Market manipulation and false trading
The market manipulation and false trading prohibitions in ss 1041A to 1041D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth): what makes a price artificial, false appearances of active trading, the role of purpose, fault, defences and relief, and the criminal and civil consequences.
Learning outcomes
- Identify which of ss 1041A to 1041D a set of trading facts engages, and what effect on a price or on the market’s appearance each requires.
- Apply the High Court’s account of an artificial price, including the part purpose plays and the limits of the reasoning.
- Distinguish the fault and defence provisions for the offence from those for civil penalty proceedings.
- State the criminal and civil consequences, including why a compensation order and not an action under s 1041I is the statutory route.
Division 2 of Part 7.10 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) prohibits market manipulation and false trading in ss 1041A to 1041D. That is Commonwealth legislation, and this article cites no State or Territory legislation. Each concerns financial products traded on a financial market operated in this jurisdiction. Sections 1041A and 1041B are written in terms of the actual or likely effect of conduct on a price or on the market’s appearance, so the first question is what the conduct did or was likely to do, and the second is what the person’s purpose shows about that; s 1041C requires a fictitious or artificial transaction or device that results in a price being maintained, inflated or depressed; and s 1041D concerns statements about the price effect of unlawful transactions. A contravention is both an offence and a civil penalty contravention. The misleading-statement provisions in the same Division (ss 1041E to 1041H) are a separate topic and are only pointed to here.
The four prohibitions
Market manipulation (s 1041A). A person must not take part in, or carry out, directly or indirectly, a transaction, or two or more transactions, that has or have, or is or are likely to have, the effect of creating an artificial price for trading in financial products on a financial market operated in this jurisdiction, or of maintaining such a price at a level that is artificial, whether or not it was previously artificial.1
False trading and market rigging (s 1041B). A person must not do, or omit to do, an act that has or is likely to have the effect of creating, or causing the creation of, a false or misleading appearance of active trading in financial products on such a market, or a false or misleading appearance with respect to the market for, or the price for trading in, those products (s 1041B(1)). A person is taken to create a false or misleading appearance of active trading if they enter into or carry out, directly or indirectly, a transaction of acquisition or disposal that involves no change in beneficial ownership, or make an offer at a specified price while having made, proposing to make, or knowing that an associate has made or proposes to make, an offer the other way for the same or substantially the same number of products at substantially the same price (s 1041B(2)). Those are not the only circumstances that can create such an appearance. There is no change in beneficial ownership if a person with an interest before the transaction, or an associate, has an interest after it (s 1041B(3)).2
Artificial transactions (s 1041C). A person must not enter into or engage in a fictitious or artificial transaction or device that results in the price for trading in financial products on such a market being maintained, inflated or depressed, or in fluctuations in that price. That the parties intended the transaction to have effect according to its terms is not conclusive that it is not fictitious or artificial (s 1041C(2)).3
Dissemination about illegal transactions (s 1041D). A person must not circulate or disseminate, or be involved in circulating or disseminating, a statement or information to the effect that the price of financial products on such a market will, or is likely to, rise, fall or be maintained because of a transaction or other act that constitutes or would constitute a contravention of s 1041A, 1041B, 1041C, 1041E or 1041F, if the person or an associate has entered into such a transaction or done such an act, or has received or may receive a consideration or benefit for circulating or authorising the circulation of the statement.4
Each section operates independently of the others, and nothing in one limits the scope of another unless the Division expressly provides otherwise (s 1041J), so the same facts can found more than one contravention.5
What makes a price artificial
Section 1041A does not define “artificial price”. In Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v JM [2013] HCA 30 the High Court (a joint judgment of all seven Justices) rejected the Victorian Court of Appeal majority’s view that the expression was confined to conduct of the kind typified by American “cornering” and “squeezing” by a dominant market participant (at [77]). It took market manipulation to be centrally concerned with conduct, intentionally engaged in, that has resulted in a price that does not reflect the forces of supply and demand (at [70]). Those forces are created by buyers who aim to acquire at the lowest available price and sellers who aim to sell at the highest realisable price, so a transaction by an on-market buyer or seller of listed shares who acts for the sole or dominant purpose of setting or maintaining the price at a particular level creates or maintains an artificial price (at [71]-[72]).16
Three features of JM matter for application. First, because the section prohibits transactions that are likely to have the effect, it is not necessary to show by counterfactual analysis that an artificial price was actually created or maintained (at [73]), or, where the transaction was made for that purpose, that it went on to affect genuine buyers and sellers (at [74]). Second, purpose is not a separate element: proof of a sole or dominant purpose, without distinction between the two, is one way of showing that the transaction was at least likely to have the effect, and the Court did not consider other ways (at [75]-[76]). Third, the Court confined its reasons to on-market transactions in shares listed on the ASX and left open whether other kinds of transaction create or maintain an artificial price (at [58], [71]). The case was a pre-trial case stated on facts the prosecution alleged and the defendant did not admit: a purchase in the closing auction said to have been made so that the closing price did not fall to the level at which a lender could make a margin call. The Court answered the reserved questions “Yes” on that assumed purpose (at [6], [24]).16
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Soust [2010] FCA 68, a decision of a single judge, applied the same reasoning to ss 1041A and 1041B(1)(b) in civil penalty proceedings. The managing director of a thinly traded ASX-listed company placed, through a broker and in his mother’s account, a market-price order for about $2,550 of its shares some 25 minutes before the close of the last trading day of the year; it lifted the price from 2.0 to 2.5 cents and secured a bonus that depended on the year-end share price (at [7], [10], [18]-[21]). On uncontested facts Goldberg J found that he intended to raise the last sale price to obtain the bonus (at [64]), held that an “artificial price” is one created not to implement a transaction between genuine parties wishing to buy and sell but for a purpose unrelated to the interplay of genuine supply and demand (at [90]), and found contraventions of s 1041A(c) and s 1041B(1)(b) (at [98]-[99]). Penalty was adjourned (at [112]).17
Fault, defences and relief
Section 1041A specifies no fault element. In Soust Goldberg J treated the absence of an intention element as a deliberate change from the former s 997 of the Corporations Law, noting Treasury commentary on the draft provisions that civil contravention of the new provisions would not require that element (at [80]).17 For an offence, s 1041B(1A), inserted with effect from 13 December 2010, specifies intention as the fault element for doing or omitting to do the act and recklessness as the fault element for the effect, so it was not part of the section when Soust was decided.2 Where the Act specifies no fault element for a physical element, the Criminal Code supplies intention for conduct and recklessness for a circumstance or result (s 5.6); the sources cited here do not say how that applies to the “effect” limbs of ss 1041A and 1041C.14 In civil penalty proceedings it is not necessary to prove a person’s state of mind, except to the extent that the civil penalty provision or a related provision expressly provides otherwise, and the rule does not apply to attempting to contravene or being involved in a contravention or affect the mistake of fact provision (s 1317QB(1)-(4)).11
Division 4 adds a defence to a prosecution for an offence based on a provision of the Part, committed by publishing an advertisement, where the defendant’s business was publishing or arranging publication of advertisements, they received it in the ordinary course of that business, and they did not know and had no reason to believe that publishing it would be an offence; the defendant bears an evidential burden. In civil penalty proceedings the court may relieve such a person wholly or partly from liability (s 1044A).6 Section 1317S separately allows relief for a person who acted honestly and ought fairly to be excused.12
Consequences
Criminal. A contravention of s 1041A, s 1041B(1), s 1041C(1) or s 1041D is an offence (s 1311(1)), and Schedule 3 specifies 15 years’ imprisonment for each. Imprisonment is the only penalty specified and is 10 years or more, so an individual is liable to imprisonment, a fine or both, the fine not exceeding the greater of 4,500 penalty units and, if the court can determine the benefit derived and detriment avoided, three times that amount (ss 1311A(1), 1311B(1)(b), (4)); a body corporate’s fine does not exceed the greatest of 45,000 penalty units, three times that benefit and detriment, and 10 per cent of annual turnover for the relevant 12 months (ss 1311A(1), 1311C(1)(b), (3)).7 A penalty unit is set under s 4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) and is $364 from 1 July 2026, and the increased amount only applies to offences committed on or after that date (s 4AA(8)).89 In JM the High Court recorded a maximum of up to five years’ imprisonment for the conduct charged and noted that the maximum has since been increased (at [3], n 7).16
Civil. Those four sections are financial services civil penalty provisions (s 1317E(3)). ASIC may apply for a declaration of contravention, a pecuniary penalty order or a compensation order; any other person who suffers damage may apply for a compensation order; and proceedings must start within six years of the contravention (ss 1317J, 1317K). A pecuniary penalty requires a declaration and that the contravention materially prejudice acquirers, disposers or the issuer, or be serious, and is capped for an individual at the greater of 5,000 penalty units and three times the benefit derived and detriment avoided (s 1317G(1), (3)). A compensation order may be made for damage resulting from the contravention, including profits made by any person, whether or not a declaration has been made (s 1317HA).10 The action for loss in s 1041I is given for contraventions of ss 1041E to 1041H and does not name ss 1041A to 1041D; liability under other laws is not addressed here.5 In Soust Goldberg J noted that ss 1041A and 1041B are contraventions only of financial services civil penalty provisions, and that the power under s 206C to disqualify a person from managing corporations is enlivened by a declaration of contravention of a corporation/scheme civil penalty provision (at [109], [111]).1713 A court must not make a declaration or a pecuniary penalty order against a person convicted of an offence constituted by substantially the same conduct (s 1317M), civil proceedings for those orders are stayed once criminal proceedings start for it (s 1317N), and criminal proceedings may follow civil ones (s 1317P(1)).11
The misleading-statement provisions
Sections 1041E to 1041H are covered separately. Sections 1041E (false or misleading statements), 1041F (inducing persons to deal) and 1041G (dishonest conduct) are offences and are not listed as civil penalty provisions in s 1317E(3); s 1041H (misleading or deceptive conduct) creates civil liability only; a contravention of any of them can found an action for loss under s 1041I.5 The two groups can apply to one scheme: s 1041D itself refers to transactions or acts contravening s 1041E or 1041F, and the High Court has observed that a person who supplies false information may contravene the market misconduct provisions while a recipient who trades may contravene the insider trading provisions (Mansfield v The Queen; Kizon v The Queen [2012] HCA 49, at [41]).15
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the products and the market: financial products traded on a financial market operated in this jurisdiction (each of ss 1041A to 1041D says so).
- Identify the conduct and pick the section by what it does: a transaction affecting price (s 1041A), an act creating a false appearance of active trading or of the market or price (s 1041B), a fictitious or artificial transaction or device (s 1041C), or circulating a statement about the price effect of one of those (s 1041D). More than one can apply (s 1041J).
- For ss 1041A and 1041B, ask what effect the conduct had or was likely to have, using purpose as evidence of it: for an on-market purchase or sale of ASX-listed shares, a sole or dominant purpose of setting or maintaining the price makes the price artificial (JM; Soust). JM does not decide other kinds of transaction.
- For no change in beneficial ownership or matched offers, apply s 1041B(2) and (3), remembering that those are not the only circumstances that can create a false or misleading appearance.
- Separate the offence from the civil penalty claim: s 1041B(1A) fixes fault elements for the offence, and s 1317QB(1) concerns proof of state of mind in civil penalty proceedings and is subject to s 1317QB(4).
- Check Division 4 and s 1317S for relief, and state the consequences for the track in play, including a compensation order (s 1317HA), not an action under s 1041I, and how one track affects the other (ss 1317M to 1317P).