Governor-General for a period that must not exceed seven years (s 18(2)), and s 23 sets out the grounds on which the appointment may, or must, be terminated.1 The South Australian Director is appointed for a term of seven years and, outside the listed grounds, “the Director’s appointment cannot be terminated” (s 4(4), (9)).8 The second is an express statement of freedom from direction. In South Australia the Director is “entirely independent of direction or control by the Crown or any Minister or officer of the Crown”, subject to s 9 itself (s 9(1)). The Western Australian Act (s 25) and the Northern Territory Act (s 26) both provide that, except as provided in their Part on the Attorney-General, the Director is not subject to direction by the Attorney-General or any other person.711
The third is a formula that keeps ministerial responsibility but protects the Director’s control of cases. In New South Wales the Director is responsible to the Attorney General for the due exercise of the Director’s functions, but “nothing in this subsection affects or derogates from the authority of the Director in respect of the preparation, institution and conduct of any proceedings” (s 4(3)).4 Victoria (s 10) and Queensland (s 10(3)) use materially similar wording.56
The statute in each jurisdiction
The Commonwealth office is established by s 5 of the Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1983 (Cth), and the table gives each State and Territory Act.910 Victoria’s statute has a different name, the Public Prosecutions Act 1994 (Vic), and a note to its Part 2 records that the Victorian Director is appointed under Part IIIA of the Constitution Act 1975 (Vic).
| Jurisdiction | Act | Office or Director | Main functions | Attorney-General’s direction power |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cth | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1983 | s 5 | ss 6, 9 | s 8, may concern particular cases |
| NSW | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1986 | s 4 | ss 7, 9 | s 26 guidelines, not for a particular case |
| Vic | Public Prosecutions Act 1994 | Constitution Act 1975 Pt IIIA | s 22 | none in the Act |
| Qld | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1984 | s 4A | ss 10, 11 | s 10A (confiscation examinations); Minister may direct some functions, s 10(1) |
| WA | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1991 | s 4 | s 11 | s 27 general policy, not for a particular case |
| SA | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1991 | s 4 | s 7 | s 9(2) directions and guidelines |
| Tas | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1973 | s 3 | s 12 | s 12, for listed advisory, counsel and practitioner work |
| ACT | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1990 | s 4 | ss 6 to 8 | s 20 general, not for a particular case |
| NT | Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1990 | s 4 | ss 12 to 14 | s 28 general policy, not for a particular case |
What a Director does
Instituting and conducting prosecutions. The core function everywhere is to bring and run prosecutions, though the drafting differs. The Commonwealth Director’s functions include instituting prosecutions on indictment for indictable offences against Commonwealth law, instituting committal proceedings and instituting proceedings for summary conviction (s 6(1)(a), (c), (d)). The New South Wales Director’s principal function is to institute and conduct, on behalf of the Crown, prosecutions for indictable offences in the Supreme Court and the District Court (s 7(1)(a)). The Western Australian Director may commence and conduct the prosecution of any offence, “whether indictable or not” (s 11(1)(a)).
Taking over and discontinuing prosecutions begun by others. The Commonwealth Act preserves the right of any person to institute summary and committal proceedings for Commonwealth offences (s 10(2)), but the Director may take over such a proceeding and then decline to carry it on (s 9(5)). In the Australian Capital Territory the Director may take over proceedings begun by another person “whether or not the person consents”, but may not take over the Attorney-General’s proceedings without a written request (s 8(1), (2)). New South Wales adds a limit: the Director may take over a summary offence matter only if the offence is prescribed or the person responsible consents in writing (s 9(2)). Once a matter is taken over, the Director may decline to proceed further (s 9(4)(b)). The South Australian Director has power “to enter a nolle prosequi or otherwise terminate a prosecution in appropriate cases” (s 7(1)(e)).
Appeals and related powers. The Commonwealth Director may exercise the Attorney-General’s rights of appeal in a prosecution the Director has instituted, taken over or is carrying on (s 9(7)), and the New South Wales Director institutes, and responds to, appeals in respect of the prosecutions the Director brings for indictable offences (s 7(1)(b), (c)). The Commonwealth and South Australian Directors may also give a person an undertaking that their evidence will not be used against them, or immunity from prosecution (Cth s 9(6), (6D); SA s 7(1)(f), (fa)).
Prosecution guidelines and the two-stage test
Each Act lets the Director issue guidelines. The Commonwealth Director may give directions or guidelines to the Australian Federal Police and other investigators and prosecutors, must give the Attorney-General a copy, and must include them in the annual report (s 11).1 The New South Wales Director’s guidelines bind the Deputy Directors, the Solicitor and Crown Prosecutors and may not be furnished for particular cases (ss 13, 15(2)). Western Australia and Victoria require the Director’s guidelines to be published in the Gazette (WA s 24(2); Vic s 26(3)).
The public guidelines state a two-stage test for whether to prosecute. Under the Commonwealth Policy, the first stage asks whether the evidence is sufficient: a bare prima facie case is not enough, and “A prosecution should not proceed if there is no reasonable prospect of a conviction being secured” (para 2.5). If that stage is passed, the prosecutor considers whether “the public interest requires a prosecution to be pursued”, and the Policy adds that “It is not the rule that all offences brought to the attention of the authorities must be prosecuted” (para 2.8).
The New South Wales Prosecution Guidelines frame the test differently.13 Guideline 1.2 asks: “can it be said that there is no reasonable prospect of conviction on the admissible evidence?” and “is the prosecution in the public interest?” Two differences in wording matter. The Commonwealth Policy says the evidential test is not satisfied “if it is considered to be clearly more likely than not that an acquittal will result” (para 2.5), a gloss the New South Wales guideline does not use. The New South Wales Guidelines also open by stating that “the public interest is the paramount consideration” (Guideline 1.1).
The Attorney-General’s residual power to direct
Most Acts let the Attorney-General direct the Director or issue guidelines, but differ on whether a direction may concern a single case and how it is made public.
- Commonwealth. The Attorney-General may give directions or guidelines after consulting the Director, and they may be given “in relation to particular cases” (s 8(1), (2)(c)).2 A copy must be published in the Gazette as soon as practicable and tabled in each House within 15 sitting days; where proceedings may be or are being taken and the interests of justice require non-disclosure, both steps run from the earlier of the Attorney-General ceasing to be so satisfied and the end of the matter, including appeals (s 8(3)-(5)). In September 2019, for example, the Attorney-General directed under s 8(1) that the Director must not proceed, without the Attorney-General’s written consent, with a prosecution of a journalist for listed Commonwealth offences where the alleged facts relate to the person’s professional work as a journalist.3
- New South Wales. The Attorney General may furnish guidelines after consulting the Director, but not in relation to a particular case; they are gazetted and tabled (s 26).
- South Australia. The Attorney-General may give directions and guidelines after consultation; they must be gazetted as soon as practicable and tabled within six sitting days. For an individual matter, both steps may be postponed until the matter is completed if the Attorney-General considers disclosure may prejudice an investigation or prosecution, and material may be withheld to avoid risk to life or safety or other severe prejudice (s 9(2)-(5)).
- Western Australia and Northern Territory. The Attorney-General may, after consultation, issue directions “as to the general policy to be followed”, but not in respect of a particular case, and each direction appears in the Director’s annual report (WA s 27; NT s 28). The Director may, however, ask the Attorney-General for a direction in a particular case, and the Attorney-General may comply (WA s 27(3); NT s 28(3)).
- Australian Capital Territory. A direction or guideline must be “of a general nature” and must not refer to a particular case; it is a notifiable instrument presented to the Legislative Assembly (s 20).
- Queensland, Victoria and Tasmania. The Queensland Act’s Attorney-General guideline power is confined to examinations under the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld) (s 10A), although the Act also lets the Minister direct the Director to perform some functions, such as taking over summary proceedings (s 10(1)(c)). The Victorian Act contains no Attorney-General direction power, though it preserves the Attorney-General’s power to enter a nolle prosequi (s 25(2)). In the Tasmanian Act, the functions the Attorney-General may direct or request are advisory, counsel and other practitioner work listed in s 12(1)(b), (c), (e) and (f).
How far the courts will review a prosecutorial decision
In Barton v The Queen (1980) 147 CLR 75, Gibbs and Mason JJ held that the New South Wales Attorney-General’s decision to file an ex officio indictment was not subject to judicial review.14 They distinguished the court’s power over its own proceedings: “The courts exercise no control over the Attorney-General’s decision to commence criminal proceedings, but once he does so, the courts will control those proceedings so as to ensure that the accused receives a fair trial.” Stephen, Aickin and Wilson JJ agreed on that point.
In Maxwell v The Queen (1996) 184 CLR 501, Gaudron and Gummow JJ, recognising that statutory Directors now exist in every jurisdiction, said that certain decisions in the prosecution process are “of their nature, insusceptible of judicial review”.15 Their list included decisions whether or not to prosecute, to enter a nolle prosequi, whether or not to present evidence, and which charge to lay. Dawson and McHugh JJ, writing separately, said the decision to accept a plea to a lesser offence “is for the prosecution and does not require the approval of the court”, and saw no reason to think a court could intervene “save to prevent an abuse of process”. High Court decisions bind lower Australian courts, and the High Court can reconsider its own decisions.
Guidelines are not a back door to review either. In Western Australia and the Northern Territory, an act or omission of the Director cannot be called in question or held invalid for failure to comply with the Director’s own statement of guidelines (WA s 24(3); NT s 25(3)). What Barton leaves open is the court’s control of its own proceedings, including a stay for abuse of process; the tort of malicious prosecution is a separate, after-the-event remedy.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify whose law the offence is against, and so which Director and which Act govern.
- Find the section conferring the function in issue (instituting, taking over, discontinuing, appealing or issuing guidelines), and any condition on it, such as the New South Wales consent rule for summary offences.
- Apply the two-stage test from that jurisdiction’s own prosecution policy: first the evidential stage, then the public interest stage, noting any difference in how the policy words the test.
- If the Attorney-General has intervened, check whether the Act permits a direction in a particular case or only a general one, and whether the publication requirements were met.
- If a party wants a charging decision overturned, explain that Barton and Maxwell treat decisions whether to prosecute as not ordinarily reviewable, and turn instead to the court’s power to prevent an abuse of process and secure a fair trial.
Self-check
- Have I named the correct Act for the jurisdiction, remembering that Victoria’s is the Public Prosecutions Act 1994?
- Have I checked whether the Attorney-General’s direction power in that jurisdiction extends to particular cases?
- Have I distinguished the decision to prosecute, which courts do not ordinarily review, from the conduct of the trial, which they control?