Service across State and national borders

Serving initiating process in another State or Territory

An initiating process is the document that starts a proceeding, or makes someone a party to one (s 3). Under the Commonwealth Act, an initiating process issued in one State can be served in another (s 15(1)). Territories count as States for this purpose, subject to s 7(2) (s 5(1)).

How service happens depends on who is served. An individual is served as if the process were being served in the place of issue (s 15(2)). A company or registered body is served under s 9, which allows leaving or posting the document at the registered office, among other methods (s 15(3)). Other bodies corporate are served under s 10 (s 15(4)). A body politic, like the Commonwealth or a State, is served as Supreme Court process of the serving State would be served on it (s 15(5)).

Service only counts if the prescribed notices are attached (s 16). Otherwise, service has the same effect as if made in the place of issue (s 12).

If the person must enter an appearance, the time allowed is whichever is longer: 21 days or the period that would apply in the place of issue, unless the issuing court allows less (s 17(1)). The appearance must give an Australian address for service to be effective (s 18(1), (2)). If the place of issue varies the appearance period by distance, the longest distance applies (s 17(1A)). An appearance that would not have needed an address for service if made in the issuing State is still treated as compliant if it states the person’s own address (s 18(5)).

Proving service means proving who served it, when, where, and how, including how the person served was identified where relevant. Service by post has its own proof rules, and the court may excuse these requirements if satisfied personal service occurred (s 11).

Being served interstate does not remove the case from the court’s power. But it does let the defendant ask that court to stay the case, if another court is more appropriate.

Serving outside Australia from the New South Wales Supreme Court

Part 11 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) covers Supreme Court proceedings (r 11.1(1)). It sets out two ways to serve documents outside Australia.

First, without leave (court permission). Under r 11.4(1), originating process can be served overseas without leave if the case fits Schedule 6. Examples include torts occurring or causing damage partly in Australia, contracts made or performed in Australia or governed by Australian law, and cases where the person has already submitted to the court’s jurisdiction (Sch 6, paras (a), (b), (k)).

Second, with leave. If Schedule 6 doesn’t apply, r 11.5(1) allows service overseas only with court leave. The applicant needs an affidavit explaining why the court should take the case. Leave may be granted if the claim has a real and substantial connection with Australia, Australia is an appropriate forum, and the court should assume jurisdiction (r 11.5(4), (5)).

Two exceptions apply. Leave isn’t needed if service can occur under a Commonwealth law, the Hague Convention, or Part 11A (r 11.2). Also, these rules don’t cover service in New Zealand where the Trans-Tasman Proceedings Act 2010 (Cth), Part 2, Division 2 already allows it (r 11.3).

Getting the wrong route matters. A person served overseas can apply to have the case dismissed or stayed, or service set aside. Grounds include: service wasn’t authorised by the rules, the court is the wrong forum, or the claim isn’t strong enough to justify the expense of defending it (r 11.6).

How courts decide whether the forum is inappropriate

Rule 11.6(2)(b) asks whether the forum is an “inappropriate forum.” The High Court has explained what this means.

In Voth v Manildra Flour Mills Pty Ltd, the High Court set out the test. A court should ask whether the local court is a “clearly inappropriate forum.” This means looking at whether the local court itself is unsuitable. It does not mean comparing it to another possibly better forum. The Court also said this same test applies whether you are trying to set aside service, or seeking leave to serve someone overseas, or applying for a stay.

Voth was decided before New South Wales had this exact “inappropriate forum” wording in its rules. Later, in Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang, the High Court considered an earlier version of the rule using similar wording to today’s r 11.6(2)(b).

The Court in Zhang clarified the test further. Calling a forum merely “inappropriate” is a lower bar than calling it “clearly inappropriate forum.” However, a court is not inappropriate just because another forum would be more suitable. The same underlying ideas apply to both versions of the test, just expressed with different emphasis.

The majority in Zhang dismissed the appeal; two judges dissented. This summary does not cover later cases interpreting r 11.6 itself.

Applying this in a problem question

First, find where the defendant is. If they are within Australia but outside the State where the case started, the Commonwealth Act applies. If they are outside Australia, use the rules of the court that started the case.

For service in another State or Territory, check what kind of defendant it is. Then find the matching service rule in s 15(2)-(5). Also check that the notices required by s 16 were attached, and check the appearance period in s 17.

For service outside Australia in the New South Wales Supreme Court, first ask whether the service fits r 11.2 or r 11.3. Then check if a Schedule 6 case applies. If not, check whether leave was obtained, based on the matters in r 11.5(5).

Next, think about what the defendant can do. For the first situation, they may apply for a stay under s 20, but only if the court of issue is not a State Supreme Court. For the second situation, they can apply under r 11.6.

If the defendant challenges the case as an inappropriate forum, state the test and its source. This is Voth’s clearly inappropriate forum test. Also mention Zhang, which explains how the rule’s shorter wording relates to that test. Note that Zhang was decided by only five of seven Justices.

Self-check

Before moving on, check a few things.

Did you say whether this is interstate service under the Commonwealth Act, or service outside Australia under a court’s own rules? These are different situations, so keep them separate.

Did you name the specific court whose rules apply? Remember, Part 11 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules only applies in the New South Wales Supreme Court, not elsewhere.

Did you keep the stay under s 20 of the Commonwealth Act separate from a challenge under r 11.6? These are two distinct processes, not one.

Finally, did you credit the “clearly inappropriate forum” test to the joint reasons in Voth? And did you correctly describe Zhang as a decision of five out of seven Justices, not a unanimous court?

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.