Northern Territory land rights: Land Trusts, traditional owners and the right to exclude

How the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth) allocates title, decision-making and consent: Land Trusts, Land Councils, traditional Aboriginal owners, the restrictions on dealings in Aboriginal land in s 19, and the right to exclude under s 70 as applied in Northern Territory v Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust (Blue Mud Bay).

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nt
Subjects
first-nations-and-australian-law
Topics
first-nations-law-and-native-title-framework

Learning outcomes

  • State who holds title to Aboriginal land under the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth), who directs the title-holder, and how the Act defines traditional Aboriginal owners.
  • Work through s 19 for a proposed grant, transfer or surrender of an interest in Aboriginal land, identifying the consents and directions required and the role of traditional owners’ consent in s 19(5).
  • Apply s 70 and Northern Territory v Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust to an entry onto Aboriginal land by water, attributing the holdings to the joint reasons and the separate reasons of Kirby, Heydon and Kiefel JJ correctly.

The Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth) grants land rather than recognising a surviving right, and the questions it raises are different from the ones native title raises. Before asking who may use a parcel of Aboriginal land, a student must ask three prior questions: who holds title, who decides what the title-holder does, and whose permission is needed to enter. The Act addresses each separately, and the High Court’s decision in the Blue Mud Bay litigation shows what follows when the answers meet a Territory fisheries licence. This article states the Commonwealth Act as it applies in the Northern Territory. It does not state the Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 (NSW), whose claim criteria are described in First Nations peoples and Australian law: an overview, or the Northern Territory’s own legislation, which is mentioned only where the High Court did.

Title sits in a Land Trust, and decisions sit with a Land Council

“Aboriginal land” is land held by a Land Trust for an estate in fee simple, or land the subject of a deed of grant held in escrow by a Land Council (s 3(1)).1 On receiving a recommendation under s 10, 11 or 11B, the Governor-General may execute a deed of grant of an estate in the land in accordance with the recommendation and deliver it to the grantee (s 12(1)(a)), in some cases only once a condition specified in the recommendation has been complied with (s 12(1)(aa)); in other cases the deed is instead delivered to a Land Council to be held in escrow (s 12(1)(b)). The Land Trust’s functions are to hold title and to exercise its powers as owner “for the benefit of the Aboriginals concerned” (s 5(1)(a)-(b)). It must not exercise its functions except in accordance with a direction from the Land Council for the area, and must act on a direction given (s 5(2)). Title and decision-making are therefore separated: the Land Trust holds the estate, and the Land Council directs it.

Traditional Aboriginal owners

The Act defines traditional Aboriginal owners, in relation to land, as a local descent group of Aboriginals who have common spiritual affiliations to a site on the land, being affiliations that place the group under a primary spiritual responsibility for that site and for the land, and who are entitled by Aboriginal tradition to forage as of right over that land (s 3(1)). The definition is of a local descent group with specified spiritual and foraging connections to a site and the land, and the Act gives that group a role where land is dealt with: a Land Council has functions of protecting the interests of traditional Aboriginal owners of, and other Aboriginals interested in, Aboriginal land, of consulting them on any proposal relating to the use of the land, and of negotiating on their behalf with persons wanting an estate or interest in it (s 23(1)(b), (c), (e)).2

Dealings with Aboriginal land

Section 19(1) provides that, except as provided by that section or s 19A or s 20, a Land Trust must not deal with or dispose of any estate or interest in land vested in it. The section then permits particular grants, each with the Minister’s written consent and at the Land Council’s written direction: to an Aboriginal or an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander corporation for residential, business or community purposes, on the conditions the subsection states (s 19(2)), to the Commonwealth, the Northern Territory or an Authority for a public purpose or to a mission for a mission purpose (s 19(3)), and to any person for any purpose (s 19(4A)). The Minister’s consent is not required for a grant under those subsections of an estate or interest whose term does not exceed 40 years (s 19(7)).

The consent of traditional owners enters through the Land Council’s direction. A Land Council must not give a direction for the grant, transfer or surrender of an estate or interest unless it is satisfied that the traditional Aboriginal owners (if any) of the land understand the nature and purpose of the proposal and, as a group, consent to it; that any other Aboriginal community or group that may be affected has been consulted and has had adequate opportunity to express its view to the Land Council; and, for a grant, that its terms and conditions are reasonable (s 19(5)). A failure to comply with s 19(5) does not invalidate the grant, transfer or surrender unless the person to whom it was made procured the direction by fraud (s 19(6)). On the text, then, the traditional owners’ consent is something of which the Land Council must be satisfied before it gives a direction, and a failure to comply does not of itself invalidate the dealing.

The right to exclude: the Blue Mud Bay decision

Section 70(1) provides that a person shall not enter or remain on Aboriginal land, with a penalty of 50 penalty units. Section 70(2A) lists defences, which include entering or remaining “in accordance with this Act or a law of the Northern Territory” (s 70(2A)(h)); s 70(2B) adds entry under a Land Trust’s authorisation given under s 19(13).3 Subject to s 71, an Aboriginal or a group of Aboriginals is entitled to enter upon Aboriginal land and use or occupy it to the extent that this is in accordance with Aboriginal tradition governing their rights with respect to that land (s 71(1)). Section 73(1)(b) extends the Northern Territory Legislative Assembly’s power to laws regulating or authorising entry on Aboriginal land, but so that any such laws provide for the right of Aboriginals to enter in accordance with Aboriginal tradition.

Northern Territory v Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust [2008] HCA 29 asked whether a person holding a licence under the Fisheries Act (NT) could fish, without the Land Trust’s permission, in tidal waters within the boundaries of grants to the Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust, which extended to low water mark.4 The joint reasons of Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne and Crennan JJ reached these conclusions:

  1. Fishing in those waters is to “enter or remain on Aboriginal land”. The grants were defined by metes and bounds, so s 70(1) applies “without regard to whether the tide is in or out” (at [55]), and “Aboriginal land” extends to so much of the water above the land surface within the grant’s boundaries as is ordinarily capable of use by an owner of land (at [58]).
  2. The grant of an estate described as a fee simple is a grant of rights that include the right to exclude others from the area, subject to any relevant common law qualification or statutory provision to the contrary (at [50]).
  3. The common law public right to fish in tidal waters had been abrogated by necessary implication by ss 10 and 11 of the Fisheries Act (at [27]), and neither that Act nor a licence under it confers permission to enter any particular place to fish (at [33], [36]).
  4. Holding a Fisheries Act licence does not make an entry one made in accordance with “a law of the Northern Territory” within the defence the Court applied, which now appears in s 70(2A)(h); permission given by a Land Council under the Aboriginal Land Act (NT) would (at [8], [61]).

The orders declared that ss 10 and 11 of the Fisheries Act do not confer power to grant a licence that would, without more, authorise the holder to enter and take fish from areas within the grants. Kirby J agreed in the orders and, generally, in the joint reasons (at [63]). Heydon J and Kiefel J dissented. Heydon J held that only the soil down to low water mark was Aboriginal land and would have restored the trial order dismissing the application (at [101], [109]); Kiefel J held that the Land Rights Act does not give the Land Trust control over entry onto intertidal waters or fishing in them (at [160], [162]). The Court also limited its decision: it was “neither necessary nor productive” to define exhaustively the rights the grants confer over the intertidal zone when covered by water (at [53]), and it is not to be supposed that the grants give a proprietary interest in any particular column of water (at [52]). The decision concerns the construction of s 70(1) and the Fisheries Act (NT); it does not state the full extent of ownership of tidal waters.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Establish that the land is Aboriginal land under s 3(1): held by a Land Trust in fee simple, or held in escrow by a Land Council. If it is not Aboriginal land, the s 70(1) prohibition does not apply on that basis; other provisions of the Act, such as s 69 on sacred sites, may still apply.
  2. Identify who holds title (the Land Trust) and who directs it (the Land Council under s 5(2)), and check the Land Trust is not acting alone.
  3. For a proposed grant, transfer or surrender, work through s 19: the permitted category, the Minister’s consent (which s 19(7) removes for a grant under s 19(2), (3) or (4A) of a term not exceeding 40 years), the Land Council’s written direction, and the s 19(5) conditions, including the traditional owners’ understanding and group consent.
  4. For an entry, start with the s 70(1) prohibition, then the s 70(2A) and (2B) defences and the Aboriginal tradition entitlement in s 71(1); where the entry is by water within the boundaries of a grant, apply Northern Territory v Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust, and state that a Territory fishing licence alone does not authorise entry.
  5. State the limits: the Act applies to the Northern Territory, s 19(6) preserves a dealing despite a non-complying direction unless the direction was procured by fraud, and the Court in the Blue Mud Bay decision left open the full extent of rights over the intertidal zone.

Self-check

  • Have I distinguished the Land Trust that holds title from the Land Council that directs it?
  • Have I quoted the statutory definition of traditional Aboriginal owners rather than treating it as anyone with a connection to the land?
  • Have I treated the traditional owners’ consent as a condition of the Land Council’s direction under s 19(5), and noted s 19(6)?
  • Have I attributed the Blue Mud Bay holdings to the joint reasons, with Kirby J agreeing and Heydon J and Kiefel J dissenting?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.