Real property and personal property

The foundational distinction between real property and personal property, and between rights in rem and rights in personam, that organises the rest of Australian property law.

Learning level
Foundation
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, qld, wa, sa, tas, nt, act
Subjects
property
Topics
property-concepts

Learning outcomes

  • Classify a given item of property as real or personal, and explain what turns on that classification.
  • Distinguish a right in rem from a right in personam and identify which remedies follow from each.
  • Distinguish a chose in possession from a chose in action within the category of personal property.

Property law organises everything a person can own around two structural distinctions: what is owned, and what kind of right is held in it. Understanding both distinctions before studying any specific doctrine — possession, title, registration, leases, mortgages, or personal property security — makes the rest of the subject far easier to place.

Real property and personal property

Real property is, broadly, land and the interests recognised in land: the fee simple, leasehold interests, easements, mortgages over land, and other estates and interests that attach to a defined parcel. The term reflects the old common-law action for the recovery of land itself (a “real” action), rather than mere damages.

Personal property is everything else capable of being owned: chattels such as vehicles, livestock, art and equipment, and intangible property such as debts, shares, intellectual property and other choses in action. The two labels come from the old forms of action: claims to chattels were brought in personal actions such as detinue and conversion, and in detinue the common law let the defendant keep the chattel and pay its value instead of returning it.

The distinction still matters practically. Real property transactions are governed by jurisdiction-specific conveyancing and land title legislation, attract particular formality requirements, and are usually recorded on a public register. Personal property has no single unifying registration system, although the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) now provides one national register for security interests over it.1 Limitation periods, formality rules for transfer, and the remedies available for interference commonly differ between the two categories.

Choses in possession and choses in action

Personal property itself divides further. A chose in possession is a tangible item that can be physically held — a car, a painting, a flock of sheep. A chose in action is an intangible right that can only be enforced by legal action rather than by taking physical possession — a debt, a cheque, shares in a company, a right under a contract, or intellectual property. Choses in action are commonly transferred by assignment rather than by delivery, and the rules governing assignment (including whether notice to a debtor is required) differ from the rules governing transfer of a chose in possession. Negotiable instruments such as cheques have rules of their own: they can be transferred by delivery, or by indorsement and delivery.

Rights in rem and rights in personam

The second foundational distinction cuts across the first. A right in rem is a right in a thing itself, good against the world (or at least against a very wide class of people) — ownership and possessory rights are the paradigm examples. A right in personam is a right against a specific person, arising from a personal obligation such as a contract or a tort, and enforceable only against that person or their estate.

The distinction explains why property law and the law of obligations produce different remedies. A right in rem can found an action against a third party who never dealt with the rights-holder at all — for example, an owner entitled to immediate possession can seek to recover a chattel from a third-party holder whose own possessory entitlement is inferior, not only from the person who took it. A right in personam cannot: it ordinarily binds only the parties. A stranger is not bound merely because the right exists; something further is needed, such as their own undertaking to honour the interest, which is how a registered proprietor can come under a personal obligation despite registration (under the Torrens statutes, mere notice of an unregistered interest does not by itself create one). That is where equity’s in personam exceptions to registered title become important. Many disputes in property law turn on correctly characterising an interest as one or the other, particularly when an interest has not been registered or perfected in the way the relevant statutory scheme requires.

Why this distinction organises the rest of the subject

Every later topic in this module builds on this orientation. Possession and title both ask what quality of right a person holds, independently of formal registration. Torrens legislation governs the registration of titles and interests in land, and the Personal Property Securities Act governs security interests in personal property, including their perfection (which does not always involve registration) and priority; each has its own rules for how an unregistered or unperfected interest fares against others. Leases and mortgages are themselves examples of proprietary interests that must be distinguished from the merely personal (a licence, an unsecured debt) using exactly the in rem/in personam distinction developed here.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify whether the property in dispute is real property (land and interests in land) or personal property (chattels or choses in action).
  2. If personal property, decide whether it is a chose in possession or a chose in action, since the rules for transfer and enforcement differ.
  3. Characterise the right asserted as in rem or in personam, and explain what that classification means for who can be sued and what remedy is available.
  4. Identify whether a registration or perfection scheme applies to the interest in question, and if so, whether the interest has been registered or perfected.
  5. Only then move to the specific doctrine (possession, title, leases, mortgages, or security interests) that governs the dispute.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.