The AFS licensing regime and licensee obligations
The Australian financial services licensing regime in Part 7.6 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth): when a licence is required and who is exempt, what a financial product and financial service are, authorised representatives, the general licensee obligations in s 912A, ASIC’s powers to condition, suspend or cancel a licence, and the consequences of unlicensed conduct.
Learning outcomes
- Decide whether conduct is the provision of a financial service in a financial services business, by classifying the product, the advice and the dealing.
- Test the licence requirement in s 911A against the exemptions, the representative rules and the scope of the licence.
- State the general obligations in s 912A, identify which paragraphs are civil penalty provisions, and apply the standard as the cases describe it.
- State ASIC’s powers over a licence and the consequences of unlicensed conduct, including the client’s rescission rights.
Part 7.6 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) requires a person who carries on a financial services business to hold an Australian financial services licence (AFSL), and imposes continuing obligations on every licensee. This is Commonwealth legislation; no State or Territory legislation is stated here. In a problem about a person who advises on or deals in investments, ask in order: is the person providing a financial service, in a financial services business carried on in this jurisdiction; if so, are they licensed for that service, exempt, or acting as another licensee’s representative; and, if licensed, has the licensee met the general obligations in s 912A? The answers decide whether the exposure is unlicensed conduct, action against the licence, or a licensee’s breach of its standard of conduct.
What triggers the requirement
A person who carries on a financial services business in this jurisdiction must hold an AFSL covering the provision of the financial services (s 911A(1)). A business is taken to be carried on in this jurisdiction if, in the course of carrying it on, the person engages in conduct intended, or likely, to induce people in this jurisdiction to use the services (s 911D).4 The sections cited here do not define a “financial services business” and no case on that threshold is cited, so a problem turning on it needs authority beyond this article.
A person provides a financial service if, among other things, they provide financial product advice, deal in a financial product, make a market for one, operate a registered scheme, provide a custodial or depository service, or provide a claims handling and settling service (s 766A(1)). Clerical or cashier work is not a financial service (s 766A(3)).3 For services such as financial product advice and dealing, the service concerns a financial product: a facility through which, or through the acquisition of which, a person makes a financial investment, manages financial risk or makes non-cash payments (s 763A(1)), as ss 763B to 763D explain.2
Two definitions decide many problems. Financial product advice is a recommendation or statement of opinion intended, or reasonably regarded as intended, to influence a decision about a particular financial product or class; it is personal advice if the provider considered, or a reasonable person might expect it to have considered, one or more of the person’s objectives, financial situation and needs (other than for anti-money-laundering compliance), and general advice otherwise (s 766B(1), (3), (4)). Legal advice given by a lawyer in a professional capacity is not financial product advice (s 766B(5)(a)). Dealing includes applying for or acquiring a product, issuing, varying or disposing of it, and arranging for another to do so unless the actions amount to providing financial product advice; a person who deals on their own behalf is not dealing unless they are an issuer dealing in their own products (s 766C).3 In the Westpac litigation the Full Court held that a telephone campaign to move customers’ superannuation gave personal advice. In Westpac Securities Administration Ltd v ASIC [2021] HCA 3 the High Court dismissed Westpac’s appeal, holding that on the undisputed facts a reasonable person might expect Westpac to have considered the member’s objectives, financial situation or needs; it did not express a concluded opinion on the Full Court’s approach.1312
Exemptions, representatives and licence scope
Section 911A(2) exempts a service provided in listed circumstances, including as a representative of a licensee (or of an exempt person) who carries on the business; the issue, variation or disposal of a product under a licensee’s intermediary authorisation; general advice by a newspaper’s proprietor or publisher, or by means of public transmissions or recordings, on the conditions in paragraphs (ea) to (ec); insolvency office-holders; services to related bodies corporate only; services as trustee of a self managed superannuation fund; services by an APRA-regulated body, where APRA has supervisory responsibilities, to wholesale clients only; and exemptions prescribed by regulation or specified by ASIC. A defendant bears an evidential burden for an exemption. No paragraph of s 911A(2) exempts operating a registered scheme or a traditional trustee company service (s 911A(4)).4
A representative who is exempt must still comply with s 911B, which allows a service to be provided on behalf of a principal in listed circumstances, for example as an employee or director of a licensee whose licence covers the service, as its authorised representative with an authorisation covering the service, or under the person’s own licence (s 911B(1)). A licensee authorises a representative by written notice specifying the services, and the authorisation is void to the extent it purports to cover a service the licence does not cover (s 916A). A licensee cannot be the authorised representative of another licensee, subject to an exception for binders (ss 916D(1), 916E), and an authorised representative generally cannot sub-authorise (s 916B(1)).17 A person must not hold out that they hold a licence or that a service is exempt when that is not so (s 911C).4
The licensee answers for its representatives. Where a representative acts for one licensee, that licensee is responsible, as between licensee and client, for conduct of the kind described in s 917A whether or not within authority, unless the lack of authority was clearly and prominently disclosed to the client before reliance (ss 917B, 917D); the responsibility extends to loss the client suffers and gives the client the same remedies against the licensee (ss 917E, 917F(1)).7 In ASIC v AGM Markets, Beach J held that a contractual prohibition on unlawful conduct in an agreement with a company that supplied account managers did not of itself relieve the licensee of responsibility for conduct done on its behalf.14
The general obligations in s 912A
A licensee must (s 912A(1)):
- do all things necessary to ensure the financial services covered by the licence are provided efficiently, honestly and fairly (para (a));
- have adequate arrangements for managing conflicts of interest (para (aa));
- comply with licence conditions (para (b)) and the financial services laws (para (c)), a term that includes Chapter 7 and Division 2 of Part 2 of the ASIC Act;
- take reasonable steps to ensure its representatives comply with the financial services laws, subject to the insurance claims handling exception in para (ca);
- subject to s 912A(4), have adequate resources; maintain competence; and ensure representatives are adequately trained and competent (paras (d) to (f));
- if services go to retail clients, have a compliant dispute resolution system, including membership of the AFCA scheme (para (g)); and
- subject to s 912A(5), have adequate risk management systems (para (h)).
Section 912A(5A) makes a contravention of paragraphs (a), (aa), (ca), (cc), (d), (e), (f), (g), (h) or (j) a civil penalty provision; paragraphs (b) and (c) are not in that list. Section 912B adds compensation arrangements for retail clients.51 Sections 911A(5B), 911B(4) and 912A(5A) appear in the s 1317E(3) table as uncategorised, meaning neither a corporation/scheme nor a financial services civil penalty provision. A pecuniary penalty therefore needs a declaration of contravention without the further conditions that apply to categorised provisions, but s 1317HA compensation orders, which require a financial services civil penalty provision, are not available for them.10
ASIC’s powers over the licence
ASIC must grant a licence if the application complies, it has no reason to believe the applicant is likely to contravene s 912A, the fit and proper person test in s 913BA, which extends beyond the applicant to others such as officers and controllers, is satisfied and any prescribed requirements are met, but must refuse if satisfied that the application or material lodged in response to a request was false in a material particular, materially misleading or omitted a material matter (s 913B(1), (2)). It may impose, vary or revoke conditions at any time, but must first offer the licensee a hearing before imposing or varying them unless the licensee applied or they are imposed on grant (s 914A). It may suspend or cancel immediately on specified events, such as an individual’s conviction for serious fraud or a body corporate ceasing to carry on the business, and must cancel where the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort operator has paid compensation for an AFCA determination the licensee was required to pay (s 915B). After offering a hearing it may suspend or cancel if the licensee has not complied with s 912A, ASIC has reason to believe it is likely to do so, the fit and proper person test is not satisfied, a banning order is made, or the application was false, misleading or omitted a material matter (s 915C). ASIC may also make a banning order against a person who has not complied with s 912A (s 920A(1)(b)).6 On ASIC’s application a court may make orders it thinks fit for a contravention of Chapter 7 if satisfied that no one is unfairly prejudiced (s 1101B).11
Consequences of unlicensed conduct
Carrying on the business without a licence is an offence (s 911A(1); Schedule 3 states five years’ imprisonment) and a civil penalty provision (s 911A(5B)). Breach of s 911B is also both (five years), and holding out is an offence (two years).910 Where a non-licensee who is not exempt enters, in the course of a financial services business, an agreement with a client who is not a licensee that constitutes or relates to the provision of a financial service by the non-licensee, the client may also rescind by written notice within a reasonable time after becoming aware of the facts, unless the client affirmed the agreement or was told within a reasonable period before it was made that the non-licensee held no licence (s 925A). Rescission takes effect unless it would prejudice a right or estate acquired by a third party in good faith, for value and without notice of the facts entitling the client to give notice (s 925B). While the client is entitled to give a notice that would rescind the agreement, and after rescission, the non-licensee cannot enforce or rely on the agreement against the client (s 925E). It also cannot recover brokerage or commission while the client is entitled to give notice, or after notice is given even if rescission does not result (s 925F), and a client who gives notice may recover commission already paid (s 925H). These remedies are additional to others (s 925I).8
What the cases show about s 912A
In ASIC v Westpac Securities Administration Ltd [2019] FCAFC 187, the Full Court (Allsop CJ, Jagot and O’Bryan JJ) upheld the finding that Westpac contravened s 912A(1)(a) by a campaign calculated to have customers make, after general advice, a decision that could prudently be made having regard to their personal circumstances. Allsop CJ reserved whether the phrase “efficiently, honestly and fairly” is compendious, and O’Bryan J had considerable reservations about reading it that way. The High Court’s later decision addressed whether the advice was personal. Beach J, in AGM Markets, applied the compendious reading as a single judge, held that dishonesty in the criminal sense need not be established and that a contravention does not require breach of a separate duty, and described the provision as principally a licensee disciplinary command directed at the licensee’s behaviour generally; he found AGM’s training, monitoring and due diligence over outsourced functions deficient.1214
In ASIC v RI Advice Group Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 496, decided on agreed facts, Rofe J declared that a licensee contravened s 912A(1)(a) and (h) by lacking adequate cybersecurity documentation and controls across its authorised representatives’ network, noting that para (h) had not been the subject of relevant prior judicial consideration.15 In ASIC v Citigroup Global Markets Australia Pty Ltd (No 4) [2007] FCA 963, Jacobson J held s 912A(1)(aa) was not engaged because ASIC’s case depended on a fiduciary relationship the court did not find, and added that managing conflicts does not require eliminating them.16
Applying this in a problem question
- Ask whether the person provided a financial service: advice, dealing or another listed service. Classify any advice as personal or general by testing both actual consideration of the person’s circumstances and what a reasonable person might expect (s 766B(3)(a) and (b)).
- Ask whether a financial services business is carried on in this jurisdiction (s 911D), and whether a licence covers the service. A service outside the licence’s scope is not covered.
- Test each exemption in s 911A(2), remembering the evidential burden on the defendant. If the person acts for another, check s 911B and s 916A, and whether the licensee answers for the conduct under ss 917B to 917F.
- For a licensee, identify which paragraph of s 912A is engaged, and whether it is a civil penalty paragraph. Do not assume para (a) requires dishonesty or breach of a separate duty (AGM Markets).
- Identify the consequence sought: criminal or civil penalty, a suspension, cancellation or banning order, or the client’s rescission rights.
Self-check
- Have I classified the advice or dealing before testing for a licence?
- Have I separated unlicensed conduct (s 911A) from a licensee’s breach of s 912A, and kept paras (b) and (c) apart from the civil penalty paragraphs?