Product Disclosure Statements: Part 7.9

Part 7.9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth): when a Product Disclosure Statement must be given to a retail client, what it must contain, what makes disclosure defective and the offences, private action and ASIC stop order that follow, with the Financial Services Guide and the contrast with the regime for securities.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
investment-and-financial-regulation
Topics
product-disclosure

Learning outcomes

  • Decide whether Part 7.9 applies to a product, and whether a Product Disclosure Statement must be given in a recommendation, issue or sale situation to a retail client.
  • State the content, form and currency requirements for a PDS, including the limits on what must be included.
  • Distinguish the two definitions of defective disclosure and state the offences, civil penalty, private action and stop order that follow, including the liable persons under s 1022B.
  • Explain how the Financial Services Guide differs from a PDS and why the general misleading conduct provisions do not apply to a disclosure document within s 1022A.

Division 2 of Part 7.9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) requires a Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) to be given to a retail client in defined situations and prescribes what it must contain; Divisions 6 and 7 of the Part attach offences, civil penalties, a private action for loss and an ASIC stop order power to a PDS that is missing or defective. This is Commonwealth legislation; no State or Territory legislation is stated here. Part 7.9 does not generally govern securities: apart from specified provisions, nothing in it applies in relation to securities, and Chapters 6CA and 6D provide for disclosure in relation to securities (s 1010A(1) and Note 1).1 The prior question in a problem is therefore whether the product is one to which Part 7.9 applies, who is a regulated person, and whether the situation is one the Act names, before asking whether the statement given was adequate.

When a PDS must be given

Apart from Division 5A, which is not examined here, Part 7.9 does not apply to a product not issued in the course of a business of issuing financial products; issuing a managed investment product or superannuation product is taken to be in the course of such a business (s 1010B(1), (2)).1 The obligation falls on a regulated person: an issuer; a seller in the secondary-sale circumstances in s 1012C(5), (6) or (8); any financial services licensee or authorised representative; certain exempt persons; and a person who is required to hold a licence but does not (s 1011B). Subject to an exception for certain issues made in this jurisdiction, the sections apply to offers and recommendations received in this jurisdiction (s 1011A(1), (2)).1 Each of the three obligations below is framed around a retail client: a financial product is provided to a person as a retail client unless s 761G(5), (6), (6A) or (7) or s 761GA provides otherwise, and is otherwise provided as a wholesale client (s 761G(1), (4)).2

Three situations give rise to the obligation, each by a separate section.3

  • Recommendation (s 1012A(3)). A regulated person gives personal advice to a retail client that includes a recommendation to acquire a product by issue, or by a transfer in the s 1012C secondary-sale circumstances. The PDS must be given at or before the time the advice is provided.
  • Issue (s 1012B(3), (4)). A regulated person offers to issue the product, offers to arrange its issue, or issues it where there are reasonable grounds to believe the client has not been given a PDS, to a retail client; the PDS must be given at or before the offer or issue. If the client offers to acquire a product by issue, the PDS must be given before the client becomes bound.
  • Sale (s 1012C). An offer to sell is caught where a sale would take place in the circumstances in s 1012C(5), (6) or (8): an off-market sale by a controller of the issuer; an offer made within 12 months after an issue for which no PDS was prepared, where the onward-sale purpose test is met; and an offer within 12 months after a controller’s off-market sale, where no PDS was prepared for that sale and the onward-sale purpose test is met.

Contravention of s 1012A, 1012B or 1012C is a civil penalty provision (ss 1012A(5), 1012B(6), 1012C(11)). Each section is subject to exceptions (ss 1012A(4), 1012B(5), 1012C(10)). The general exceptions apply where the client has already received a PDS containing all the information the new one would have to contain, or the regulated person reasonably believes so; and where the client already holds a product of the same kind and the regulated person reasonably believes the client has received, or has and knows they have access to, all that information through a PDS and information provided under ss 1017B to 1017D or through continuous disclosure under Chapter 6CA (s 1012D(1), (2)). Further exceptions, including small scale offerings, are in ss 1012DAA to 1012G and are not examined here.3 A PDS for an issue statement must be prepared by the issuer, and a sale statement by the seller (s 1013A).4

Content and form

A PDS must carry the title “Product Disclosure Statement” at or near the front (s 1013B) and must include the statements and information required by s 1013D, the information required by s 1013E and the information required by the other provisions of the Subdivision (s 1013C(1)(a)). It may include or refer to other information (s 1013C(1)(b)). The information must be worded and presented in a clear, concise and effective manner (s 1013C(3)), and information required by ss 1013D and 1013E need only be included to the extent it is actually known to the responsible person and the other persons listed in s 1013C(2).4

Section 1013D(1) requires the issuer’s name and contact details and such of the following as a person would reasonably require to decide, as a retail client, whether to acquire the product: significant benefits and risks; cost and amounts payable after acquisition; commissions that may affect a return; other significant characteristics and the rights, terms, conditions and obligations; the dispute resolution system; significant tax implications; any cooling-off regime; how other information can be accessed; any prescribed information; for an investment product, how labour standards and environmental, social or ethical considerations are taken into account; and, unless the regulations allow otherwise, the benefit, cost and commission amounts in dollars. Section 1013E adds that the PDS must contain any other information that might reasonably be expected to have a material influence on the decision of a reasonable person, as a retail client, whether to acquire the product. Section 1013F(1) limits both: information is not required if it would not be reasonable for a person considering the product as a retail client to expect to find it in the PDS.4

The information must be up to date when the PDS is given (s 1012J). A Supplementary PDS can correct a misleading statement or omission or update the PDS, and once given is taken to form part of it (ss 1014A, 1014D). Where the client already has a PDS containing some of the required information, a Supplementary PDS with the additional information may be given instead of a new PDS (s 1014E).4

Defective disclosure and its consequences

Two definitions of “defective” apply, and they differ. For the offences and civil penalties in Subdivision A of Division 7, a document is defective if it contains a misleading or deceptive statement, or (for a PDS) omits material required by s 1013C (other than material required by s 1013B or 1013G), being a statement or omission that is or would be materially adverse from the point of view of a reasonable person considering whether to proceed to acquire the product (s 1021B(1)). The definition in s 1022A(1), which applies to the private action and the stop order power, uses similar heads (with further heads for offer documents) but its text as compiled does not repeat the “materially adverse” qualifier. Under either, out-of-date information contrary to s 1012J is treated as a misleading statement, and a failure to include newly required information as an omission (ss 1021B(1A), 1022A(1A)).56

Offences and civil penalties. A person who prepares a disclosure document (other than the oral information required by s 1012G(3)(a)) and gives it where one is required, or gives or makes it available reckless as to whether the recipient will rely on it, contravenes s 1021E if it is defective, whether or not they knew; there is no contravention if the person took reasonable steps to ensure it would not be defective (s 1021E(1)-(3)). Contravention is an offence (s 1021E(5)) and a civil penalty provision (s 1021E(8)). Knowingly giving a defective document is a separate offence (ss 1021D, 1021F).5

Private action. Under s 1022B(2), a person who suffers loss or damage because the required PDS was not given, or because the PDS given was defective, may recover it by action against the liable person where a PDS required by Part 7.9 was not given (s 1022B(1)(a)), or a defective PDS was given in circumstances where one was required, or a regulated person gave or made available a defective PDS reckless as to whether the client would rely on it (s 1022B(1)(c)). It applies whether or not anyone has been convicted. For a defective PDS the liable persons are the person by whom or on whose behalf it was prepared and each other person involved in its preparation who directly or indirectly caused or contributed to the defect, with a substitution where an unauthorised alteration made the document defective (s 1022B(3)(b), (5)). In a defective-document situation under s 1022B(1)(c), a person is not liable if they took reasonable steps to ensure the document would not be defective (s 1022B(7)); that defence is not stated for the failure-to-give situation in s 1022B(1)(a). The action may be begun within six years, and the section does not affect liability under any other law (s 1022B(6), (8)). The court may also declare the client’s contract void and make consequential orders, including for return of money (s 1022C). No decision awarding damages under s 1022B is cited here.6

Other misleading conduct provisions are displaced. Conduct in relation to a disclosure document or statement within s 1022A does not contravene s 1041H(1) of the Corporations Act, or s 12DA(1) of the ASIC Act.910

A responsible entity case. In ASIC v Theta Asset Management Ltd [2020] FCA 1894, the responsible entity of a retail managed investment scheme and its managing director admitted contraventions arising from several PDSs. McKerracher J made agreed declarations that Theta contravened s 601FC(1)(b) in issuing PDSs that were defective within s 1022A because they contained a misleading or deceptive statement (that distributions would be sufficient to enable retirees to pay the rent due on their leases) and did not disclose in a clear, concise and effective manner matters such as conflicts of interest, the risks of different unit classes and income support from a related group. The declarations of contravention were made under s 1317E(1) of ss 601FC and 601FD, not of s 1021E. The court ordered a pecuniary penalty of $2,000,000 against Theta, and a penalty of $100,000 and four years’ disqualification against the managing director, on declarations that he breached his officer’s duties, including in authorising the PDSs.11

The stop order power

ASIC may make a stop order under s 1020E where a disclosure document or statement is defective in the s 1022A sense, or does not comply with the requirement to be worded and presented in a clear, concise and effective manner. The order may provide that specified conduct in respect of the financial products to which the document relates must not be engaged in while the order is in force. ASIC must hold a hearing and give interested people a reasonable opportunity to make submissions, but may make an interim order without a hearing, lasting 21 days unless revoked, where delay would prejudice the public interest. Acting contrary to an order is an offence.7

The Financial Services Guide

Subject to the exceptions in s 941C, a licensee must give a Financial Services Guide (FSG) to a person to whom it provides a financial service as a retail client (s 941A(1)), and an authorised representative must do so where it provides such a service (s 941B(1)); each is a civil penalty provision. A licensee’s FSG must include its name and contact details, the services its licence authorises, who it acts for, remuneration and benefits received for the services, and associations with product issuers that might influence it (s 942B(2)). The FSG tells the client about the provider; the PDS tells the client about the product, and a given transaction may require both.8

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Ask whether the Division 2 PDS regime applies: the product must not be a security (subject to the specified exceptions) and must be issued in the course of a business of issuing financial products.
  2. Identify the regulated person, the retail client and the situation: recommendation, issue or sale. Check each element of the section, including timing and, for a sale, the secondary-sale circumstances.
  3. Check the exceptions, including whether the client already has an up-to-date PDS or access to the information.
  4. Test the content: the matters in s 1013D(1) to the extent a retail client would reasonably require them, other material information under s 1013E, subject to s 1013F, clear, concise and effective presentation, and up-to-date information (s 1012J).
  5. If the PDS is defective, use the definition that matches the remedy (s 1021B for offences and civil penalties; s 1022A for the private action and a stop order). Ask whether the preparer took reasonable steps and who is a liable person under s 1022B(3).
  6. State the consequences separately: criminal or civil penalty proceedings, a private claim for loss within six years, an ASIC stop order, and, for a responsible entity, the duties it breaches by issuing the PDS (Theta).

Self-check

  • Have I confirmed the PDS regime applies, rather than the regime for securities, and used the right definition of “defective” for the remedy?