The AFS licensing regime and licensee obligations

The general obligations in s 912A

An AFS licensee must meet several duties under s 912A(1). It must do everything necessary to provide the licensed financial services efficiently, honestly and fairly (para (a)), and have adequate arrangements to manage conflicts of interest (para (aa)).

The licensee must also comply with its licence conditions (para (b)) and the financial services laws (para (c)). “Financial services laws” includes Chapter 7 and Division 2 of Part 2 of the ASIC Act.

It must take reasonable steps to ensure its representatives comply with those laws, except for the insurance claims handling exception in para (ca). Subject to s 912A(4), it must also have adequate resources, maintain competence, and ensure representatives are properly trained (paras (d)-(f)).

Where services are provided to retail clients, the licensee needs a compliant dispute resolution system, including AFCA membership (para (g)). Subject to s 912A(5), it must also maintain adequate risk management systems (para (h)).

Section 912A(5A) makes breaches of paragraphs (a), (aa), (ca), (cc), (d), (e), (f), (g), (h) or (j) civil penalty provisions. Paragraphs (b) and (c) are not included. Section 912B separately requires compensation arrangements for retail clients.

Sections 911A(5B), 911B(4) and 912A(5A) are listed as “uncategorised” in the s 1317E(3) table. This means they are neither corporation/scheme provisions nor financial services civil penalty provisions.

Because they are uncategorised, a pecuniary penalty only needs a declaration of contravention, without the extra conditions that apply to categorised provisions. However, compensation orders under s 1317HA are not available, since those require a financial services civil penalty provision.

Consequences of unlicensed conduct

Running a financial services business without a licence breaks the law. It is both a criminal offence and a civil penalty provision (s 911A(1), (5B)). The maximum prison term is five years.

Breaching s 911B works the same way. It is also a criminal offence and a civil penalty provision, carrying up to five years’ imprisonment. Falsely claiming to be licensed (“holding out”) is a separate offence, carrying up to two years.

Section 925A gives extra protection to clients. If an unlicensed, non-exempt provider enters a financial services agreement with a client, the client may rescind. Rescission means cancelling the agreement. The client must give written notice within a reasonable time of discovering the facts.

This rescission right has limits. It does not apply if the client affirmed the agreement, or was told beforehand that the provider was unlicensed. It also will not defeat a third party’s rights, if that third party acted in good faith, gave value, and did not know the relevant facts (s 925B).

Once the client can give notice, or after they do, the provider loses certain rights. The provider cannot enforce the agreement against the client (s 925E). It also cannot recover brokerage or commission, even if rescission does not end up occurring (s 925F).

A client who does rescind can recover any commission already paid (s 925H). All these client remedies are additional to other remedies available at law (s 925I).

What the cases show about s 912A

The Full Court in Westpac upheld a finding that Westpac breached s 912A(1)(a). This happened through a campaign pushing customers towards a decision after only general advice, where that decision needed to suit their personal situation.

Allsop CJ left open whether “efficiently, honestly and fairly” should be read as one combined phrase (called a compendious reading) rather than three separate requirements. O’Bryan J doubted that compendious reading. A later High Court decision dealt with a different question: whether the advice given was actually personal advice.

In AGM Markets, Beach J (sitting alone) adopted the compendious reading. He held that dishonesty in the criminal sense is not required to prove a breach. He also said a contravention under s 912A(1)(a) doesn’t need a separate duty to have been broken. He described the provision mainly as a general disciplinary standard for licensees. On the facts, he found AGM’s training, monitoring and oversight of outsourced work fell short.

In RI Advice, decided on agreed facts, Rofe J declared the licensee breached both s 912A(1)(a) and s 912A(1)(h). The problem was inadequate cybersecurity documentation and controls across its representatives’ network. Rofe J noted that s 912A(1)(h) hadn’t previously been judicially considered on this point.

In Citigroup, Jacobson J held s 912A(1)(aa) didn’t apply. ASIC’s case relied on there being a fiduciary relationship, which the court did not find existed. Jacobson J also noted that managing conflicts of interest doesn’t mean a licensee must eliminate them entirely.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by asking whether the person gave a financial service. This could be advice, dealing, or another listed service. If it is advice, work out whether it is personal or general. Test this two ways: did the person actually consider the client’s circumstances, and what would a reasonable person expect (s 766B(3)(a) and (b)).

Next ask whether a financial services business operates in this jurisdiction (s 911D). Then check whether a licence actually covers that service. A service outside the licence’s scope is not covered.

Then test each exemption in s 911A(2). Remember the defendant carries the evidential burden here. If the person acted for someone else, check s 911B and s 916A. Also ask whether the licensee is answerable for that conduct under ss 917B to 917F.

If dealing with a licensee, work out which paragraph of s 912A applies, and whether it is a civil penalty provision. Do not assume paragraph (a) requires dishonesty or breach of some separate duty — this reflects the reasoning in AGM Markets.

Finally, identify what consequence is being sought. This might be a criminal or civil penalty, a suspension, cancellation or banning order, or the client’s rescission rights.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →