Robertson v The Balmain New Ferry Company Ltd

Judicial Committee of the Privy Council · 1909

TortsIntentional Torts

Robertson v The Balmain New Ferry Company Ltd [1909] UKPC 1; [1910] AC 295

A ferry passenger changed his mind after entering a wharf, refused the penny required to return through its turnstile, and was stopped by force. Was that false imprisonment?

What happened?

Mr Robertson paid a penny to enter the Balmain New Ferry Company’s wharf, stay until its boat started, and travel by ferry to the other side. The company remained ready and willing to carry him. He changed his mind and wanted to return through the turnstile, for which the rules required another penny. He refused to pay it and was prevented by force from passing through the turnstile (judgment of the Lord Chancellor).

Mr Robertson claimed damages for assault and false imprisonment. No issue of excessive violence was left to the jury at his request (judgment of the Lord Chancellor).

What did the Court decide?

The Committee agreed with the High Court’s conclusion and held that there was no false imprisonment. It advised that Mr Robertson’s appeal be dismissed with costs (judgment of the Lord Chancellor).

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

The Lord Chancellor, delivering the judgment of the Committee, reasoned that Mr Robertson had contracted to leave the wharf by ferry and that the company was ready to perform that contract. The parties had not agreed on terms for a return through the turnstile because neither had contemplated it. When he chose that route, the company could impose a reasonable condition before allowing him to pass; payment of a penny was a fair condition, and he could still take the ferry journey for which he had paid.

Why does this case matter?

A gate or turnstile can make a false-imprisonment problem look simpler than it is. A strong answer identifies the route the claimant was prevented from taking and tests it against the transaction that brought the claimant to the place.

Exam and application relevance

Use the case to examine a dispute about leaving private premises after a person changes their plans. What significance did the Committee give to the transaction on entry and the later request to return through the turnstile?

Which features of the original transaction limit the decision’s application to other restrictions on leaving premises?

Check your understanding

1. What journey had Mr Robertson paid for, and what route did he later try to take?

2. Why had the parties not agreed on terms for returning through the turnstile?

3. How did the Committee assess the penny required for return through the turnstile, and which facts supported that assessment?