False imprisonment and lawful authority

False imprisonment as the trespass that protects liberty: detention and unlawfulness, the defendant’s onus to show lawful authority, why an unlawful decision behind a detention does not itself make the detention unlawful, New South Wales arrest powers, and loss in damages.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw
Subjects
torts
Topics
intentional-torts

Learning outcomes

  • State the two requirements of false imprisonment and say who bears the onus of showing the detention was unlawful.
  • Distinguish the lawfulness of a decision that leads to a detention from the lawfulness of the detention itself, using Ruddock v Taylor.
  • Identify the statutory conditions a New South Wales police officer or private person must meet to arrest without a warrant.
  • Explain why false imprisonment is actionable without proof of loss while compensatory damages require loss, using Lewis v Australian Capital Territory.

False imprisonment is the trespass to the person that protects liberty. A student can usually show that the plaintiff was held, so the question that often decides a problem is the second one: whether the person who held the plaintiff can point to lawful authority for doing so. This article states that question through High Court authority, attributing each statement to the Justice or joint reasons it comes from, and uses the New South Wales arrest powers to show what statutory authority looks like. The arrest and detention statutes of the other States and Territories are not stated here, and they differ from New South Wales.

Detention and unlawfulness

In Lewis v Australian Capital Territory [2020] HCA 26, Gageler J began from Blackstone’s statement that false imprisonment needs “The detention of the person” and “The unlawfulness of such detention”. Once the plaintiff establishes detention, his Honour said, the onus shifts to the defendant to negative unlawfulness, but “it is detention in combination with unlawfulness that constitutes the tort” (at [24]).1 Gordon J described the tort as a form of trespass to the person that is “actionable per se, regardless of whether the victim suffers any harm” (at [45]).

An earlier High Court decision places the onus the same way. In Trobridge v Hardy (1955) 94 CLR 147 a constable had arrested a taxi proprietor. Fullagar J said that the mere interference with the plaintiff’s person and liberty was prima facie “a grave infringement of the most elementary and important of all common law rights”, that “It was for the defendant to justify, if he could, by reference to his office or otherwise”, and that the plaintiff did not need to allege either the absence of reasonable and probable cause or malice (at 152). He noted that the plaintiff might also have sued for malicious prosecution, a different tort treated in Malicious prosecution.3 Kitto J and Taylor J gave separate reasons, and the Court allowed the appeal for the plaintiff. The defendant there also relied on a statutory protection for constables, which is not the point for which the case is cited here.

What counts as imprisonment

Kirby J, dissenting in the result in Ruddock v Taylor [2005] HCA 48, described false imprisonment as “a species of the tort of trespass to the person” that “is concerned with direct and intentional forms of harm” (at [137]), and added that the plaintiff must prove the defendant was a direct cause and had the requisite intent (at [141]).2

Restraint is measured against the terms on which the plaintiff came to be where he was. In Balmain New Ferry Co Ltd v Robertson (1906) 4 CLR 379, Robertson paid a penny to enter a ferry wharf, abandoned his journey, and was stopped by the company’s officers when he tried to leave through the turnstile without paying a second penny. O’Connor J accepted that prima facie “any restraint of a person’s liberty without his consent is actionable”, but said that where the restraint is “referable to the terms on which the person entered the premises”, those terms must be examined first. Griffith CJ, who agreed fully with O’Connor J, added that the plaintiff was “free to leave the premises by water” and so there was “no imprisonment”. The Court entered judgment for the company.4 On further appeal the Privy Council agreed with the result but reasoned that nothing had been agreed on entry about the terms of return, so the company was entitled to impose a reasonable condition on exit.8 The case concerned private premises entered on conditions. It shows that a restraint is assessed against those conditions, not that every obstruction is imprisonment, and is not a general test of how complete a restraint must be.

Lawful authority is a separate inquiry

In Ruddock v Taylor the plaintiff’s permanent transitional visa was cancelled twice under s 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), and each cancellation was later quashed. After each, officers detained him under s 189 of that Act, for 161 days and then 155 days. He sued the Ministers who made the cancellation decisions, and the Commonwealth, for false imprisonment and obtained judgment for $116,000. The High Court allowed the appeal, Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ giving joint reasons, Callinan J agreeing in the orders, and McHugh J and Kirby J dissenting.

The joint reasons rejected the argument that because the decision to cancel was unlawful, the detention was too. That argument, they said, “conflates two separate inquiries”: the lawfulness of the decision, and the lawfulness of the detention, which “turned upon whether there was statutory or other authority to detain him” (at [24]-[25]). As s 189 stood at the times in question, it required an officer to detain a person the officer “knows or reasonably suspects” is an unlawful non-citizen. The joint reasons held that it could apply to a person later shown not to be one, so long as the officer had the required state of mind (at [28]). They described it as not “an excusing provision” but one that “both authorised and required officers to detain” (at [31]), and said that reasonable grounds are judged against “what was known or reasonably capable of being known at the relevant time” (at [40]). They noted that misfeasance in public office might lie against a Minister who exercised power knowing, or when he ought to have known, that it was beyond power, which was not the case pleaded (at [28]). Section 189 is stated here as it stood then, not as now in force.

The dissentients started from the same question. McHugh J said that “The only defence to the tort of false imprisonment is lawful authority” (at [121]) and would not read s 189 as abrogating the common law doctrine of false imprisonment “[i]n the absence of words such as ‘is satisfied’” (at [109]). Kirby J said that absent statutory provisions clearly affording an immunity or defence, a good-faith but mistaken detention favours the individual, and that lack of bad faith is irrelevant to the existence of the wrong (at [140]).2 On the passages cited here, the Justices divided over what s 189 authorised, not over whether authority is the test. The decision is therefore authority about a particular statute, not for the proposition that a detention following a later-quashed decision is lawful.

Statutory authority: New South Wales

Section 99(1) of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW) lets a police officer arrest without a warrant if the officer suspects on reasonable grounds that the person is committing or has committed an offence, and is satisfied that the arrest is reasonably necessary for one or more listed reasons, such as to stop the person committing or repeating the offence or to ensure the person appears before a court. It does not authorise arrest for an offence for which the person has already been tried (s 99(5)). The arresting officer or another officer must take the arrested person before an authorised officer as soon as reasonably practicable (s 99(3)), but s 105 allows a police officer to discontinue an arrest at any time, despite that obligation. In New South Wales v Robinson [2019] HCA 46, Bell, Gageler, Gordon and Edelman JJ held that an officer arresting under s 99 must intend at the time to take the person before an authorised officer to answer a charge, and that an arrest made without that intention is unlawful (at [114]-[116]); Kiefel CJ, Keane and Nettle JJ would have allowed the appeal, holding that the officer need not have determined at the time of arrest that the person will definitely be charged.7

A person who is not a police officer has a differently framed power. Under s 100(1) the person may arrest without a warrant only if the other person is in the act of committing an offence under any Act or statutory instrument, has just committed one, or has committed a serious indictable offence for which the person has not been tried, and must likewise take the person before an authorised officer as soon as reasonably practicable (s 100(2)).5 Each power has conditions, so a defendant relying on one is put to showing that they were met.

Consequences and civil liability legislation

Liability does not depend on proof of loss, but compensatory damages do. In Lewis, the Sentence Administration Board’s decision to cancel the plaintiff’s periodic detention was invalid for want of procedural fairness, and he was imprisoned full-time for 82 days. The High Court dismissed his appeal against an award of nominal damages only. Gageler J held that he had no entitlement to compensatory damages because he would likely have been lawfully imprisoned for the same period (at [21]). Gordon J put the distinction this way: “No counterfactual can or should be used to determine liability”, but when assessing compensatory damages “some counterfactual analysis is necessary” (at [50]). The measure of damages is dealt with in Tort: damages.

In New South Wales, s 3B(1)(a) of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) provides that the Act does not apply to civil liability “in respect of an intentional act that is done by the person with intent to cause injury or death or that is sexual assault or other sexual misconduct committed by the person”, except for the listed provisions, which still apply.6 The exclusion is defined by the defendant’s intent to cause injury or death, or by sexual assault or other sexual misconduct, not by whether the tort is a trespass. A detention is not within the first limb merely because it was intentional, since that limb requires intent to cause injury or death; the separate sexual-misconduct limb would also have to be considered. Whether any provision of the Act then applies depends on that provision’s own terms, which are not examined here. The paragraph is not confined to the person who personally did the act: in AA v The Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle [2026] HCA 2, the joint reasons of Gageler CJ, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ recorded as unchallenged New South Wales authority that it treats a person’s vicarious liability for another’s intentional act as the same liability (at [133]-[134]).9 The civil liability Acts of the other jurisdictions are not stated here.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify each period and means of confinement separately, and who caused it. Ruddock v Taylor involved two periods of detention and Lewis one of 82 days.
  2. Ask what the plaintiff was free to do, including on what terms the plaintiff came to the place. Do not treat every obstruction as imprisonment without testing it against those terms.
  3. Once detention is made out, put the onus on the defendant to show lawful authority, as Gageler J said in Lewis and Fullagar J in Trobridge v Hardy, each for himself. Do not require the plaintiff to prove malice or the absence of reasonable cause unless a statute protecting the defendant requires it, as the statute in Trobridge v Hardy did.
  4. Identify the defendant’s status and the statute relied on. In New South Wales, compare s 99 (police) with s 100 (others) of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002, and check each condition, including, for police, the arresting officer’s intention at the time of arrest as stated in New South Wales v Robinson (a four-Justice majority). In any other jurisdiction, find the equivalent provision rather than assuming it.
  5. Keep the lawfulness of any earlier decision apart from the lawfulness of the detention, and ask what the particular statute authorised. Treat Ruddock v Taylor as a decision on s 189 as it then stood, in which two Justices dissented.
  6. If liability is made out, state that the tort is complete without loss, then ask whether compensatory damages are available, bearing in mind Lewis.

Self-check

  • Have I identified the detention and then asked for the defendant’s lawful authority, rather than asking the plaintiff to prove unlawfulness?
  • Have I distinguished an unlawful decision behind a detention from an unlawful detention?
  • Have I stated which jurisdiction’s arrest statute I am applying, and checked its conditions?
  • Have I kept liability, which needs no loss, apart from compensatory damages, which do?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.