Protection of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultural heritage
How Australian cultural heritage statutes protect Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander places and objects: each State and Territory prohibits harm to a differently defined subject matter, usually grading liability by the actor’s state of mind, lifts the prohibition by permit, management plan, agreement, certificate or ministerial consent, and imposes duties that operate before any harm, while the Commonwealth Act protects an area or object only by declaration on an Aboriginal applicant’s application.
Learning outcomes
- Identify the cultural heritage Act in force in a given Australian jurisdiction and characterise the thing harmed against that Act’s own definition of the protected subject matter.
- Distinguish the tiers of a graded harm offence, and identify where a scheme imposes strict liability or shifts the onus onto the defendant.
- Identify the instrument that authorises harm in a given jurisdiction and explain why exceeding its conditions removes the protection.
- Explain how the duties that operate before harm - a mandatory management plan, a cultural heritage duty of care, a due diligence standard, a reporting obligation - differ between jurisdictions, and when the Commonwealth declaration power is engaged.
Australian cultural heritage legislation controls what a landholder, a developer or anyone else may lawfully do to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander places and objects. Before asking whether a particular act was lawful, a student must ask a prior question: which Act applies? Protection is overwhelmingly State and Territory statute law, and each jurisdiction defines its own protected subject matter, offences and authorising instruments, while the Commonwealth Act works on an application by an Aboriginal person or group rather than as a general prohibition on harm. The answer to that prior question settles what the elements are, who carries the burden, and whether anything short of a permit protects the person who did the harm.
What each Act protects
The protected subject matter differs between jurisdictions, and that definition supplies the first element of each offence stated here.
| Jurisdiction | Act | Protected subject matter |
|---|---|---|
| NSW | National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 | Aboriginal object; Aboriginal place3 |
| Vic | Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006 | Aboriginal cultural heritage5 |
| Qld | Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act 2003 | Aboriginal cultural heritage7 |
| WA | Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 | Aboriginal site; objects on or under one8 |
| SA | Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 | Aboriginal site, object or remains9 |
| Tas | Aboriginal Heritage Act 1975 | Relic10 |
| NT | Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989 | Sacred site11 |
| ACT | Heritage Act 2004 | Aboriginal place or object12 |
Registration generally raises the stakes rather than creating the protection. In Queensland the maximum penalty for an individual is higher, and includes imprisonment, where the heritage harmed is a registered significant area or registered significant object, but the prohibition is not confined to registered heritage.
The prohibition on harm, and how fault is graded
Every one of these Acts makes harm to the protected subject matter an offence, and most grade liability by the actor’s state of mind rather than treating all harm alike. Victoria is the clearest example: s 27 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006 (Vic) creates three indictable offences of harming Aboriginal cultural heritage, descending from knowledge that the act or omission was likely to harm it, through recklessness, to negligence, with the maximum penalty falling at each step; s 28 adds a separate and much lower prohibition on doing an act that harms or is likely to harm Aboriginal cultural heritage5. The Heritage Act 2004 (ACT) is built the same way, with a reckless offence, a negligent offence and a strict liability offence for conduct causing damage, where causing damage includes disturbing and destroying12.
The lowest tier of a graded scheme is where a student is most likely to go wrong, because the knowledge requirement in the headline offence is not the standard that decides the case. In New South Wales, s 86(1) of the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 requires knowledge that the object is an Aboriginal object, but harming an Aboriginal object and harming or desecrating an Aboriginal place are offences of strict liability to which the defence of honest and reasonable mistake of fact applies; and if the court is satisfied the accused did not know the object was an Aboriginal object, it may still find the strict liability offence proved3. South Australia and Tasmania use the same two-tier shape, and in South Australia it falls to the defendant on the lesser offence to prove that they did not know, and could not reasonably have been expected to know, what the site, object or remains was910.
Three jurisdictions place the question somewhere other than in a tier of offences. Queensland builds a reasonableness standard into the offence itself, prohibiting harm where the person knows or ought reasonably to know that it is Aboriginal cultural heritage7. Western Australia’s s 17 states a single offence of excavating, destroying, damaging, concealing or in any way altering an Aboriginal site, committed unless the person acts with the Registrar’s authorisation or a ministerial consent8. In the Northern Territory it is an offence to carry out work on or use a sacred site, and ignorance operates as a defence rather than as a missing element: the defendant must prove no reasonable grounds for suspecting that the sacred site was a sacred site11.
What makes harm lawful
In each of the schemes set out below an instrument lifts the prohibition, and two things about it are common ground: the instrument must cover the heritage actually harmed, and its conditions must have been complied with. An authorisation exceeded protects nobody — New South Wales states that expressly, making it a defence that the harm was authorised by an Aboriginal heritage impact permit and that the permit’s conditions were not contravened4. The authorisation route under the Heritage Act 2004 (ACT) is not stated here.
| Jurisdiction | Authorising instrument | Decided by |
|---|---|---|
| NSW | Aboriginal heritage impact permit | The Secretary4 |
| Vic | Cultural heritage permit, approved management plan, or land management agreement | Permit granted or plan approved under the Act; agreement entered into under the Act5 |
| Qld | A cultural heritage management plan, or a native title agreement or another agreement with an Aboriginal party | Different mechanisms: the plan must be approved under the Act; the agreement need not be, the person must be acting under it, and the heritage must not be expressly excluded from being subject to it7 |
| WA | Ministerial consent to use the land | The Minister, on the Committee’s recommendation8 |
| SA | Ministerial authorisation | The Minister9 |
| Tas | Permit | The Minister, on the Director’s recommendation10 |
| NT | Authority Certificate | The Authority11 |
Two of these schemes reach past instruments. Victoria’s s 29 also permits harm where a person acts in accordance with Aboriginal tradition as it relates to the heritage, in the course of preparing a plan or agreement, out of emergency necessity, or as a coroner determining whether human remains are Aboriginal ancestral remains5. Queensland’s equivalent list includes ownership of the heritage, acting with the owner’s agreement, and emergency necessity7. Queensland’s agreement route is also worth separating from its plan route, because the two are not approved the same way. Under s 24(2)(a)(ii) the exception for a cultural heritage management plan requires an approved plan that applies to the heritage; under s 24(2)(a)(iii) the exception for “a native title agreement or another agreement with an Aboriginal party” requires no approval under the Act at all — the person must be acting under the agreement, and the exception is lost where the heritage “is expressly excluded from being subject to the agreement”. The same split runs through the duty-of-care provision, s 23(3).
Two also build Aboriginal participation into the decision. In the Northern Territory the Authority may issue a certificate only where satisfied that the work could proceed without substantive risk of damage to or interference with a sacred site, or that an agreement has been reached between the custodians and the applicant, and the certificate’s conditions must accord with the custodians’ wishes or with that agreement11. In Western Australia the process starts with the owner of the land — which includes a lessee from the Crown and the holder of a mining tenement — notifying the Committee, which evaluates the importance and significance of any site and recommends; the Minister then, having regard to the general interest of the community, either consents on conditions or wholly declines, and an owner or a native title party aggrieved by that decision may seek review in the State Administrative Tribunal8.
The duties that bite before any harm
Several schemes impose obligations in advance, and these produce most of the compliance work. In Victoria a cultural heritage management plan is an assessment of an area to determine the nature of any Aboriginal cultural heritage in it, plus a written report setting out the results and the conditions to be complied with before, during and after an activity; that report is the plan. A plan is mandatory in defined cases, including where the regulations require one or the Minister directs one, and commencing such an activity without an approved plan is itself an offence graded by knowledge, recklessness and negligence6.
Queensland instead imposes a general cultural heritage duty of care: a person who carries out an activity must take all reasonable and practicable measures to ensure the activity does not harm Aboriginal cultural heritage. The Act lists what a court may consider on that question — including the extent of consultation with Aboriginal parties and its results, whether a study or survey was done, and whether the database and register were searched — and deems the duty complied with where the person acts in compliance with ministerial duty of care guidelines7. New South Wales does comparable work through a due diligence defence to the strict liability object offence, available where the defendant exercised due diligence and reasonably determined that no Aboriginal object would be harmed4. In the Australian Capital Territory the advance duty is a reporting one, and it is strict: a person who discovers an Aboriginal place or object and has reasonable grounds to believe it is one commits a strict liability offence by failing to take reasonable steps to report it to the council12.
When the Commonwealth Act matters
The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 (Cth) does not prohibit harm generally. It empowers the Minister, on an application made orally or in writing by or on behalf of an Aboriginal or a group of Aboriginals, to protect a significant Aboriginal area or object by declaration made by legislative instrument. An emergency declaration under s 9 requires satisfaction that the area is under serious and immediate threat of injury or desecration and lasts no more than 30 days, extendable but not beyond 60 days from when it took effect. A declaration under s 10 requires a threat, a report from a nominated person, and public notice inviting representations, which the Minister must consider1.
Two features explain why a student should reach for the State or Territory Act first. The Commonwealth Act is not intended to exclude or limit a State or Territory law capable of operating concurrently with it, and where one act or omission offends both, the person may be prosecuted under either but cannot be punished twice for it. And the s 10 report must deal expressly with the extent to which the area is or may be protected under a State or Territory law, and with the effectiveness of the remedies available there2.
Where the authority sits
Each of these Acts is the law of its own jurisdiction, so a provision stated here is authority in that jurisdiction and section numbers do not transfer between them. The shared structure — a prohibition on harm, lifted by an authorising instrument, supported by duties that operate before any harm occurs — is a reliable map, but the elements, the fault required and the onus are all set by the Act in force where the land, object or remains is situated.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the jurisdiction in which the land, object or remains is situated, and name that jurisdiction’s Act before stating any rule.
- Characterise the thing said to be protected against that Act’s own definition — object, place, site, relic, sacred site or cultural heritage.
- State the conduct precisely, and check the Act reaches it: harm, desecration, damage, disturbance, alteration, removal, concealment, or merely carrying out work.
- Work out which offence fits the actor’s state of mind, and check whether the lowest tier is strict liability or shifts the onus onto the defendant.
- Ask which authorising instrument was in force, whether it covered this heritage, and whether its conditions were complied with.
- Only then consider any duty engaged before the harm, and whether a Commonwealth declaration was sought or made.
Self-check
- Have I named the jurisdiction’s own Act rather than assuming a national rule?
- Have I matched the facts to that Act’s definition of the protected subject matter?
- Have I identified which tier of offence applies, and whether it requires knowledge, recklessness, negligence or nothing at all?
- Have I distinguished an exception that defeats the offence from a defence the defendant must prove?