The Australian Consumer Law framework

One text applied nine times: the Australian Consumer Law is Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), applied as a law of the Commonwealth by s 131 and as a law of each State and Territory by that jurisdiction’s own application Act, with the regulator, the courts, the interpretation statute and, in Western Australia, the version of the text itself all supplied locally.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, act, nsw, nt, qld, sa, tas, vic, wa
Subjects
consumer-and-competition-law
Topics
consumer-and-competition-framework

Learning outcomes

  • Explain that the Australian Consumer Law is a single text in a Commonwealth schedule, applied separately as a law of the Commonwealth and of each State and Territory.
  • Identify, on given facts, whether the Australian Consumer Law applies as a law of the Commonwealth, of a State or Territory, or of both, and name the application provision.
  • Name the applied law, its regulator, its courts and its interpretation statute from the applying Act, rather than referring to ‘the ACL’ unqualified.
  • Identify the two respects in which the scheme is not uniform: the Western Australian version of the text, and the exclusion of financial services from the Commonwealth application.

Australian consumer protection is not nine bodies of law, and it is not quite one either. It is one text, enacted once in a Commonwealth schedule and then applied nine times — once by the Commonwealth and once by each State and Territory — as a law of the applying jurisdiction. Before asking whether conduct breached the Australian Consumer Law, a student must ask a prior question: as whose law does it apply on these facts? The answer settles which application provisions govern, which regulator acts, which court hears the matter, which interpretation statute is used and, in one jurisdiction, which version of the text is in force.

One text, held in a Commonwealth schedule

The ACL is not a standalone Act, and there is no statute called the Australian Consumer Law. The Australian Consumer Law text consists of Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) together with the regulations made under s 139G of that Act. Each applying Act sets out that definition itself, and the three set out here do so in the same words: Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 27,4 Australian Consumer Law and Fair Trading Act 2012 (Vic) s 75 and Fair Trading Act 1989 (Qld) s 15.6 Each points at the Commonwealth text rather than reproducing it, which is how a Commonwealth amendment reaches the applied laws at all — though, as the sections below show, not automatically in every jurisdiction.

That is also why citation is unusual here. The prohibitions students meet — misleading or deceptive conduct, unconscionable conduct, unfair contract terms, the consumer guarantees — sit in numbered sections of Schedule 2, not of the host Act, and the section number alone does not say which jurisdiction’s version is in play.

Applying as a law of the Commonwealth

Section 131(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) provides that “Schedule 2 applies as a law of the Commonwealth to the conduct of corporations”, and in relation to contraventions of Chapter 2, 3 or 4 of Schedule 2 by corporations.1

Read the limit carefully: the Commonwealth application is expressed by reference to corporations, not to consumers or to conduct generally. Section 131(2) then extends four particular parts of Schedule 2 beyond that limb — s 21 to supplies or acquisitions of goods or services between any person and a corporation, s 147 to a corporation as a supplier, Division 2 of Part 5-1 where the other person referred to in s 219 is a corporation, and s 33 to the conduct of any person. A note to s 131(1) adds that ss 5 and 6 of the host Act extend the application of the Part, and so of the applied Law.

What the Commonwealth application leaves out

The Commonwealth limb has a carve-out that catches students out, and it is drawn by subject matter rather than by respondent. Section 131A provides that, despite s 131, the Division does not apply to the supply or possible supply of services that are financial services, or of financial products, other than in relation to Division 3A of Part 3-2, Division 3A of Part 4-2 and Part 5-5 of Schedule

  1. Section 131A(2) spells out two consequences that matter most: Part 2-1 of Schedule 2, which

contains the misleading or deceptive conduct prohibition, does not apply to conduct in relation to financial services, and Part 2-3, the unfair contract terms regime, does not apply to contracts that are financial products or contracts for the supply of financial services.2

The conduct is not unregulated; it is regulated by a different statute. Section 12DA(1) of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) provides that a person “must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct in relation to financial services that is misleading or deceptive” or is likely to mislead or deceive.3 So on facts involving a financial service the Schedule 2 prohibition is the wrong provision to cite, and the error is invisible if the only question asked was whether the conduct was misleading.

Section 12DA is not a clean substitute, and it has carve-outs of its own. Section 12DA(1A) takes out conduct contravening the misleading takeover, fundraising and crowd-sourced funding provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and conduct in relation to a disclosure document or statement within the meaning of s 953A or s 1022A of that Act. Section 12DA(3) adds a continuous-disclosure carve-out. Conduct that “does not contravene subsection 674A(2) of the Corporations Act, but would contravene that subsection if paragraph 674A(2)(d) of the Corporations Act contained the same text as paragraph 674(2)(d)” — and the matching case for ss 675A(2) and 675(2)(b) — “does not contravene subsection (1) of this section”. Those subsections, as the Act’s own note says, “deal with continuous disclosure of information by disclosing entities”, and they carry a fault element that ss 674 and 675 do not. The practical effect is that a continuous-disclosure failure which escapes ss 674A and 675A for want of that fault element cannot be re-run as misleading or deceptive conduct under s 12DA(1); and by s 12DA(4) conduct still “contravenes” a provision for this purpose even where it is not an offence, or attracts no liability, because a defence is available.3 Section 131A operates on the Commonwealth application; whether a State’s applied law is cut back in the same way is a question for that State’s own Act and is not answered here.

Applying as a law of a State or Territory

Each participating jurisdiction applies the same text as its own law through its own application Act, and the operative provisions are in a common form: the text “applies as a law of this jurisdiction”, “may be referred to as the Australian Consumer Law (jurisdiction)”, and “is a part of this Act”. (Western Australia is the exception in one respect: under s 19(2) of its Act only the Schedule 2 component is part of the Fair Trading Act 2010 (WA), and the component that constitutes regulations is subsidiary legislation.) The applying provision and the name it gives the applied law are:

JurisdictionApplication ActProvisionApplied law
New South WalesFair Trading Act 1987 (NSW)s 28(1)Australian Consumer Law (NSW)
VictoriaAustralian Consumer Law and Fair Trading Act 2012 (Vic)s 8(1)Australian Consumer Law (Victoria)
QueenslandFair Trading Act 1989 (Qld)s 16(1)Australian Consumer Law (Queensland)
Western AustraliaFair Trading Act 2010 (WA)s 19(2)Australian Consumer Law (WA)
South AustraliaFair Trading Act 1987 (SA)s 14(1)Australian Consumer Law (SA)
TasmaniaAustralian Consumer Law (Tasmania) Act 2010 (Tas)s 6(1)Australian Consumer Law (Tasmania)
Australian Capital TerritoryFair Trading (Australian Consumer Law) Act 1992 (ACT)s 7(1)Australian Consumer Law (ACT)
Northern TerritoryConsumer Affairs and Fair Trading Act 1990 (NT)s 27(1)Australian Consumer Law (NT)

Seven of those eight apply the text “as in force from time to time”, so a Commonwealth amendment takes effect in the jurisdiction without further action — South Australia,8 Tasmania,9 the Australian Capital Territory10 and the Northern Territory11 in the same words as New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland. Each application is also expressly subject to the three sections that follow it, headed in each Act future modifications of the Australian Consumer Law text, the meaning of generic terms (in the Northern Territory, the meaning of “regulator”) and interpretation of the Australian Consumer Law: ss 29 to 31 in New South Wales, ss 9 to 11 in Victoria, ss 17 to 19 in Queensland, ss 15 to 17 in South Australia, ss 7 to 9 in Tasmania, ss 8 to 10 in the Australian Capital Territory and ss 28 to 30 in the Northern Territory. Section numbers therefore differ in every jurisdiction even where the words do not, and one jurisdiction’s application section number is not authority for another’s.

Western Australia applies a different text

Western Australia is the exception, and it is a substantive one rather than a matter of numbering. Section 19(1) of the Fair Trading Act 2010 (WA) defines the text it applies as Schedule 2 “as in force on 1 June 2021 and as amended by each provision” that is in an amending law having effect under s 19B and that has come into operation under s 19C. An amending law has effect only if it is laid before each House of Parliament and is not disallowed, the notice period being 14 sitting days and the disallowance period 30 sitting days; the Governor must then declare that fact by proclamation as soon as practicable. Which commencement branch applies is then fixed by a stated time — whether the amending provision “has come into operation in the Commonwealth before the proclamation is published in the Gazette”. If it has, the provision commences for the purposes of s 19 on a day fixed by the proclamation (s 19C(3)); if it has not, it commences for those purposes when it comes into operation in the Commonwealth in accordance with the amending law (s 19C(4)).7

The consequence for a student’s answer is practical: a Commonwealth amendment to Schedule 2 cannot be assumed to be in force as part of the Australian Consumer Law (WA). Nor is the position in the other jurisdictions quite automatic. Section 29 of the Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) lets a future Commonwealth modification be excluded by proclamation, and s 9 of the Victorian Act by Order of the Governor in Council. The two-month clock runs to publication, not to the making of the instrument. A New South Wales proclamation “has effect only if published or notified no later than 2 months after the date of the modification” (s 29(2)), and a Victorian Order “has effect only if published before the end of 2 months after the date of the modification” (s 9(2)). Each Act then fixes the date the clock runs from: “the date of the modification is the date on which the Commonwealth Act effecting the modification receives the Royal Assent or the regulation effecting the modification is registered” under the Commonwealth legislative-instruments legislation (NSW s 29(4); Vic s 9(4)). In each case a later instrument can reverse the exclusion (NSW s 29(3); Vic s 9(3)). The scheme is accordingly substantially uniform rather than uniform, and the question “is this amendment in force here?” is answered from the applying Act.

What the local Act supplies

An applied text cannot name its own institutions, so each jurisdiction fills the generic terms, and this is where the practical differences live. Under Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 30 the “regulator” in the Australian Consumer Law (NSW) is the Secretary, and the “court” is the Local Court, the District Court or the Supreme Court, with s 218, Division 2 of Part 5-2, Division 4 of Part 5-2 and “sections 246, 247, 248 and 250” reserved to the Supreme Court — the enumeration skips s 249 — and the Tribunal included for Part 2-3. Those meanings are expressly “subject to any jurisdictional limits on the court concerned or the Tribunal imposed by any other Act” (s 30(5)), and the “court” definition itself applies “unless otherwise expressly provided by this Act” (s 30(2)). Under the Victorian Act s 10 the regulator is the Director, and the meaning of “court” is taken from s 223 of that Act. The prohibition is word-for-word the same; the body that enforces it and the court that hears it are not.

Two further substitutions are easy to miss. Each applying Act chooses the interpretation statute: Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 31 and the Victorian Act s 11 each apply the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) to the applied law and expressly disapply the State’s own interpretation Act, so an argument built on a State interpretation provision is built on the wrong statute. And each applying Act sets the territorial reach: Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 32 and the Victorian Act s 12 apply the law to persons carrying on business in the jurisdiction, bodies corporate incorporated or registered under its law, persons ordinarily resident there and persons otherwise connected with it, and extend it to conduct occurring outside the jurisdiction. That is a different connecting factor from the Commonwealth’s corporate one, and the two overlap rather than divide neatly, so the same conduct may engage more than one application law at once.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the conduct and locate the prohibition in Schedule 2 — which Chapter, which section.
  2. Ask whether the subject matter is a financial service or financial product. If it is, check s 131A before citing Schedule 2, and consider s 12DA of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) instead.
  3. Ask whether the respondent is a corporation. If so, Schedule 2 applies as a law of the Commonwealth under s 131(1), and check whether s 131(2) extends the provision relied on.
  4. Ask what connects the respondent to a State or Territory — business carried on there, incorporation or registration, residence, or another connection — and identify that jurisdiction’s application Act and section.
  5. Name the applied law in the form the application Act gives it, rather than writing “the ACL” unqualified, and substitute the local regulator, court and interpretation statute before naming any of them.
  6. In Western Australia, check under ss 19B and 19C whether the amendment relied on has effect there; elsewhere, check whether a modification has been excluded under the applying Act’s future-modifications provision.

Self-check

  • Have I said which jurisdiction’s application of the ACL governs, rather than treating it as one law?
  • Have I cited the prohibition to Schedule 2, and the application separately to the applying Act and its own section number?
  • Have I checked whether the subject matter is a financial service, which s 131A removes from the Commonwealth application?
  • Have I identified the regulator, the court and the interpretation statute from the local Act rather than assuming the ACCC and the State’s own interpretation Act?
  • Have I checked that the version of the text I am relying on is in force in the jurisdiction, rather than assuming the current Commonwealth text applies everywhere?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.