Continuous disclosure by listed entities
How the continuous disclosure obligation of ASX-listed entities works: Listing Rule 3.1 and its carve-out, the elements in ss 674 to 677 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and the split since August 2021 between the s 674(2) offence and the fault-based civil penalty provision in s 674A.
Learning outcomes
- Identify whether a listed entity’s failure to disclose engages s 674(2), s 674A(2) or both, by reference to the date of the conduct and the proceeding brought.
- Apply the elements of the obligation (having the information, not generally available, material effect under ss 676 and 677) to a set of facts.
- Determine whether information falls within the Listing Rule 3.1A carve-out by testing each of its three cumulative conditions.
- Explain the fault element in s 674A(2)(d), the liability of persons involved under s 674A(3) and (4), and how far cases decided before August 2021 remain usable.
A company or trust listed on the ASX must tell the market, as it happens, information that a reasonable person would expect to move the price of its securities. The obligation starts in the ASX Listing Rules and is picked up and enforced by Chapter 6CA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), which is Commonwealth law; no State or Territory statute forms part of the regime described here. Before asking whether an entity should have disclosed something, a student must ask a prior question: which statutory provision is being enforced, and against conduct on what date? Since 14 August 2021 a failure to disclose is an offence under s 674(2), and a civil penalty contravention under s 674A(2) only if the entity knew, or was reckless or negligent about, the information’s effect on price; the answer decides what must be proved and how far the older cases apply.
Where the obligation comes from
ASX Listing Rule 3.1 is the general rule: once an entity is or becomes aware of any information concerning it that a reasonable person would expect to have a material effect on the price or value of its securities, the entity must immediately tell ASX that information.11 The ASX Guidance Note 8 says that “immediately” is read as “promptly and without delay”, not “instantaneously”.12
Section 674(1) of the Corporations Act applies the statutory obligation to a listed disclosing entity whose market’s listing rules require it to notify the market operator of information about specified events or matters as they arise, so that the operator can make it available to participants in the market.1 The statute requires notification “in accordance with those provisions”, so the Rule’s own terms, including its exceptions and its definition of awareness, shape the statutory obligation.
The elements
Section 674(2) and s 674A(2) share their first three paragraphs. The obligation arises where:
- the entity has information that the listing rules require it to notify to the market operator;
- the information is not generally available; and
- in s 674(2)(d), a reasonable person would expect the information, if it were generally available, to have a material effect on the price or value of ED securities of the entity.
Section 674A(2)(d) replaces the third element with a fault element.2
Having the information. Listing Rule 19.12, as Guidance Note 8 and the Full Federal Court state it, treats an entity as aware of information if, and as soon as, an officer has, or ought reasonably to have, come into possession of it in the course of the performance of their duties as an officer.12 In Crowley v Worley Ltd (2022) 293 FCR 438; [2022] FCAFC 33 the Full Court held that information includes opinions, and that what a corporation ought reasonably to have includes opinions an officer ought to have formed from facts known to the officer; otherwise an entity could avoid disclosure by its officers simply not forming the opinion.15 The appeal was allowed and the case remitted, and special leave to appeal to the High Court was refused. On remitter the trial judge found that Worley had contravened s 674(2), and in Crowley v Worley Ltd [2026] FCAFC 78 a later Full Court dismissed Worley’s cross-appeal on liability.16
Not generally available. Section 676 says information is generally available if it consists of readily observable matter, or if it has been made known in a manner that would, or would be likely to, bring it to the attention of persons who commonly invest in securities of a kind whose price might be affected and a reasonable period for dissemination has elapsed; deductions, conclusions or inferences drawn from readily observable matter, or from information made known in that way, are also generally available.3 In Grant-Taylor v Babcock & Brown Ltd (in liq) [2016] FCAFC 60 the Full Court said these limbs are read disjunctively, that the test is objective, and that information may be readily observable even if no one has observed it.14
Material effect. For s 674, s 677(1) deems a reasonable person to expect a material effect if the information would, or would be likely to, influence persons who commonly invest in securities in deciding whether to acquire or dispose of the ED securities.4 In Babcock & Brown the Full Court read “persons who commonly invest in securities” as a class description, not a test of how sophisticated, large or frequent an individual investor is, and wider than the class in s 676, which looks at investors in securities of the relevant kind. It also said material information must be non-trivial at least, and that “may” or “might” influence is not enough. On the facts that construction did not help the shareholders: the trial judge’s unchallenged findings that the dividend and financial-report information was economically irrelevant stood, there was no insolvency information requiring disclosure, and the appeal was dismissed.14
The carve-out and the false-market rule
Listing Rule 3.1A takes information outside Rule 3.1 while three conditions are all satisfied: one of five situations applies (disclosure would breach a law; the information concerns an incomplete proposal or negotiation; it comprises matters of supposition or is insufficiently definite to warrant disclosure; it is generated for internal management purposes; or it is a trade secret); the information is confidential and ASX has not formed the view that it has ceased to be confidential; and a reasonable person would not expect it to be disclosed.11 On the Rule’s terms the conditions are cumulative and must continue to be met: once confidentiality is lost, the exception ends even if the negotiation is still incomplete.
Under Listing Rule 3.1B, if ASX considers there is or is likely to be a false market and asks for information to correct or prevent it, the entity must immediately give it, and the Rule’s note says this applies even if the Rule 3.1A exception applies.11
Two provisions since August 2021: the offence and the civil penalty
Parts 1 to 3 of Schedule 2 to the Treasury Laws Amendment (2021 Measures No. 1) Act 2021 (Cth) commenced on 14 August 2021.9 It removed s 674(2) and (2A) from the civil penalty table in s 1317E, repealed s 674(2A) and (2B), and inserted s 674A, whose subsections (2) and (3) took their place in the table. The amendments apply to conduct engaged in on or after that day (s 1683A).
Section 674(2): the offence. Failure to comply with s 674(2) is an offence under s 1311(1), and s 674(2) is not listed among the civil penalty provisions in the s 1317E table.1 Section 674 itself states no fault element; s 678 applies the Criminal Code to an offence based on s 674(2), and Chapter 2 of the Code sets out the general principles of criminal responsibility, including fault elements, that then govern.5 ASIC may also issue an infringement notice to an entity it has reasonable grounds to believe has contravened s 674(2), and in deciding whether to do so must have regard to the market operator’s guidelines on the listing rules.6
Section 674A(2): the civil penalty provision. Section 674A(2) is identical to s 674(2) except for paragraph (d), which requires that the entity “knows, or is reckless or negligent with respect to whether, the information would, if it were generally available, have a material effect on the price or value of ED securities of the entity”. Section 677(2) supplies the same “persons who commonly invest” test for that knowledge, recklessness or negligence.4 Subsection (2) is a financial services civil penalty provision, so compensation orders are available under s 1317HA; it does not create an offence; and s 674A(7) displaces the general rule in s 1317QB(1) that no state of mind need be proved in civil penalty proceedings.2
People involved. Under s 674A(3), a person involved in the entity’s contravention of s 674A(2), in the s 79 sense, contravenes s 674A(3), which is also a financial services civil penalty provision. Under s 674A(4) the person does not contravene if they prove they took all steps (if any) that were reasonable in the circumstances to ensure the entity complied, and after doing so believed on reasonable grounds that it was complying.2
Closing the side door. A claim cannot avoid the fault element by being pleaded as misleading or deceptive conduct. Under s 1041H(4), an entity’s conduct that does not contravene s 674A(2), but would if s 674A(2)(d) had the same text as s 674(2)(d), does not contravene s 1041H(1).7 Section 12DA(3) of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) does the same for misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to financial services.8
Reform not yet made. The report of an independent review required by s 1683B was tabled in May 2024. In its response of 12 August 2024 the Government agreed to remove the requirement for ASIC to prove knowledge, recklessness or negligence in civil penalty proceedings, to retain it for private litigants for the time being, and to legislate how a state of mind is attributed to the entity.10 None of those changes is made in the compilation of the Act dated 19 September 2026, so the fault element still applies to ASIC’s civil penalty proceedings as well as to private compensation claims.
Reading the older cases
Forrest v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2012] HCA 39, Babcock & Brown and Crowley v Worley were all decided under the provisions as they stood before 14 August 2021, when s 674(2) was itself a civil penalty provision with no fault element, s 674(2A) caught people involved, and s 674(2B) gave them the reasonable-steps defence. The paragraphs the cases construe were re-lettered in 2021: what Babcock & Brown calls s 674(2)(c)(i) and (ii) are now s 674(2)(c) and (d). The cases are best used element by element, an approach drawn from comparing the two texts rather than from anything the cases decided: their reasoning on having the information, general availability and material effect goes to words that survive in s 674(2) and s 674A(2)(a) to (c), and “persons who commonly invest in securities” reappears in s 677(2). Nothing in them decides what knowledge, recklessness or negligence requires under s 674A(2)(d), and none of them was a criminal prosecution.
In Forrest the High Court held that Fortescue’s announcements that it had made binding contracts with three Chinese companies to build, finance and transfer the project’s railway, port and mine were not misleading or deceptive, and that this disposed of ASIC’s primary case under s 674: having lawfully made those statements, Fortescue was not required to tell the market that the agreements were not binding. Because the statements accurately conveyed what the agreements provided, s 674 did not require Fortescue to publish their text.13 The Court did not reach the arguments on directors’ involvement or the reasonable-steps defence.
A research trap: the Guidance Note 8 annexure on Corporations Act consequences, even as amended in May 2024, still describes s 674(2) as a civil penalty provision and refers to s 674(2A) and (2B).12 Use the Act for the statutory consequences.
Misleading statements and directors’ duties
A statement that is made, rather than withheld, raises misleading or deceptive conduct under s 1041H, which has its own article. ASIC may also allege that a director breached the duty of care and diligence in s 180(1), discussed in Directors’ statutory duties; in Forrest that claim against Mr Forrest depended on showing a contravention of s 1041H or s 674, and failed with them.13 Shareholder compensation claims are commonly brought as representative proceedings; Babcock & Brown was a damages claim by 77 persons and entities who had bought the company’s shares.
Applying this in a problem question
- Establish that the entity is a listed disclosing entity whose market’s listing rules impose a continuous disclosure obligation, and identify the date of the conduct: before or after 14 August 2021.
- Identify the information precisely and ask whether an officer had, or ought reasonably to have, come into possession of it; after Crowley v Worley, decided on the pre-2021 text, that can include an opinion the officer ought to have formed.
- Test general availability under s 676: readily observable matter; information made known and disseminated; or inferences drawn from readily observable matter or from information made known in the specified manner, which s 676(3) does not make wait for the dissemination period.
- Test materiality through s 677: would the information, or would it be likely to, influence persons who commonly invest in securities in deciding whether to acquire or dispose of the entity’s securities.
- Check whether every condition of Listing Rule 3.1A is satisfied, including confidentiality, and whether ASX has asked for information under Rule 3.1B.
- Choose the provision. For a prosecution, use s 674(2) with the Criminal Code’s fault rules. For conduct before that date the former s 674(2), (2A) and (2B) apply. For ASIC civil penalty proceedings or a compensation claim on conduct from 14 August 2021, use s 674A(2) and prove knowledge, recklessness or negligence about material effect; for an officer, add involvement under s 674A(3) and consider the s 674A(4) defence.
Self-check
- Have I identified whether the conduct occurred before or after 14 August 2021?
- Have I kept the offence in s 674(2) apart from the civil penalty provision in s 674A(2)?
- Have I applied each condition of Listing Rule 3.1A, rather than treating confidentiality or an incomplete negotiation alone as enough?
- Have I used an older case for an element that survives in the current text, and not for the s 674A fault element?
- Have I checked for legislation implementing the Government’s 2024 response?