The exclusionary discretions: ss 135, 137 and 138

Where the discretions sit

Quick Read: before the discretions can apply, evidence must first clear two hurdles.

Section 55(1) says evidence is relevant if it could rationally affect the probability of a fact in issue. Section 56 says relevant evidence is admissible, unless the Act says otherwise.

The exclusionary discretions are part of that “unless”. They only come into play once evidence is already relevant, and no other rule has already excluded it.

Section 135: the general discretion

Section 135 gives courts a discretion to refuse evidence. “Discretion” means the court may choose, but does not have to.

The court can refuse evidence if its probative value (how much it helps prove something) is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, by the risk of misleading or confusing the court, or by undue waste of time. “Substantially outweighed” is a high bar — more than just outweighed.

This applies in both civil and criminal cases, to any party. Each ground should be argued on its own, not lumped together as general unfairness.

Most places list three grounds. Victoria has a fourth: evidence that might unnecessarily demean a deceased person in a homicide trial. Victoria’s version also notes it does not limit family violence evidence covered elsewhere.

The section number “135” is the same everywhere. So an answer naming only three grounds misses Victoria’s extra one.

Section 137: the criminal mandatory exclusion

Section 137 applies only in criminal proceedings. It says the court must refuse to admit evidence if the prosecutor relies on it, and its probative value (how much it helps prove something) is outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant.

This differs from s 135 in key ways. Section 135 applies in civil or criminal proceedings, to any party’s evidence, and only gives the court a discretion to refuse (it “may” refuse, not “must”). Section 135 also needs the danger to substantially outweigh the probative value, a higher bar than s 137’s plain “outweighed”.

Section 135 covers more types of danger too: unfair prejudice, misleading or confusing the jury, wasting time, and in Victoria, unnecessarily demeaning a deceased person in a homicide case. Section 137 only covers unfair prejudice to the defendant.

So s 137 is narrower in scope but stricter in effect. When the prosecution leads evidence in a criminal trial, both sections can apply. Because s 137’s threshold is lower, it is usually the one argued.

Section 138: the one that runs the other way

Section 138 works backwards compared to ss 135 and 137. Evidence obtained improperly, or in breach of an Australian law, is excluded by default. It only comes in if the desirability of admitting it outweighs the undesirability of how it was obtained.

This reversal matters. The party wanting the evidence admitted must make that case. Treating s 138 as just another balancing test like s 135 misreads it.

Section 138(2) deems certain conduct improper. If a person is questioned and makes an admission, that admission (and evidence got because of it) counts as improperly obtained in two situations. First, if the questioner did or failed to do something, knowing or reasonably ought to have known it was likely to substantially impair the person’s ability to respond rationally. Second, if the questioner made a false statement, knowing or reasonably ought to have known it was false and likely to cause an admission. Note two details: the impairment must be substantial, and in both cases it is enough that the questioner ought reasonably to have known, even without actual knowledge.

Section 138(3) lists eight factors courts must weigh in the balancing exercise. These include the probative value and importance of the evidence, the nature of the offence or cause of action, how serious the impropriety was, whether it was deliberate or reckless, whether it breached a right under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and how hard it would have been to get the evidence lawfully. Courts must work through these factors rather than just stating a conclusion.

The gateway is broad. It applies beyond criminal proceedings, and covers evidence obtained as a consequence of the impropriety, not just its direct product.

“Unfair prejudice” is not “damaging”

Evidence can be damaging without being unfairly prejudicial. Strong evidence often makes conviction more likely — that is simply what good evidence does.

Unfair prejudice is different. It means there is a danger the tribunal will misuse the evidence, or give it more weight than it deserves. Just saying “this hurts the accused” does not show that.

This point only applies to the unfair-prejudice ground under s 135. The other dangers — misleading or confusing evidence, wasting time, and (in Victoria) unnecessarily demeaning a deceased person in a homicide case — are separate dangers, argued on their own terms.

All s 135 grounds do share one thing: the same threshold. The evidence’s probative value must be substantially outweighed by the relevant danger.

Applying this in a problem question

Work through exclusionary discretions in order. First check relevance under s 55 and admissibility under s 56, and apply the exclusionary rules.

Next, identify the proceeding and who is adducing the evidence. This tells you whether s 137 is even available.

Then ask how the evidence was obtained. If it was improperly or unlawfully obtained, s 138 applies, and exclusion is the default. Work through its eight listed matters, rather than simply asserting the evidence is desirable.

State the probative value of the evidence based on the facts, rather than just asserting it.

Name the statutory danger you rely on and show how it arises on the facts. If it is unfair prejudice, explain why the danger is improper use of the evidence by the tribunal, not just damage to a party’s case. If it is another s 135 ground, argue that ground directly: how the evidence misleads, confuses, wastes time, or, in a Victorian homicide case, unnecessarily demeans the deceased. These other grounds do not need a risk of improper use.

Apply the correct threshold: substantially outweighed under s 135, or outweighed under s 137. Remember s 137 is mandatory.

Finally, name the governing Act before listing the s 135 grounds, since Victoria has an extra, fourth ground.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.