Continuous disclosure by listed entities

Where the obligation comes from

This duty comes from two sources. ASX Listing Rule 3.1 says a listed entity must immediately tell ASX any information a reasonable person would expect to affect the price or value of its securities. The entity must be aware of that information first.

“Immediately” does not mean instant. ASX Guidance Note 8 says it means promptly and without delay.

Section 674(1) of the Corporations Act backs this up with a statutory obligation. It applies where listing rules require notifying the market operator about certain events, so the operator can share that information with the market.

The statute says notification must happen “in accordance with those provisions”. This means Listing Rule 3.1’s own terms, including its exceptions and its definition of awareness, shape what the statutory duty requires.

The carve-out and the false-market rule

Listing Rule 3.1A creates an exception to the general disclosure rule. Three conditions must all be met together.

First, one of five situations must apply. These include: disclosure would break a law; the information is about an incomplete proposal; it is mere supposition; it is for internal management use; or it is a trade secret.

Second, the information must still be confidential. ASX must not have decided it has stopped being confidential.

Third, a reasonable person would not expect the information to be disclosed. All three conditions must keep being satisfied, not just at the start. If confidentiality ends, the exception ends too, even if talks are still incomplete.

Listing Rule 3.1B deals with false markets, where the market has wrong information about an entity. If ASX believes there is, or is likely to be, a false market, it can ask the entity for information. The entity must give that information immediately.

Importantly, this duty applies even where the Rule 3.1A exception would otherwise excuse disclosure.

Reading the older cases

These three cases - Forrest v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2012] HCA 39, Babcock & Brown and Crowley v Worley - were decided under the law before 14 August 2021. Then, s 674(2) was a civil penalty provision with no fault element. Section 674(2A) caught people involved in a contravention, and s 674(2B) gave them a reasonable-steps defence.

The 2021 reforms relettered some paragraphs. What Babcock & Brown called s 674(2)(c)(i) and (ii) are now s 674(2)(c) and (d).

Use these cases element by element, not for their overall results. Their reasoning on having information, general availability, and material effect still helps interpret s 674(2) and s 674A(2)(a) to (c). The phrase “persons who commonly invest in securities” reappears in s 677(2).

None of these cases decide what knowledge, recklessness or negligence requires under s 674A(2)(d). None was a criminal prosecution.

In Forrest, the High Court held Fortescue’s announcements about binding contracts with three Chinese companies were not misleading. This defeated ASIC’s main case under s 674. Because the statements accurately described the agreements, Fortescue did not need to disclose that the agreements weren’t actually binding.[^cite:forrest-v-asic-2012-hca-39] The Court did not decide the separate arguments about directors’ involvement or the reasonable-steps defence.

A research trap: the ASX Guidance Note 8 annexure on Corporations Act consequences, even as amended in May 2024, still wrongly describes s 674(2) as a civil penalty provision. It still refers to the old s 674(2A) and (2B).[^cite:asx-guidance-note-8] Check the Act itself for the current statutory consequences.

Misleading statements and directors’ duties

If a company actually makes a statement, rather than staying silent, that can be misleading or deceptive conduct under s 1041H.

ASIC may also claim a director breached the duty of care and diligence in s 180(1). But in Forrest, that claim depended on first proving a breach of s 1041H or s 674. It failed once those claims failed.

Shareholders seeking compensation often bring representative proceedings, where a group sues together. Babcock & Brown was one such case, brought by 77 shareholders claiming damages.

Self-check

Before finishing, check a few things.

Work out whether the conduct happened before or after 14 August 2021. This date matters for which rules apply.

Keep the criminal offence in s 674(2) separate from the civil penalty provision in s 674A(2). They are different and should not be mixed up.

Apply every condition of Listing Rule 3.1A. Confidentiality alone, or an incomplete negotiation alone, is not enough on its own.

If using an older case, make sure it supports an element that still applies under the current text. Do not use it for the fault element in s 674A.

Finally, check whether any legislation now implements the Government’s 2024 response.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →