Extinguishment of native title by grants of interests in land
How a grant of an interest in land extinguishes native title: the common-law rule in Fejo v Northern Territory (a fee simple extinguishes permanently and without revival), and the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) rules on extinguishment, including Division 2B on previous exclusive and non-exclusive possession acts and ss 47A-47C, under which earlier extinguishment is disregarded for some claimant applications.
Learning outcomes
- State the common-law rule in Fejo v Northern Territory that a grant of an unqualified fee simple extinguishes native title permanently, and identify what the case did not decide.
- Explain how s 11, s 237A and Division 2B of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) limit and confirm extinguishment, distinguishing previous exclusive possession acts from previous non-exclusive possession acts.
- Work through the extinguishing effect of a grant on given facts, separating the common-law rule from the Act’s confirmation provisions and checking the date, the exclusions and the attribution of the act to the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
Native title is recognised by Australian law as a burden on the Crown’s title, but it does not last for ever once the land is dealt with. Before asking whether native title exists over a parcel today, a student of property law must ask a prior question: has any grant of an interest in that land, by the Crown or under legislation, extinguished it, and if so by what rule? The answer comes from two sources that must be kept apart: the common-law rule that a grant inconsistent with native title extinguishes it, stated by the High Court in Fejo v Northern Territory, and the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), which limits how native title may be extinguished and confirms the extinguishment effected by particular past acts. This article states those two sources. The origin and recognition of native title, and the requirements of s 223(1), are in Native title: common-law recognition and the statutory framework and Native title and Yorta Yorta.
The common-law rule: a grant of an inconsistent interest extinguishes
In Fejo v Northern Territory [1998] HCA 58; (1998) 195 CLR 96 the Larrakia people claimed native title over land near Darwin that had been granted in fee simple in 1882 and later acquired by the Commonwealth.1 The joint judgment of Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow, Hayne and Callinan JJ held that “[n]ative title is extinguished by a grant in fee simple”, and gave the reason: the rights given by a fee simple “are rights that are inconsistent with the native title holders continuing to hold any of the rights or interests which together make up native title” (at [43]). An estate in fee simple is “for almost all practical purposes, the equivalent of full ownership of the land”, and the holder may use the land as he or she sees fit and may exclude everyone from access to it, subject to statute, the common law, reservation or grant (at [43], [47]).
Four points in the joint judgment carry the rule beyond its facts.
- Extinguishment, not suspension. A grant in fee simple does not have a temporary effect on native title or one conditioned on the land not coming to be held by the Crown again (at [45]). Native title was therefore not, and could not be, revived when the land came to be held once more by the Crown (at [56]-[58]).
- The test is effect, not intention. The conclusion follows from the effect of the later grant on the rights that make up native title, and not from identifying an intention in the grantor (at [47]).
- A grant can reserve rights. A fee simple can be granted on terms that reserve rights to others, such as easements and profits, but the 1882 grant was unqualified and carried no reservation (at [52]).
- Leases were not decided. The question in the case was the effect of the 1882 grant; the questions about leasehold interests considered in Wik Peoples v Queensland did not arise (at [55]).
Kirby J gave separate reasons and agreed in the result on the substantive question, holding that the extinguishment occasioned by the grant of a fee simple is irreversible (at [107], [112]). The decision is of the High Court and binds lower Australian courts as to what it decided; it is an authority on the effect of an unqualified fee simple, and it does not state the effect of every kind of grant.
The Native Title Act: extinguishment only as the Act allows
The Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) provides that native title is not able to be extinguished contrary to the Act (s 11(1)).2 Legislation made on or after 1 July 1993 by the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory is able to extinguish native title only in accordance with Division 2B (confirmation of past extinguishment) or Division 3 (future acts) of Part 2, or by validating past acts or intermediate period acts (s 11(2)). To “extinguish” native title means to extinguish it permanently, so that the rights and interests cannot revive even if the act that caused the extinguishment ceases to have effect (s 237A), which is consistent with the conclusion Fejo reached at common law that the extinguishment is not reversed when the land returns to the Crown.
Earlier extinguishment disregarded for some claims. Permanence does not end the inquiry where a native title claim is made over certain kinds of land. Sections 47A, 47B and 47C provide that, “[f]or all purposes under this Act in relation to the application”, earlier extinguishment by the acts each section lists, subject to its own exceptions, must be disregarded.3 Section 47A covers an area that, when a claimant application is made, is held under a freehold estate, lease or vesting granted under legislation that provides for such grants only to or for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders, or is held, held on trust or reserved expressly for their benefit, and that one or more members of the claim group occupy (s 47A(1)-(2)). Section 47B covers vacant Crown land: an area not covered by a freehold estate or lease, by a reservation or other authority under which it is to be used for public purposes or a particular purpose, or by a resumption process, and occupied by one or more members of the claim group when the application is made (s 47B(1)-(2)). Section 47C covers a park area set aside or vested to preserve the natural environment, but only where the Commonwealth, State or Territory concerned and the registered native title body corporate or the applicant for the claim group have agreed in writing to the section applying to an onshore area, after at least three months for public comment, and only where that area is Crown land or freehold held by the Crown or a statutory authority of the Crown and none of ss 47, 47A and 47B applies (s 47C(1), (3), (6)-(8)). In each case the claim group must still show the connection the common law concept of native title requires, a determination does not affect the validity of the earlier grant or interest, and the non-extinguishment principle applies to that grant or interest (ss 47A(3), 47B(3), 47C(9), 238(2)). So a fee simple or lease that extinguished native title under Fejo or Division 2B may have to be disregarded in a claim if the land now falls within one of these sections.
Division 2B deals with certain acts done on or before 23 December 1996 and has two tiers (s 23A).
Previous exclusive possession acts. These are valid acts, on or before 23 December 1996, that consist of the grant or vesting of a freehold estate, a Scheduled interest, certain exclusive pastoral or agricultural leases, a residential lease, a community purposes lease, a commercial lease that is neither an agricultural nor a pastoral lease, or any other lease (other than a mining lease) that confers exclusive possession, or the construction or establishment of a public work begun on or before that date (s 23B(2), (7)). The definition carries exclusions, including that an act is not one if made under legislation providing for grants only for the benefit of Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders, if it establishes a national park or similar area to preserve the natural environment, or if the legislation expressly provides that the act does not extinguish native title (s 23B(9), (9A), (9B)). Where a grant or vesting of that kind is attributable to the Commonwealth, it extinguishes any native title in the land covered by the freehold estate, Scheduled interest or lease, and the extinguishment is taken to have happened when the act was done (s 23C(1)). A public work attributable to the Commonwealth extinguishes native title in relation to the land or waters on which the completed work was or is situated, and the extinguishment is taken to have happened when its construction or establishment began (s 23C(2)).
Previous non-exclusive possession acts. These are the grants, in the same period, of non-exclusive agricultural or pastoral leases, and certain later acts done in exercise of a legally enforceable right created, or in good faith giving effect to a commitment made, on or before that date (s 23F(2)-(3)). For a Commonwealth act, rights granted that are not inconsistent with native title prevail over the native title rights but do not extinguish them; and, to the extent the rights granted are inconsistent with native title, the native title rights are extinguished if the act would have extinguished them apart from the Act, and otherwise are suspended while the lease, or the lease as renewed, re-made, re-granted or extended, is in force (s 23G(1)). Section 23G does not apply to the grant of a pastoral or agricultural lease to which s 15(1)(a) applies, and s 15 is not stated in this article (s 23G(2)).
The Division speaks of acts attributable to the Commonwealth. A law of a State or Territory may make provision to the same effect for its own previous exclusive possession acts if the law contains a provision to the same effect as s 23D or s 23DA (s 23E), and for its own previous non-exclusive possession acts if it contains provisions to the same effect as ss 23H and 23HA, which deal with beneficial reservations and notification (s 23I). The native title holders are entitled to compensation in accordance with Division 5 for extinguishment under the Division, to the extent their rights were not extinguished otherwise than under the Act (s 23J).
Why the two sources are kept apart
Fejo answers whether an unqualified fee simple extinguished native title as a matter of the common law of inconsistency. Division 2B answers what the Act confirms for the listed past acts, in its own terms and with its own exclusions. A student who cites Fejo for the extinguishing effect of a lease, or who applies Division 2B to a State grant without checking whether the State has enacted a confirming law, has used the wrong source. Where Division 2B does not apply, the Act’s other provisions, such as those on validation and on future acts, which this article does not state, must be checked before asking what the general law of inconsistency makes of the grant, because native title is not able to be extinguished contrary to the Act (s 11(1)).
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the interest granted, who granted it, when, and whether the grant was valid. Statutory text and the instrument itself decide what rights were conferred.
- If it is an unqualified fee simple, apply Fejo: native title was extinguished, the extinguishment is permanent, and it does not revive if the Crown later holds the land again. Check for any reservation in the grant.
- If a claimant application now covers the land, check whether s 47A, 47B or 47C requires the earlier extinguishment to be disregarded for that application.
- If it is a lease, a public work or another interest, do not apply Fejo; ask whether Division 2B applies, check the Act’s other provisions, and only then ask whether the grant was inconsistent with the native title rights.
- Under Division 2B, classify the act as a previous exclusive possession act or a previous non-exclusive possession act, check the 23 December 1996 date and the exclusions, and note whether the act is attributable to the Commonwealth or to a State or Territory.
- For a State or Territory act, check whether the State or Territory has legislated to confirm extinguishment in the manner ss 23E and 23I allow.
- State the consequence: extinguishment (permanent), suspension or coexistence, and note the entitlement to compensation under s 23J.
Self-check
- Have I distinguished the common-law rule in Fejo from the confirmation provisions in Division 2B?
- Have I confined Fejo to an unqualified fee simple and said that leasehold questions were not decided?
- Have I checked the 23 December 1996 date, the exclusions in s 23B, and whether the act is attributable to the Commonwealth or a State?
- Have I said that extinguishment is permanent, checked whether ss 47A-47C require it to be disregarded for a claim, and noted that compensation may be payable under s 23J?