Smethurst v Commissioner of Police

High Court of Australia · 2020

Criminal Law And ProcedureCriminal Process

Smethurst v Commissioner of Police [2020] HCA 14

Police searched a journalist’s home under a warrant that named an offence, but the offence it named was not the one the statute creates. Does the wording of a warrant matter once the search is over?

What happened?

A journalist’s home was searched by the Australian Federal Police on 4 June 2019 under a search warrant issued the day before. The warrant named an offence under s 79(3) of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), and its own wording of that offence is what the Court had to examine. The officers required her to give her mobile phone passcode, copied the data from the phone, and copied the documents they identified onto a USB stick that they took from the premises. No criminal charges had been laid when the special case was stated [9] and [10]. The AFP believed its actions were authorised by the warrant. The question for the Court was whether the warrant was valid and, if it was not, what should follow.

What did the Court decide?

Before you read the Proposition, decide two things. Was the warrant valid, given the wording of its offence? And if it was not, what should the Court order: only that the warrant be quashed, or something more about the copied material? The Court’s answers, and which Justices gave which reasons, are in the Proposition and the judgments.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

A search warrant under s 3E(1) of the Crimes Act is not valid unless it states the particular offence to which it relates, in terms that are intelligible and sufficient to convey the object and limits of the search. It need not match the precision of an indictment. A warrant that misstates the offence can fail that condition where the misstatement, together with the rest of the warrant, leaves the search’s object impossible to understand. The plurality found that this warrant did so, and Edelman J found it lacked the clarity its purposes required. The result was that the entry and search were not authorised by the Act.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Only selected propositions are annotated. An unmarked proposition has not been classified.

Proposition 1

Ratio · Kiefel CJ, Bell and Keane JJ (the plurality); Gageler and Nettle JJ agreeing with those reasons

Read judgment: [26]–[30] (PDF p 17) (opens in a new tab), [43]–[44] (PDF p 22) (opens in a new tab)

The plurality’s paragraphs 26 to 30 set out why the statement of the offence is a condition of validity and how sufficiency is judged, and paragraphs 43 and 44 apply that to a warrant that misstated the offence and conclude that s 3E(5)(a) was not complied with. Those passages are necessary to the plurality’s conclusion that the warrant was invalid. Edelman J reached the same answer by a separate route at paragraphs 202 to 204, which is not part of the plurality’s reasoning and is not attributed to it here.

Why does this case matter?

Students often treat a defective warrant as a technical point about paperwork. The case asks a student to follow the warrant’s wording through to the officers’ authority for each step of the search. It also separates two questions a student must keep apart: whether the entry and search were lawful, and what should happen to material already taken. A correct answer on the first can leave the second open, and the second is where the Justices divided.

Exam and application relevance

When a question describes a warrant with a defective description of the offence, work through the warrant’s own words first and ask what an executing officer and the occupier would each understand about the object of the search. Then treat the consequences of invalidity as a separate issue. Where a question asks what remedy the plaintiff can obtain, say what the Court ordered, identify the Justices who would have gone further, and give the reasons the plurality gave for refusing the injunction. Quashing a warrant and returning copied material are separate questions, and an answer should keep them apart.

Check your understanding

1. What did the warrant say about the offence, and why did the mismatch matter to the people carrying it out?

2. Why might a student need to separate the question whether the search was lawful from the question what should happen to the copied data?