Misleading conduct about financial products and services

How a student argues and answers a problem on misleading conduct about financial products and services under ss 1041E and 1041H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and ss 12DA and 12DB of the ASIC Act: why the Australian Consumer Law provision does not apply, how the provisions differ, who may sue and what remedies follow.

Learning level
Application
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
investment-and-financial-regulation
Topics
market-misconduct

Learning outcomes

  • Choose between ss 1041E and 1041H of the Corporations Act and ss 12DA and 12DB of the ASIC Act for a statement about a financial product or service, and explain why the Australian Consumer Law provision is not the one to cite.
  • Apply the audience-based test from Forrest to what a statement conveyed, keeping a case of knowledge or fraud separate from a misleading conduct case.
  • Identify the carve-outs and the future-matters rule that change the analysis, including the disclosure document and continuous disclosure carve-outs and ss 769C and 12BB.
  • State who may sue, the limits that apply to claims under ss 1041H and 12DA, and the remedies available to ASIC as against a private claimant.

This article states Commonwealth law only: the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act). State and Territory fair trading legislation is not covered. The prior question in a problem about a misleading statement concerning a share, a fund or investment advice is which statute is in play, because the Commonwealth application of the Australian Consumer Law’s misleading conduct prohibition does not apply to conduct in relation to financial services.1 The financial services provisions are worded differently, carry different fault requirements and give different remedies, so the choice decides who may sue and for what. The general test is taught in Misleading and deceptive conduct and the carve-out in The Australian Consumer Law framework; this article takes both as known and teaches how to plead and answer a claim under the financial services provisions.

The four provisions

Section 1041H (Corporations Act). A person must not, in this jurisdiction, engage in conduct, in relation to a financial product or a financial service, that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive. Failure to comply is not an offence, and may lead to civil liability under s 1041I. It has no fault element, and its text does not require trade or commerce. Conduct “in relation to” a financial product includes, without limit, dealing in it, issuing it, publishing a notice in relation to it, and making or evaluating a takeover offer or a recommendation about one (s 1041H(2)).2 In Forrest v ASIC, ASIC alleged that Fortescue’s ASX announcements were misleading conduct in relation to its shares by “publishing notices in relation to that financial product”.12

Section 12DA (ASIC Act). A person must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct in relation to financial services that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive. It requires trade or commerce, and it speaks of financial services rather than financial products; but for that Division of the ASIC Act a financial product is itself a financial service (s 12BAB(1AA)), so supplying a product is within it.56 The operative words, “misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive”, are identical in the two sections. A problem answer ordinarily runs one analysis of the statement and its audience against both; Forrest was a s 1041H case and Wingecarribee decided its misleading conduct issues under s 12DA.14

Section 12DB (ASIC Act). This is a list, not a general norm: false or misleading representations, in trade or commerce and in connection with supplying or promoting financial services, about matters such as their standard, quality, value or grade, their price, the need for them, or the effect of a condition, warranty, guarantee, right or remedy (s 12DB(1)). Unlike s 12DA, s 12DB is a civil penalty provision, and breach is also an offence, of strict liability (s 12DB(3)).57

Section 1041E (Corporations Act). This is the statement provision. A person must not make a statement or disseminate information that is false in a material particular or materially misleading, if it is likely to induce persons in this jurisdiction to apply for, dispose of or acquire financial products, or to affect the price for trading in financial products on a financial market operated in this jurisdiction, and if, when making it, the person does not care whether it is true or false, or knows or ought reasonably to have known that it is false in a material particular or materially misleading. Unlike s 1041H, it requires materiality, a likely effect on dealing or price, and fault. It is an offence (Schedule 3 states 15 years’ imprisonment) and founds a civil action under s 1041I.29 It is not in the table of civil penalty provisions in s 1317E(3), so ASIC has no pecuniary penalty route under it.8 Sections 1041F (inducing persons to deal) and 1041G (dishonest conduct in a financial services business) sit beside it and are not examined here.

Where the provisions stop

Sections 1041H, 12DA and 12DB yield to regimes that govern particular documents; the text of s 1041E contains no equivalent exclusion. Conduct that contravenes the misleading takeover or fundraising document provisions (ss 670A, 728 and 738Y) or s 1021NA or 1021NB, or is in relation to a disclosure document or statement within s 953A or s 1022A (which covers Product Disclosure Statements), does not contravene s 1041H(1) (s 1041H(3)). Section 12DA(1A) and s 12DB(2) take out the same conduct apart from ss 1021NA and 1021NB. Conduct that does not contravene s 674A(2) or s 675A(2) as drafted, but would if the relevant paragraph had the same text as the corresponding paragraph of s 674(2) or s 675(2), is not re-run as a contravention of s 1041H(1) or s 12DA(1) (s 1041H(4); s 12DA(3)). 25

Predictions about the future

A representation about a future matter made without reasonable grounds is taken to be misleading: under Corporations Act s 769C(1) for the purposes of Chapter 7, which includes Part 7.10, and under ASIC Act s 12BB(1) for ss 12DA to 12DN. Section 12BB(2) adds that the person is taken not to have had reasonable grounds unless evidence to the contrary is adduced, and s 12BB(3) says that adducing evidence does not itself establish reasonable grounds or place an onus on the person. Section 769C as compiled has no equivalent subsection. Neither limits the other ways a representation can be misleading.46 In Wingecarribee evidence of reasonable grounds had been adduced, which put the onus on the councils to prove there were none.14

Who can sue and what follows

A private claim lies under s 1041I for a contravention of s 1041E, 1041F, 1041G or 1041H, and under s 12GF for a contravention of Subdivision D of the ASIC Act, which includes ss 12DA and 12DB. Each lets a person who suffers loss or damage by the conduct of another recover it from that person or any person involved in the contravention; s 1041I applies whether or not anyone has been convicted. Each action may be begun within six years after the cause of action arose. Both speak of “a person” on each side, so neither plaintiff nor defendant is confined to a client or a licensee.37

Three qualifications apply to claims for a contravention of s 1041H or s 12DA.

  • A State or Territory professional standards law may limit occupational liability (s 1044B; s 12GNA).
  • If a claimant suing for economic loss or damage to property suffered it partly through a failure to take reasonable care, and the defendant neither intended nor fraudulently caused the loss, damages are reduced to the extent the court thinks just and equitable (s 1041I(1B); s 12GF(1B)).
  • Proportionate liability applies to a claim for damages for economic loss or damage to property: a defendant who is a concurrent wrongdoer has its liability limited to the proportion the court considers just, unless it intended or fraudulently caused the loss (ss 1041L to 1041N for s 1041H; ss 12GP to 12GR for s 12DA).37

Section 1041I(4) applies the relief power in s 1317S, as if the sections in s 1041I(1) were civil penalty provisions: a court may relieve a person who has acted honestly and ought fairly to be excused. Section 1044A(2) allows relief for a publisher of an advertisement, received in the ordinary course of a publishing business, who had no reason to believe its publication would amount to an offence.3

ASIC’s position differs. Section 1041H is not in s 1317E(3), and s 12GBA(6)(b) excludes s 12DA from the ASIC Act’s civil penalty provisions, so neither carries a pecuniary penalty. ASIC instead seeks declarations and orders: orders for a contravention of a provision of Chapter 7 (s 1101B), an injunction (s 1324, also open to a person whose interests are affected), and compensatory or preventive orders for a contravention of Part 7.10 (s 1325) or the ASIC Act Division (s 12GM), including on ASIC’s application on behalf of persons who consent in writing.871011

What the cases show

What the statement conveyed. In Forrest v Australian Securities and Investments Commission; Fortescue Metals Group Ltd v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2012] HCA 39, ASIC alleged that Fortescue’s announcements that it had made “binding contracts” with Chinese state-owned companies were misleading or deceptive under s 1041H. The High Court, whose decisions bind lower Australian courts, allowed the appeals. The joint reasons ask what the statements conveyed to their intended audience, judged by the ordinary or reasonable member of it. The announcements conveyed what the parties had done and said they had done, not that an Australian court would enforce the agreements, and ASIC had not shown that any further message was conveyed.12 The inquiry is hypothetical, so it answers both whether conduct is misleading and whether it is likely to mislead. The critical question is what the statement conveyed to its audience, not what its maker says was intended, and the Court did not lay down a general proposition about what a public statement of a contract conveys. It also held that a case that a person knew a statement was false is a case of fraud, to be pleaded specifically and kept separate from the misleading conduct case, which must identify what the statements conveyed.12 ASIC’s continuous disclosure claim in Forrest was decided on s 674 as it stood before 14 August 2021. From that date Schedule 2 to the Treasury Laws Amendment (2021 Measures No. 1) Act 2021 (Cth) removed s 674(2) from the civil penalty provisions, put civil penalty liability in s 674A, which requires that the entity knows, or is reckless or negligent as to whether, the information would have a material effect on price, and added s 1041H(4).13

Application to investment advice. In Wingecarribee Shire Council v Lehman Brothers Australia Ltd (in liq) [2012] FCA 1028, Rares J (a single judge of the Federal Court, at first instance) held that the respondent (then Grange Securities) contravened s 12DA(1) by representing to councils that synthetic collateralised debt obligations were suitable for conservative investors and that it observed prudent, conservative practices. He remarked on the differences in wording between the two provisions. The respondent also ran the defences that attach to these claims, arguing that rating agencies were concurrent wrongdoers and that damages should be reduced under s 12GF(1B). On the facts, Rares J declined to attribute any share of responsibility to the rating agencies and rejected the s 12GF(1B) reduction for Parkes and Wingecarribee.14

Pleading in the alternative. In ASIC v AGM Markets Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3) [2020] FCA 208, Beach J (a single judge of the Federal Court, at first instance) found that account managers for three derivatives businesses told retail clients that depositing more money would reduce their risk, and that one business was licensed by ASIC when it was not. He held that each representation contravened s 1041H and/or s 12DA(1) and/or s 12DB(1), and that many, as representations about future matters, were deemed misleading under s 12BB.15

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify what was said or done and who received it, and state the impression it conveyed to the ordinary or reasonable member of that audience (Forrest), not what the speaker meant.
  2. Ask whether the conduct is in relation to a financial product or financial service. If so, the Australian Consumer Law’s Commonwealth application is not the provision to cite; use ss 1041H and 12DA, and s 12DB if a listed representation was made.
  3. Check the carve-outs: disclosure documents within s 953A or s 1022A, the takeover and fundraising document provisions, and the continuous disclosure overlap.
  4. If the statement is a prediction, apply s 769C and s 12BB and ask who bears the onus after evidence of reasonable grounds.
  5. Ask whether fault is provable. If the maker did not care, or knew or ought to have known, that the statement was false in a material particular or materially misleading, and it was likely to induce dealing or to affect price as s 1041E(1)(b) requires, add s 1041E and note the criminal consequences.
  6. Identify the claimant and the remedy: damages under s 1041I or s 12GF within six years, subject to the reasonable care, proportionate liability and professional standards limits, or ASIC’s declarations and orders, with no pecuniary penalty for ss 1041H and 12DA.

Self-check

  • Have I said why the Australian Consumer Law prohibition is not the provision, and used the audience-based test for what the conduct conveyed?
  • Have I applied the qualifications that attach to ss 1041H and 12DA claims but not to the other provisions, and kept ASIC’s remedies separate from a private claim?