Defences

Contributory negligence and apportionment, voluntary assumption of risk, obvious risk and dangerous recreational activity, illegality, and the defences to intentional torts.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, qld, wa, sa, tas, nt, act
Subjects
torts
Topics
tort-defences

Learning outcomes

  • Apply apportionment for contributory negligence, including the statutory power to reduce damages entirely.
  • Distinguish voluntary assumption of risk from the statutory obvious risk provisions.
  • Identify the defences available to the intentional torts and who bears the onus.

Defences are generally pleaded and proved by the defendant, although a statutory presumption can place a rebuttal burden on the plaintiff. In negligence they mostly reduce damages; a few defeat the claim. In the intentional torts they are usually the whole contest, because the elements of the tort are easily made out.

Contributory negligence

The plaintiff failed to take reasonable care for their own safety, and that failure contributed to the harm. The standard mirrors the defendant’s: what a reasonable person in the plaintiff’s position would have done, judged prospectively, with the statutory principles applied in the same way as to a defendant’s negligence.

At common law contributory negligence was a complete defence. Apportionment legislation in every State and Territory replaced that with a reduction of damages. Most of the Acts set the reduction at the extent the court thinks just and equitable having regard to the plaintiff’s share in the responsibility, but the wording is not uniform (Western Australia’s Act, for example, refers to the extent the court thinks just in accordance with the degree of negligence attributable to the plaintiff), so the provision of the jurisdiction in question should be read. The apportionment reflects both the relative culpability of each party and the causal potency of their conduct, per Joslyn v Berryman (2003) 214 CLR 552.1

Most jurisdictions now allow a reduction of 100 per cent where the court considers it just and equitable — restoring, in an extreme case, the effect of the old complete defence. Statutory presumptions of contributory negligence also apply in several jurisdictions where the plaintiff was intoxicated or relied on the skill of a person they knew to be intoxicated.

For a New South Wales motor accident, the statute requires the finding where an injured voluntary passenger (not being a minor) was aware, or ought to have been aware, that the driver’s ability to drive was impaired by alcohol or another drug, unless in the circumstances the passenger could not reasonably be expected to have declined to become a passenger. That is s 138(2)(b) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW)2 and, in the same terms, s 4.17(2)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW).3 Joslyn was decided under s 74(2)(b) of the Motor Accidents Act 1988 (NSW), which the 1999 Act’s s 138 is marked as corresponding to (“cf s 74 MAA”); s 4.17 is marked “cf s 138 MACA”. The change from one provision to the next is legislative succession, with the date of the accident deciding which Act applies, and not judicial disapproval of Joslyn.

Voluntary assumption of risk

A complete defence, and a narrow one. Absent statutory modification, the defendant must prove the plaintiff knew of and fully appreciated the specific risk and freely accepted it. Mere knowledge of a general danger, or continuing with an activity, is not enough. Because knowledge and voluntary acceptance are difficult to establish, the defence rarely succeeds on its own, and the statutory obvious risk provisions below modify and supplement it.

Obvious risk and dangerous recreational activities

The statutes are the practical route. In broad terms, and with real variation between jurisdictions:

  • A plaintiff is presumed to have been aware of an obvious risk unless they prove otherwise, which converts the hardest element of voluntary assumption of risk into a presumption operating in the defendant’s favour.
  • There is generally no duty to warn of an obvious risk, subject to exceptions.
  • A defendant is not liable for harm suffered from the materialisation of an obvious risk of a dangerous recreational activity engaged in by the plaintiff. This is a powerful provision: it operates whether or not the plaintiff was aware of the risk, and it can defeat an otherwise sound claim outright.

What counts as a dangerous recreational activity, and how narrowly the risk is characterised, is where these cases are won and lost, and the answers differ across jurisdictions.

Illegality

There is no general rule that a criminal cannot sue. The principle operates through coherence: a duty is denied, or a defence allowed, where recognising the claim would be inconsistent with the purpose of the criminal law — most clearly where the parties were engaged in a joint criminal enterprise and the injury arose out of it. Several jurisdictions have statutory provisions denying or limiting damages where the harm occurred during the commission of a serious offence.

Defences to the intentional torts

  • Consent — the plaintiff consented to the contact or entry. Consent obtained by fraud as to the nature of the act, or exceeded in scope, is no consent. Capacity to consent is its own enquiry, and for medical treatment it is governed by statute in part.
  • Self-defence and defence of another — the response must be necessary and reasonable, and the test is framed differently across jurisdictions. In New South Wales, for example, the defendant must believe the conduct necessary for a protective purpose and the conduct must be a reasonable response in the circumstances as the defendant perceives them (Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 52(2)).
  • Defence of property — reasonable protective force may be justified, subject to jurisdiction-specific restrictions; in New South Wales, for example, s 52(3) excludes force involving the intentional or reckless infliction of death only to protect property or to prevent or remove a criminal trespasser.
  • Necessity — an emergency justifying what would otherwise be a trespass, judged objectively and narrowly.
  • Lawful authority — a justification arising under legislation (the arrest, detention and search powers of the jurisdiction, and their conditions) or under common law powers that survive. Identify the particular power and its conditions.

Limitation periods

An action must be brought within the statutory limitation period, which is not a defence to the merits but ends the claim just as effectively. Periods differ by cause of action and by jurisdiction, personal injury regimes commonly run from the date of discoverability rather than the date of injury, extension powers exist, and several jurisdictions have removed limitation periods altogether for claims arising from child sexual abuse. Check the jurisdiction’s Act; nothing here is safely generalised.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Deal with the elements of the tort first. Some matters conventionally discussed as defences, such as voluntary assumption of risk and the statutory absence of a duty to warn of an obvious risk, negate an element or exclude a duty rather than answer a completed cause of action.
  2. Take the statutory defences before the common law ones — obvious risk and dangerous recreational activity usually decide recreational injury cases.
  3. For contributory negligence, identify the specific failure of care, then apportion, giving reasons for the percentage.
  4. Keep complete defences separate from reductions in damages, and state which you are arguing.
  5. Identify the burden on each issue: it is generally the defendant’s, but a statutory presumption, such as the presumption of awareness of an obvious risk, can place a rebuttal burden on the plaintiff.

Where the authority sits

Apportionment legislation and the civil liability statute of each jurisdiction, read with the common law they modify. The differences between jurisdictions here are larger than anywhere else in tort law, so a defence must be stated for a nominated jurisdiction.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.