Voth v Manildra Flour Mills Pty Ltd
Voth v Manildra Flour Mills Pty Ltd (1990) 171 CLR 538
Two New South Wales companies sue a Missouri accountant at home over tax advice given in Kansas City. He says the case belongs in the United States. How bad a fit must the local court be before it steps aside?
Qualified by Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang (2002) 210 CLR 491
The choice of law reasoning in Voth applied the double actionability rule of Phillips v Eyre. In Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang (2002) 210 CLR 491 the joint reasons of Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ held at [60] that the double actionability rule should now be held to have no application in Australia in international torts, and at [75] extended the lex loci delicti to foreign torts. The Voth test for a stay on forum grounds is unaffected: Dow Jones & Co Inc v Gutnick (2002) 210 CLR 575 at [9] records it as accepted by both parties.
What happened?
The two respondents were companies incorporated and resident in New South Wales, members of the Manildra Group, which made and sold starches. The appellant was an accountant, a citizen and resident of the United States who practised in Missouri. Between 1976 and 1983 members of the group sold starch products to Manildra Milling Corporation (MMC), a Kansas corporation that the joint reasons describe as a wholly-owned subsidiary of the second respondent, and MMC became indebted to the first respondent for interest. The appellant provided accounting, auditing and related services to MMC. Neither respondent claimed to have been his client.
MMC did not deduct and pay United States withholding tax on the interest it paid to the first respondent, and the appellant’s firm discovered the omission in 1984. The respondents alleged that the appellant was negligent in not drawing it to attention, and sued in the Supreme Court of New South Wales for damages, chiefly for Australian income tax overpaid and tax losses lost because the interest should have been treated as exempt income.
On 17 March 1986 the respondents were given leave to serve the statement of claim in Missouri. The appellant filed a conditional appearance and moved to have the statement of claim or its service set aside or the proceedings stayed. Clarke J dismissed the motion. The New South Wales Court of Appeal (Gleeson CJ and McHugh JA; Kirby P dissenting) dismissed the appeal. In the High Court the appellant no longer pursued his argument that the Supreme Court lacked jurisdiction.
What did the Court decide?
The Court allowed the appeal with costs on 13 December 1990. It set aside the Court of Appeal’s order and the orders of Clarke J, and ordered that the action be stayed on condition that the appellant, in any proceedings the respondents brought in Missouri about the subject-matter, undertake not to plead any defence based on a limitation statute or other law, provided the respondents began those proceedings in Missouri within three months.
Mason CJ, Deane, Dawson and Gaudron JJ gave joint reasons, and Brennan J and Toohey J each gave separate reasons. Brennan J would have dismissed the appeal; the other five Justices agreed in the orders.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
The test. In the joint reasons, the principles for an application to set aside service outside the jurisdiction and for a stay on inappropriate forum grounds are those stated by Deane J in Oceanic Sun, and the question is whether the local court is a clearly inappropriate forum. In their words the question “focuses, on both kinds of application, upon the inappropriateness of the local court and not the appropriateness or comparative appropriateness of the suggested foreign forum.” Their Honours added that Lord Goff’s discussion in Spiliada of “connecting factors” and “a legitimate personal or juridical advantage” “provides valuable assistance.”
Applying it, they had “little doubt that Missouri is the more appropriate forum but it does not necessarily follow that New South Wales is a clearly inappropriate forum.” They weighed the connections with Missouri against the respondents’ residence and the legitimate juridical advantages they pointed to, and concluded that New South Wales was a clearly inappropriate forum. The one advantage that could be met by an undertaking, the limitation bar, became the condition of the stay.
On the onus, the joint reasons said that where leave to serve out was granted ex parte, “the onus should remain on the plaintiff on a subsequent application to set aside the service outside the jurisdiction,” while the onus will differ on an application to stay the proceedings, where it falls on the defendant. Toohey J would have placed it on the defendant in both.
Who joined the test. Brennan J said “I add my acceptance of the test proposed by the majority,” giving as his reason that it was more important that a test be authoritatively settled than that he adhere to the test he preferred, and then said “I respectfully dissent from the result of its application.” Toohey J was “impenitent in adhering to the view which Wilson J. and I expressed in Oceanic Sun; thus the doctrine of forum non conveniens should determine” the stay. He agreed with the joint reasons that the complaint was committed in Missouri, adopted their reasons on that point, and agreed with the orders.
Where the tort was committed. The joint reasons held that “it is some act of the defendant, and not its consequences, that must be the focus of attention.” They treated the complaint as one that could be put as an omission or as a misstatement and concluded that “in substance, the cause of complaint is the act of providing the professional accountancy services on an incorrect basis,” an act complete in Missouri. The tort, if there was one, was therefore committed in Missouri, and the appellant was liable “only if he is liable under the law of Missouri,” a law the joint reasons called “fundamental” to the dispute.
Brennan J disagreed about the act. He treated the larger claims as resting on the plaintiffs’ own mistaken reliance and so on the appellant’s failure to communicate the true position to them, and held that “a misrepresentation is made when, and therefore where, it is received,” which was New South Wales.
Why does this case matter?
Voth is where Australian stay applications start, and a problem about an Australian plaintiff suing a defendant based overseas usually reaches it. The weak answer quotes the test without saying for which kind of application it was stated, and without a connection between the test and the facts that decided this case.
The orders in Voth were agreed by five Justices who did not all reason the same way, so a citation that says only that the High Court held something may claim more than one set of reasons gives.
Exam and application relevance
Begin by saying what kind of application is before the court: a stay of proceedings begun regularly, or an application to set aside service outside the jurisdiction. Then state the question the joint reasons asked and apply it to the connecting factors they weighed in this case: where the acts were done, where the parties live, the law governing the claim, where the evidence is, and any legitimate personal or juridical advantage the plaintiff would lose.
Say whose reasons carry each point you rely on, and do not describe the application of the test as unanimous.
On the law governing a foreign tort, the case relied on Phillips v Eyre and Zhang later replaced that rule, so the choice of law rule for a foreign tort should be stated from Zhang.
Check your understanding
1. Which Justices stated the clearly inappropriate forum test, and what did Brennan J and Toohey J each say about it?
2. The joint reasons had little doubt that Missouri was the more appropriate forum. Why did that not decide the application?
3. Brennan J and the joint reasons identified different acts of the appellant as the one that gave the respondents their cause of complaint. What was each, and how did that affect their conclusions about the forum?