Service across State and national borders

How initiating process reaches a defendant in another State under the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) or outside Australia under Part 11 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), and how Voth and Zhang govern a challenge on inappropriate-forum grounds.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw
Subjects
civil-procedure
Topics
service

Learning outcomes

  • Explain how initiating process is served in another State or Territory under the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth), including the mode of service, the notices, the appearance period and the address for service.
  • Distinguish service outside Australia without leave under Schedule 6 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) from service with leave under r 11.5, and identify the defendant’s challenge under r 11.6.
  • State the clearly inappropriate forum test from Voth and explain, from the joint reasons in Zhang, how it relates to the rule’s ‘inappropriate forum’ ground.

A defendant who lives in another State, or outside Australia, raises a question that ordinary service rules do not answer: whether the court’s process can reach that defendant at all, and by what route. This article states the answer in two parts. For service of initiating process from one Australian State or Territory into another it follows the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth), which applies Australia-wide. For service outside Australia it follows the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), whose Part 11 applies in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, together with two High Court decisions on when a court will decline to hear a proceeding served outside its territory. The rules of the Federal Court and of the other States and Territories on service abroad are not covered, and the general law of service is in Service.

Serving initiating process in another State or Territory

An initiating process is a process by which a proceeding is commenced or by reference to which a person becomes a party to a proceeding (s 3). Under the Commonwealth Act an initiating process issued in a State may be served in another State (s 15(1)). Each Territory is regarded as a State for this purpose, subject to s 7(2) (s 5(1)). The Act prescribes how the service is done1:

  1. An individual must be served in the same way as the initiating process could be served in the place of issue (s 15(2)).
  2. A company or registered body is served in accordance with s 9, which allows the document to be left at, or posted to, the registered office, among other methods (s 9; s 15(3)).
  3. Any other body corporate is served in accordance with s 10 (s 15(4)).
  4. A body politic, such as the Commonwealth or a State, is served in the way process of the Supreme Court of the State of service may be served on it (s 15(5)).

Service is effective only if copies of the prescribed notices are attached to the process or the copy served (s 16). Subject to the Act, service under it has the same effect, and may give rise to the same proceedings, as if the process had been served in the place of issue (s 12). If the person served is required or permitted to enter an appearance under the law of the place of issue, the period is the longer of 21 days and the period that would have applied in the place of issue, unless the court of issue allows a shorter period on application (s 17(1)); an appearance must state an address for service within Australia and is effective only if it does (s 18(1), (2)). Where the law of the place of issue varies the appearance period by distance, the longest distance is used (s 17(1A)), and an appearance that would not have needed an address for service had service been made in the State of issue is taken to contain one if it states the person’s own address (s 18(5)). Proof of service under the Act requires proof of the identity of the person who served, the time and day, the place and the way in which it was served and, where the way of serving required the person served to be identified, how that was done, though service by post has its own proof rules and the court may dispense with requirements where it is satisfied that personal service was effected (s 11).

Service in another State does not take the defendant out of the court’s reach, but it does give the defendant a statutory way to say that the court is the wrong one. The person served may apply to the court of issue for a stay if a court of another State with jurisdiction over all the matters in issue is the appropriate court. That application is not available where the Supreme Court of a State is the court of issue (s 20(1)-(3)). The stay section is considered in Forum, stay and contract.

Serving outside Australia from the New South Wales Supreme Court

Part 11 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) applies to proceedings in the Supreme Court (r 11.1(1)) and provides two routes2:

  • Without leave. Originating process may be served outside Australia without leave in the cases listed in Schedule 6 (r 11.4(1)). They include a claim founded on a tortious act or omission done or occurring wholly or partly in Australia, or in respect of which damage was sustained wholly or partly in Australia; a claim on a contract that was made in Australia, was to be performed wholly or partly in Australia or was to be governed by Australian law, among other links; and a case in which the person to be served has submitted to the jurisdiction (Sch 6, paras (a), (b), (k)).
  • With leave. Where Schedule 6 does not apply, service outside Australia is allowed with the leave of the court (r 11.5(1)). The application is supported by an affidavit on the desirability of the court assuming jurisdiction, and the court may grant leave if satisfied that the claim has a real and substantial connection with Australia, that Australia is an appropriate forum for the trial, and that in all the circumstances the court should assume jurisdiction (r 11.5(4), (5)).

Two carve-outs sit beside these routes. Part 11 does not require leave for service that may be effected under a Commonwealth law, the Hague Convention or Part 11A (r 11.2), and the Division containing the rules on service outside Australia does not apply to service in New Zealand of originating process that may be served there under Division 2 of Part 2 of the Trans-Tasman Proceedings Act 2010 (Cth) (r 11.3). Choosing the wrong route has a consequence. A person served outside Australia may apply for the proceeding to be dismissed or stayed or for service to be set aside, including on the grounds that service is not authorised by the rules, that the court is an inappropriate forum for the trial, or that the claim has insufficient prospects of success to warrant putting the person to the time, expense and trouble of defending it (r 11.6).

How courts decide whether the forum is inappropriate

The rule’s words “inappropriate forum” (r 11.6(2)(b)) come with a High Court gloss. In Voth v Manildra Flour Mills Pty Ltd (1990) 171 CLR 5383, the joint reasons of Mason CJ, Deane, Dawson and Gaudron JJ said that applications to set aside service on inappropriate-forum grounds, and applications for leave to serve outside the jurisdiction, are governed by the same principles as a stay on those grounds, because questions of service out of the jurisdiction are subordinate to the ultimate question of the appropriateness of the chosen forum (paras 48, 51-52). The test those principles state is whether the local court is a clearly inappropriate forum, which looks to the inappropriateness of the local court and not to the comparative appropriateness of another.

The application in Voth was decided at first instance before New South Wales had written an express “inappropriate forum” ground into its rules (Zhang at [18]). In Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang (2002) 210 CLR 4914, the joint reasons of Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ considered the earlier form of the rule, which used materially the same words as r 11.6(2)(b) does now. Their Honours said the expression is less emphatic than “clearly inappropriate forum”, so that a court is not an inappropriate forum merely because another is more appropriate, but that the same concepts and considerations inform both tests, in the same way ([23]-[25]). The appeal was dismissed by five of the seven Justices; Kirby J and Callinan J would have allowed it. Later decisions on r 11.6 itself are not covered here.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Locate the defendant. Within Australia but outside the State of issue, apply the Commonwealth Act; outside Australia, the rules of the court in which the proceeding was commenced.
  2. For service in another State or Territory, identify the kind of defendant and the service rule in s 15(2)-(5), check that the notices required by s 16 were attached, and check the appearance period in s 17.
  3. For service outside Australia in the New South Wales Supreme Court, ask first whether the service falls within r 11.2 or r 11.3, then whether a Schedule 6 case applies, and if not, whether leave was obtained on the matters in r 11.5(5).
  4. Ask what the defendant can do. In the first situation, the stay application under s 20 if the court of issue is not a State Supreme Court; in the second, an application under r 11.6.
  5. On an inappropriate-forum challenge, state the test with its source: Voth’s clearly inappropriate forum test, and Zhang on how the rule’s shorter words relate to it, noting that Zhang was decided by five of seven Justices.

Self-check

  • Have I said whether the situation is interstate service under the Commonwealth Act or service outside Australia under a court’s own rules?
  • Have I named the court whose rules I am applying, given that Part 11 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules applies only in the New South Wales Supreme Court?
  • Have I kept the stay under s 20 of the Commonwealth Act separate from the challenge under r 11.6?
  • Have I attributed the “clearly inappropriate forum” test to the joint reasons in Voth and described Zhang as a decision of five of seven Justices?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.