Real property and personal property
Real property and personal property
Real property means land and the legal interests attached to it. This includes the fee simple (full ownership), leases, easements and mortgages over land. The name comes from old “real” actions, where courts could order the actual land returned.
Personal property is everything else you can own. This includes physical things like vehicles and art, plus intangible property like debts, shares and intellectual property. These claims used personal actions like detinue and conversion; under detinue, a defendant could keep the item and just pay its value.
The difference still matters today. Real property deals follow specific state land laws, need particular formalities, and are usually recorded on a public register.
Personal property has no single registration system generally. However, the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) now provides one national register for security interests over personal property. Time limits, transfer rules and available remedies often differ between real and personal property.
Choses in possession and choses in action
Personal property splits into two types. A chose in possession is something physical you can hold, like a car or a painting. A chose in action is a right that is intangible. You can only enforce it through legal action, not by holding it, like a debt or shares.
These two types transfer differently. Choses in action are usually transferred by assignment, not delivery. The rules for assignment can differ, including whether you must notify a debtor.
Negotiable instruments like cheques have their own rules. They can transfer by delivery alone, or by indorsement plus delivery.
Rights in rem and rights in personam
There’s a second key distinction, separate from the first one. A right in rem is a right in a thing itself. It’s good against the world, or at least a very wide class of people. Ownership and possessory rights are examples.
A right in personam is different. It’s a right against a specific person, arising from a personal obligation like a contract or a tort. It can only be enforced against that person or their estate.
This distinction explains why property law and the law of obligations give different remedies. A right in rem lets you sue a third party who never dealt with you at all. For example, an owner entitled to immediate possession can recover a chattel from a third-party holder whose own possessory claim is weaker, not just from the original wrongdoer.
A right in personam generally only binds the original parties. A stranger isn’t bound simply because the right exists. Something extra is needed, such as the stranger’s own promise to honour the interest.
This is how a registered proprietor can still come under a personal obligation, despite being registered. Under the Torrens statutes, mere notice of an unregistered interest doesn’t, by itself, create such an obligation. This is why equity’s in personam exceptions to registered title matter.
Many property law disputes depend on correctly classifying an interest as in rem or in personam. This is especially important when an interest hasn’t been registered or perfected as the relevant statutory scheme requires.
Why this distinction organises the rest of the subject
Everything later in this module depends on this starting point. Possession and title both ask what quality of right someone holds. This question exists separately from whether the right is formally registered.
Torrens legislation deals with registering titles and interests in land. The Personal Property Securities Act deals with security interests in personal property, covering perfection (which does not always need registration) and priority. Each system has its own rules for how an unregistered or unperfected interest ranks against other claims.
Leases and mortgages are proprietary interests, meaning they attach to the property itself. They must be told apart from merely personal rights, like a licence or an unsecured debt. This is done using the in rem (against the thing) versus in personam (against the person) distinction explained earlier.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by asking whether the disputed property is real property (land and interests in it) or personal property (chattels or choses in action).
If it is personal property, work out whether it is a chose in possession or a chose in action. This matters because the rules for transferring and enforcing each type differ.
Next, classify the right claimed as in rem or in personam. This classification shows who can be sued and what remedy is available.
Check whether a registration or perfection scheme covers the interest. If one applies, check whether the interest has actually been registered or perfected.
Only after these steps, apply the specific doctrine that governs the dispute, such as possession, title, leases, mortgages, or security interests.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.