Market manipulation and false trading

The four prohibitions

Section 1041A bans market manipulation. A person must not take part in transactions that create, or are likely to create, an artificial price for financial products on an Australian market. This includes keeping a price artificial, even if it was artificial before.

Section 1041B bans false trading and market rigging. A person must not act, or fail to act, in a way that creates a false or misleading appearance of active trading, or of the market or price for products. Certain conduct automatically counts as creating this false appearance: trades with no real change in beneficial ownership, or matched buy-and-sell offers at the same price and quantity, including through an associate. These are examples only; other conduct can also count. Ownership does not change if the same person or an associate still holds the interest afterward.

Section 1041C bans artificial transactions. A person must not enter into a fictitious or artificial transaction or device that maintains, inflates, depresses, or causes fluctuations in the price of financial products. Even if the parties meant the transaction to operate as written, that does not necessarily stop it being fictitious or artificial.

Section 1041D bans dissemination about illegal transactions. A person must not spread, or help spread, information suggesting a product’s price will move or stay the same because of conduct that breaches s 1041A, 1041B, 1041C, 1041E or 1041F. This applies only if the person or an associate actually did that conduct, or received or may receive a benefit for spreading the information.

The misleading-statement provisions

Sections 1041E to 1041H are dealt with separately from the main scheme. Sections 1041E, 1041F and 1041G are offences. They are not listed as civil penalty provisions under s 1317E(3).

Section 1041H works differently. It creates civil liability only, not a criminal offence. A breach of any of these sections (1041E, 1041F, 1041G or 1041H) can support a claim for loss under s 1041I.

These provisions can overlap with the main scheme. Section 1041D itself refers to transactions or acts that contravene s 1041E or 1041F. So conduct can trigger both sets of provisions at once.

The High Court illustrated this overlap in Mansfield v The Queen; Kizon v The Queen [2012] HCA 49. It observed that someone who supplies false information may contravene the market misconduct provisions. Meanwhile, a person who receives that information and trades on it may separately contravene the insider trading provisions.

Applying this in a problem question

First, identify the products and market. The products must be financial products traded on a financial market operated in this jurisdiction. Each of ss 1041A to 1041D requires this.

Next, match the conduct to the right section. A transaction affecting price falls under s 1041A. An act creating a false appearance of active trading, or of the market or price, falls under s 1041B. A fictitious or artificial transaction or device falls under s 1041C. Circulating a statement about the price effect of one of these falls under s 1041D. More than one section can apply at once (s 1041J).

For ss 1041A and 1041B, ask what effect the conduct had, or was likely to have. Purpose can be evidence of that effect. For an on-market purchase or sale of ASX-listed shares, a sole or dominant purpose of setting or maintaining the price makes the price artificial (JM; Soust). JM does not settle the position for other kinds of transactions.

Where there is no change in beneficial ownership (who truly owns the shares), or where offers are matched, apply s 1041B(2) and (3). These provisions are not the only situations that can create a false or misleading appearance.

Keep the criminal offence separate from the civil penalty claim. Section 1041B(1A) sets the fault elements (the mental state needed) for the offence. Section 1317QB(1) deals with proving state of mind in civil penalty proceedings, subject to s 1317QB(4).

Finally, check Division 4 and s 1317S for possible relief. State the consequences that follow, including a compensation order under s 1317HA rather than an action under s 1041I, and note how the criminal and civil tracks can affect each other (ss 1317M to 1317P).

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →