Edmunds v The King

Supreme Court of Victoria, Court of Appeal · 2025

Criminal Law And ProcedureDefences

Edmunds v The King [2025] VSCA 31

A planned killer was stabbed during the attack and then fired the fatal shot. Could the victim’s use of the knife turn the killer’s conduct into self-defence?

Under appeal in Edmunds v The King [2026] HCADisp 114

On 7 May 2026, Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ granted special leave to appeal. The disposition gives no reasons and does not alter the Court of Appeal’s holding, but it places that holding before the High Court.

What happened?

Biannca Edmunds was convicted of murdering her former partner, Michael Caposiena, through her involvement in a plan carried out by her husband, Glen Cassidy. Cassidy went to Caposiena’s home armed with a sawn-off shotgun and intending to kill him. After Caposiena opened a locked security door to shake hands, Cassidy grabbed him and pushed into the house. During the ensuing struggle, Caposiena stabbed Cassidy and Cassidy shot Caposiena in the head. Both men died at the scene.

Edmunds sought leave to appeal against conviction on the ground that the trial judge should have directed the jury on self-defence. Her argument depended on a reasonable possibility that Cassidy shot in response to Caposiena’s potentially unlawful use of the knife, rather than simply completing the planned killing.

What did the Court decide?

Emerton P, Taylor JA and Kidd AJA refused leave to appeal. The joint reasons accepted that the evidence suggested a reasonable possibility that Caposiena’s use of the knife was unlawful, so the statutory exclusion concerning a response to known lawful conduct did not by itself dispose of the issue. But the evidence did not suggest a reasonable possibility that Cassidy believed the shooting was necessary to defend himself from death or really serious injury. He shot in pursuit of the pre-existing plan to kill, independently of the knife attack. The trial judge was therefore correct not to direct the jury on self-defence.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

The common-law principles governing an original aggressor’s reliance on self-defence remain relevant to Victoria’s statutory defence. Emerton P, Taylor JA and Kidd AJA said those principles apply with the same or similar force under the statutory provisions. They bear on whether the accused believed the charged conduct was necessary in self-defence, whether it was a reasonable response in the circumstances as perceived, and whether the accused responded defensively or instead pursued the original aggression or criminal design.

Original aggression is therefore relevant but not automatically decisive. The whole circumstances must be assessed, including whether the original aggression ceased and whether the accused’s conduct was responsive to the victim’s conduct. Self-defence cannot operate as a pretext for carrying out a criminal purpose already formed.

Why does this case matter?

A strong analysis separates what the victim did from why the accused used force and tests the accused’s claimed defensive purpose against the sequence and dynamics of the confrontation.

Exam and application relevance

For a Victorian problem involving an aggressor who later claims self-defence, identify the conduct said to have caused a defensive response and ask whether the evidence suggests that the accused actually responded to it. Then assess the perceived necessity and reasonableness required by s 322K, along with the s 322L issue about known lawful conduct. Where the accused entered with a settled plan to kill and carried it through irrespective of the victim’s resistance, Edmunds supports treating that continuity of purpose as powerful evidence against the claimed defensive belief.

The original-aggressor holding is under appeal. The High Court granted special leave on 7 May 2026, but the disposition gave no reasons and did not alter the Court of Appeal’s holding.

Check your understanding

1. Why did the possible unlawfulness of Caposiena’s knife use fail to establish a sufficient evidential basis for Cassidy’s self-defence?

2. What circumstances help distinguish a defensive response by an original aggressor from continued pursuit of an original criminal design?