Directors of Public Prosecutions in Australia
Why the office exists: separating prosecution from police and politics
The office keeps prosecution decisions separate from the police who investigate, and from the elected government. The Commonwealth Policy says the Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1983 (Cth) took prosecutions out of politics, giving the Director independent status. It also says the Act separated investigation from prosecution.
Three legal techniques protect this independence. First, security of tenure: the Commonwealth Director is appointed by the Governor-General for up to seven years (s 18(2)), with termination only on listed grounds (s 23). South Australia’s Director also serves a seven-year term and cannot be removed except on listed grounds (s 4(4), (9)).
Second, some Acts state independence directly. South Australia’s Director is “entirely independent” of the Crown or any Minister, subject to s 9 itself (s 9(1)). Western Australia (s 25) and the Northern Territory (s 26) similarly say the Director is free from direction, except as their Acts’ Attorney-General provisions allow.
Third, some Acts keep ministerial responsibility but protect case control. In New South Wales, the Director answers to the Attorney General generally, but this doesn’t affect the Director’s authority over how proceedings are run (s 4(3)). Victoria (s 10) and Queensland (s 10(3)) use similar wording.
The statute in each jurisdiction
Each Australian jurisdiction has its own Act setting up a Director of Public Prosecutions office. The Commonwealth Act is the Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1983 (Cth), with the office established by s 5.
Victoria is different. Its Act is called the Public Prosecutions Act 1994 (Vic), not a “Director of Public Prosecutions Act”. A note to its Part 2 says the Victorian Director is appointed under Part IIIA of the Constitution Act 1975 (Vic), not the 1994 Act itself.
Every jurisdiction’s Act sets out the Director’s main functions in specific sections (for example, ss 6 and 9 for the Commonwealth, s 22 for Victoria). These sections differ by jurisdiction, so students should check the right one.
Most Acts also give the Attorney-General, or in Queensland the Minister, some power to direct or guide the Director. This power is usually limited: in NSW, WA, ACT and NT, it covers general guidelines or policy only, not a particular case.
The Commonwealth is different again: s 8 lets the Attorney-General’s direction power concern a particular case. Victoria’s Act contains no such power at all. South Australia’s s 9(2) allows both directions and guidelines. Tasmania’s s 12 power is limited to certain listed advisory, counsel and practitioner work. Queensland has a separate s 10A power for confiscation examinations, plus a general Ministerial direction power under s 10(1).
Prosecution guidelines and the two-stage test
Each Act allows the Director to issue guidelines. The Commonwealth Director may direct the AFP and others, but must give the Attorney-General a copy and report them annually (s 11). NSW guidelines bind the Deputy Directors, Solicitor and Crown Prosecutors, and must not be given out for particular cases (ss 13, 15(2)). WA and Victoria require guidelines to be published in the Gazette (WA s 24(2); Vic s 26(3)).
The guidelines set a two-stage test for prosecuting. The Commonwealth Policy first asks if the evidence is sufficient. A bare prima facie case (enough evidence to require an answer, but no more) is not enough; there must be a reasonable prospect of conviction (para 2.5). If that stage is met, the prosecutor asks whether the public interest requires prosecution, noting not every offence must be prosecuted (para 2.8).
NSW frames this differently. Guideline 1.2 asks if there is “no reasonable prospect of conviction” and whether prosecution serves the public interest. Unlike the Commonwealth Policy, NSW does not add that the test fails if acquittal is “clearly more likely than not” (para 2.5). NSW also states the public interest is the “paramount consideration” (Guideline 1.1).
The Attorney-General’s residual power to direct
Most Acts let the Attorney-General direct the Director or set guidelines. They differ on whether a direction can target one case, and how it becomes public.
Commonwealth: the Attorney-General may direct or guide after consulting the Director, even for particular cases (s 8(1), (2)(c)). The direction must be gazetted soon and tabled in Parliament within 15 sitting days. If justice requires secrecy, both steps wait until the Attorney-General no longer thinks disclosure risky, or until the matter (including appeals) ends (s 8(3)-(5)). In 2019, the Attorney-General used this power to require written consent before prosecuting a journalist for certain offences linked to their journalism.
New South Wales: the Attorney General may issue guidelines after consulting the Director, but never about a particular case. These are gazetted and tabled (s 26).
South Australia: the Attorney-General may direct or guide after consultation, normally gazetted promptly and tabled within six sitting days. For an individual matter, these steps can wait until it ends if disclosure might prejudice an investigation or prosecution; some material may be withheld to protect life, safety, or avoid serious prejudice (s 9(2)-(5)).
Western Australia and Northern Territory: the Attorney-General may issue only general policy directions after consultation, not case-specific ones; these appear in the Director’s annual report (WA s 27; NT s 28). The Director may ask for a direction in a specific case, which the Attorney-General may choose to give (WA s 27(3); NT s 28(3)).
Australian Capital Territory: directions or guidelines must stay general and cannot mention a particular case. They are notifiable instruments presented to the Legislative Assembly (s 20).
Queensland, Victoria and Tasmania: Queensland’s guideline power only covers examinations under the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld) (s 10A). The Minister may also direct the Director to perform certain other functions.
How far the courts will review a prosecutorial decision
Courts generally cannot review a prosecutor’s core decisions. In Barton v The Queen, Gibbs and Mason JJ held the Attorney-General’s decision to file an indictment was not reviewable. Stephen, Aickin and Wilson JJ agreed.
The court distinguished this from its control over its own proceedings. Courts do not control the decision to start proceedings, but once started, courts ensure the accused gets a fair trial.
In Maxwell v The Queen, Gaudron and Gummow JJ said some prosecutorial decisions are “insusceptible of judicial review”. This included whether to prosecute, entering a nolle prosequi (ending a prosecution), whether to call evidence, and which charge to lay.
Dawson and McHugh JJ separately said accepting a plea to a lesser offence needs no court approval. They saw no basis for courts to intervene, except to stop an abuse of process.
High Court decisions bind lower courts, but the High Court can reconsider its own past rulings.
Prosecutorial guidelines don’t create a review right either. In WA and the NT, a Director’s act or omission cannot be invalidated just for breaching the Director’s own guidelines (WA s 24(3); NT s 25(3)).
What remains open after Barton is the court’s own control over its proceedings, including staying a case for abuse of process. Malicious prosecution is a separate tort remedy, available only after the event.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by working out which law was broken. That tells you which Director and which Act apply.
Next, find the exact section giving the power you need. This might be the power to start, take over, or drop a case, to appeal, or to issue guidelines. Check for conditions, like the New South Wales rule needing consent for summary offences.
Then apply that jurisdiction’s own two-stage test from its prosecution policy. First ask the evidential question, then the public interest question. Watch for differences in how each policy phrases this test.
If the Attorney-General stepped in, check the Act allows a direction in that specific case, not just a general one. Also check whether publication rules were followed.
Finally, if someone wants a charging decision reversed, remember Barton and Maxwell. These cases say such decisions are not ordinarily reviewable. Instead, look to the court’s power to stop an abuse of process, meaning unfairness in how the case is run, and to ensure a fair trial.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.