Extinguishment of native title by grants of interests in land
The common-law rule: a grant of an inconsistent interest extinguishes
In Fejo v Northern Territory (1998), the High Court dealt with land near Darwin. The Larrakia people claimed native title over land that had been granted in fee simple in 1882. The Commonwealth later acquired that land.
The Court held that a grant of fee simple extinguishes native title. A fee simple is an estate treated as almost equivalent to full ownership of land. The Court reasoned that fee simple rights are inconsistent with native title rights continuing to exist alongside them.
The extinguishment is permanent, not temporary. Native title does not revive even if the Crown later holds the land again.
The test for extinguishment looks at the effect of the grant, not the grantor’s intention. Whether native title survives depends on what rights the grant actually confers.
A grant of fee simple can reserve rights for others, such as easements or profits (rights to use or take something from land). But the 1882 grant here had no such reservation; it was unqualified.
The case did not decide the effect of leasehold interests. That issue, considered elsewhere in Wik Peoples v Queensland, did not arise on these facts.
Justice Kirby agreed with the outcome but wrote separate reasons. He held that extinguishment by a fee simple grant cannot be reversed.
As a High Court decision, Fejo binds lower courts on what it actually decided. It establishes the effect of an unqualified grant of fee simple. It does not determine the effect of every other type of grant.
Why the two sources are kept apart
Fejo and Division 2B answer different questions. Fejo deals with the common law of inconsistency, asking whether an unqualified fee simple extinguishes native title. Division 2B deals with what the Act confirms for certain listed past acts, using its own terms and exclusions.
Mixing them up is a mistake. Citing Fejo for a lease’s extinguishing effect, or applying Division 2B to a State grant without checking for a confirming State law, means using the wrong source.
Where Division 2B does not apply, other parts of the Act may still matter. The passage mentions provisions on validation and future acts, without detailing them here. These must be checked before asking what the general law of inconsistency says about the grant.
This matters because native title cannot be extinguished contrary to the Act (s 11(1)). So the Act’s own rules always take priority over common law inconsistency principles.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the interest granted: what it is, who granted it, when, and whether the grant was valid. The statutory text and the instrument itself determine what rights it gave.
If the grant is an unqualified fee simple (full, outright ownership), apply Fejo. Native title was extinguished, this extinguishment is permanent, and it does not revive even if the Crown later holds the land again. Still check the grant for any reservation.
If a native title claim now covers the land, check whether ss 47A, 47B or 47C require that earlier extinguishment to be disregarded.
For a lease, public work or other interest, do not apply Fejo. Instead ask whether Division 2B applies, check the Act’s other provisions, then ask whether the grant was inconsistent with the native title rights.
Under Division 2B, classify the act as a previous exclusive possession act or a previous non-exclusive possession act. Check whether it occurred before 23 December 1996, check the exclusions, and note whether it is attributable to the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
For a State or Territory act, check whether that State or Territory has legislated to confirm extinguishment, as ss 23E and 23I allow.
Finally, state the consequence: extinguishment (permanent), suspension, or coexistence, and note any entitlement to compensation under s 23J.
Self-check
Before moving on, check you have kept these points separate.
Fejo is a common-law rule. Division 2B contains confirmation provisions, which are different. Keep these two sources of extinguishment apart.
Fejo dealt only with unqualified fee simple, meaning full, unrestricted ownership. The case did not decide what happens with leasehold interests.
For Division 2B, confirm the act happened on or before 23 December 1996. Check the exclusions in s 23B, and confirm whether the act is attributable to the Commonwealth or a State.
Extinguishment is permanent once it occurs. But check whether ss 47A-47C require it to be disregarded for a particular claim. Also note that compensation may be payable under s 23J.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.