The exclusionary discretions: ss 135, 137 and 138
Where the discretions sit after relevance and admissibility, the five differences between the general discretion in s 135 and the mandatory exclusion in s 137, the reversed default in s 138, and the fourth s 135 ground that exists only in Victoria.
Learning outcomes
- Place the discretions after relevance under s 55 and admissibility under s 56.
- State the five differences between ss 135 and 137.
- Distinguish unfair prejudice from evidence that is merely damaging.
- Apply s 138 as a reversed-default provision: improperly obtained evidence is excluded unless admission is shown to be desirable.
- Name the governing Act before listing the s 135 grounds, because Victoria has a fourth ground the other Acts do not.
Relevant evidence is admissible unless the Act provides otherwise, and the discretions are the most general way it does provide otherwise. They operate after the admissibility rules are satisfied, so an answer that concludes evidence is admissible under an exception has not finished: the question is then whether it should nonetheless be excluded.
This article states the position under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Sections 55, 56, 137 and 138 are enacted to the same effect, under the same numbers, in New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory. Section 135 is not the same rule in all of them — Victoria has a ground the others do not — and that divergence is set out below.5
Where the discretions sit
Section 55(1) defines relevant evidence as evidence that, if accepted, could rationally affect (directly or indirectly) the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue; s 56 then provides that relevant evidence is admissible except as otherwise provided by this Act, and irrelevant evidence is not.1
The discretions are part of that “except”. They presuppose relevance and presuppose that no exclusionary rule has already disposed of the evidence.
Section 135: the general discretion
The court may refuse to admit evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger that the evidence might be unfairly prejudicial to a party, be misleading or confusing, or cause or result in undue waste of time.2
Three features decide most answers. It is a discretion — “may”. The threshold is substantially outweighed, not merely outweighed. And it is available in civil and criminal proceedings to which the governing Act applies, to any party, on distinct grounds that should be argued separately rather than merged into a general complaint of unfairness.
Three grounds, except in Victoria, where there are four. The Commonwealth, New South Wales, Tasmanian, ACT and Northern Territory Acts stop at undue waste of time. The Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) adds a fourth ground: that the evidence might “unnecessarily demean the deceased in a criminal proceeding for a homicide offence” (s 135(d)). Victoria’s s 135 also carries a note that the section does not limit evidence of family violence that may be adduced under Part IC of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic). The section number is the same everywhere, so nothing on the face of a citation warns of the extra ground; an answer in a Victorian homicide trial that lists only three has left out one the court may act on.6
Section 137: the criminal mandatory exclusion
In a criminal proceeding the court must refuse to admit evidence adduced by the prosecutor if its probative value is outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant.3
Set the two side by side, because the differences are the examinable part:
| s 135 | s 137 | |
|---|---|---|
| Proceeding | civil or criminal, where the Act applies | criminal only |
| Whose evidence | any party’s | the prosecutor’s |
| Obligation | may refuse | must refuse |
| Threshold | substantially outweighed | outweighed |
| Danger | unfair prejudice, misleading or confusing, undue waste of time — and in Victoria, unnecessarily demeaning the deceased in a homicide proceeding | unfair prejudice to the defendant |
So s 137 is narrower in what it reaches and stronger in what it requires. Prosecution evidence in a criminal trial engages both, and the lower threshold in s 137 means it is usually the one argued.
Section 138: the one that runs the other way
Sections 135 and 137 ask whether evidence that is otherwise admissible should be kept out. Section 138 starts from the opposite end. Evidence obtained improperly or in contravention of an Australian law, or in consequence of such an impropriety or contravention, is not to be admitted unless the desirability of admitting it outweighs the undesirability of admitting evidence obtained in that way.4
The default is exclusion, and the party seeking admission carries the argument. That reversal is the single most important thing to say about s 138, and an answer that treats it as another balancing discretion in the same direction as s 135 has misread it.
What counts as improper is partly deemed, on conditions. Section 138(2) provides that evidence of an admission made during or in consequence of questioning, and evidence obtained in consequence of the admission, is taken to have been obtained improperly if the person conducting the questioning either did or omitted an act in the course of the questioning even though they knew or ought reasonably to have known it was likely to impair substantially the ability of the person being questioned to respond rationally; or made a false statement in the course of the questioning even though they knew or ought reasonably to have known both that it was false and that making it was likely to cause the person to make an admission. Note the two features that are easy to drop: the impairment under the first limb must be substantial, and in both limbs constructive knowledge — what the questioner ought reasonably to have known — is enough.
And the balance is structured. Section 138(3) lists eight matters the court is to take into account, among them the probative value and importance of the evidence, the nature of the offence or cause of action, the gravity of the impropriety, whether it was deliberate or reckless, whether it was contrary to a right recognised by the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and the difficulty of obtaining the evidence lawfully. Work the listed matters; do not assert a conclusion about desirability.
Note the breadth of the gateway: it is not confined to criminal proceedings, and it reaches evidence obtained in consequence of an impropriety, not only the impropriety’s immediate product.
“Unfair prejudice” is not “damaging”
Evidence that makes conviction more likely is not for that reason unfairly prejudicial — that is what probative evidence does. The danger this ground addresses is that the tribunal will use the evidence in some improper way, or give it more weight than it can rationally bear. An answer that treats “this is very damaging to the accused” as establishing unfair prejudice has not engaged with the section.
That point is about the unfair-prejudice ground, and it does not travel to the others. Misleading or confusing evidence, evidence that would cause undue waste of time, and — in Victoria — evidence that would unnecessarily demean the deceased in a homicide proceeding are each dangers in their own right, argued on their own terms. What every s 135 ground shares is not improper use but the threshold: the probative value of the evidence must be substantially outweighed by the danger.6
Applying this in a problem question
- Establish relevance under s 55 and admissibility under s 56 and the exclusionary rules first.
- Identify the proceeding and who is adducing the evidence; that decides whether s 137 is available at all.
- Ask how the evidence was obtained. If improperly or unlawfully, s 138 applies and the default is exclusion — work its eight listed matters rather than asserting desirability.
- State the probative value of the evidence on these facts, rather than asserting it.
- Name the statutory danger you are relying on and explain how it arises on the facts. If it is unfair prejudice, say why the danger is of the tribunal using the evidence improperly rather than of the evidence simply damaging a party’s case. If it is one of the other s 135 grounds, argue that ground on its own terms — how the evidence misleads or confuses, what time it would waste, or, in a Victorian homicide proceeding, how it would unnecessarily demean the deceased. Those grounds do not require a danger of improper use.
- Apply the right threshold — substantially outweighed under s 135, outweighed under s 137 — and note that s 137 is mandatory.
- Name the governing Act before listing the s 135 grounds, because Victoria has a fourth.
Self-check
- Can I state the five differences between ss 135 and 137 without looking?
- Do I know which way s 138 runs, and who has to make the argument under it?
- Do I argue probative value as a step, rather than assuming it?
- Can I explain why damaging evidence is not thereby unfairly prejudicial — and that the other s 135 grounds do not turn on improper use at all?
- Do I know which jurisdiction’s s 135 has a fourth ground, and what that ground is?
Where the authority sits
In the Commonwealth Act the discretions are in Part 3.11, “Discretionary and mandatory exclusions”, with relevance and the inclusionary rule in Part 3.1. Sections 55, 56, 137 and 138 are enacted to the same effect across the scheme, so the position stated above holds in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory; the differences in those four provisions are drafting ones — the ACT says “present” where the others say “adduce”, and Victoria’s s 137 protects “the accused” rather than “the defendant”. Section 135 is the exception, and it is a difference of substance: Victoria’s fourth ground has no counterpart in the other five Acts. Identify the court before stating the test. Queensland and South Australia have not enacted the uniform scheme for their own courts. Western Australia has enacted it but has not commenced it, and the two are different questions: the Evidence Act 2025 (WA) was assented to on 25 September 2025, but under its s 2 only Part 1 and s 384 are in operation and the substantive Parts commence on 18 September 2027. So in all three the exclusionary discretions are for now governed by the common law and those jurisdictions’ own statutes, and there is no operative Western Australian section number to cite.5