Managed investment schemes: definition, exclusions and registration

What makes an arrangement a managed investment scheme under s 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), which arrangements are excluded, when a scheme must be registered, and the consequences of operating one unregistered.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
investment-and-financial-regulation
Topics
managed-investment-schemes

Learning outcomes

  • Apply the three features of the s 9 definition of a managed investment scheme to an arrangement, and identify the exclusion or regulation that removes it from the definition.
  • State when a scheme must be registered under s 601ED, how the count of members is made, and what the registration process requires.
  • Identify the consequences of operating an unregistered scheme: the offence and civil penalty, a winding up under s 601EE, and a subscriber’s right to avoid under s 601MB.
  • Explain how the treatment of litigation funding arrangements has changed from Brookfield to Stanwell and the current regulation 5C.11.01, and say which of them states the current position.

Chapter 5C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) regulates managed investment schemes, and a student given an investment arrangement has two prior questions. First, does the arrangement fall within the definition of a “managed investment scheme” in s 9? Second, if it does, must it be registered with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)? The answers decide whether it needs a registered responsible entity, a constitution and a compliance plan, or is an unregistered scheme that the Act prohibits. This is Commonwealth law, stated from the Act as compiled to 19 September 2026; State and Territory legislation is not covered.

The definition in section 9

Section 9 defines a managed investment scheme as a scheme with three features, or a time-sharing scheme, less a list of exclusions.1 The three features are cumulative:

  1. people contribute money or money’s worth as consideration to acquire rights (interests) to benefits produced by the scheme, whether the rights are actual, prospective or contingent and whether or not they are enforceable;
  2. any of the contributions are to be pooled, or used in a common enterprise, to produce financial benefits, or benefits consisting of rights or interests in property, for the people who hold interests in the scheme (the members); and
  3. the members do not have day-to-day control over the operation of the scheme, whether or not they have the right to be consulted or to give directions.

Burton v Arcus [2006] WASCA 71, a decision of the Court of Appeal of Western Australia on this Commonwealth definition, shows how the features are read.11 Buss JA, with whom Steytler P and McLure JA agreed, held that the money must be contributed to acquire the rights to benefits, and that “contribute” means to pay or supply, to or as directed by the promoter or operator (at [56]-[57]). The third feature concerns control in fact by the members as a whole, not a legal right to control: they have day-to-day control only if, as a whole, they take part in the routine, ordinary, everyday management decisions and are bound by them (at [79]-[80]), and the promoter’s or operator’s management on their behalf is not imputed to them (at [82]). Outside Western Australia the decision is persuasive, not binding.

Pooling needs more than an operator collecting money. In National Australia Bank Ltd v Norman [2009] FCAFC 152 the Full Court (Spender, Graham and Gilmour JJ) held that an accountant’s receipt of investors’ money into a trust account was not a managed investment scheme.12 Gilmour J, whose reasons Spender J adopted on the central question, said that the words “are to be pooled” require an intention, objectively discerned, forming part of the scheme and formed before the contributions are made, that they are to be pooled (at [148]; Spender J at [5]); Graham J held that contributors must have known, when contributing, that the money was to be pooled or used in a common enterprise (at [81]). Buss JA had said in Burton that pooling is satisfied where the operator in fact pools the money without the contributors’ agreement, approval or knowledge (at [68]-[70]). Graham J held that view plainly wrong (at [82]), and Gilmour J respectfully disagreed with it to the extent that it treated pooling by the recipient after the contribution as enough (at [147]). LCM Funding Pty Ltd v Stanwell Corporation Limited [2022] FCAFC 103, discussed below, later cited the prior-intention requirement as the Full Court’s view (Lee J at [19]).

What is excluded

Paragraphs (c) to (n) of the definition remove arrangements that would otherwise satisfy it. They include a body corporate (other than a body corporate that operates as a time sharing scheme); a franchise; a regulated superannuation fund, approved deposit fund, pooled superannuation trust or public sector superannuation scheme; a scheme operated by an Australian authorised deposit-taking institution in the ordinary course of its banking business; the issue of debentures or convertible notes by a body corporate; a retirement village scheme of the kind paragraph (l) describes; and the provision of a crowd-funding service. Other paragraphs cover narrower arrangements, so each must be read against the facts.1

Paragraph (n) excludes “a scheme of a kind declared by the regulations not to be a managed investment scheme”. It is the route by which the Corporations Regulations remove litigation funding schemes, discussed below.

When a scheme must be registered

A managed investment scheme must be registered if any one of three things is true (s 601ED(1)):5

  • it has more than 20 members;
  • it was promoted by a person, or an associate of a person, who was in the business of promoting managed investment schemes when the scheme was promoted; or
  • a determination by ASIC under s 601ED(3) that a number of schemes are closely related is in force and the total number of members of all the schemes it covers exceeds 20.

Joint holders of an interest count as one member, and an interest held on trust for a beneficiary is taken to be held by the beneficiary, not the trustee, if the beneficiary is presently entitled to a share of the trust estate or its income or, alone or with other beneficiaries, is in a position to control the trustee (s 601ED(4)).

Two exceptions apply. A scheme does not have to be registered if every issue of interests made would not have required a Product Disclosure Statement under Division 2 of Part 7.9 had the scheme been registered when the issues were made (s 601ED(2)); regulation 5C.11.05A adds to that test the words “and Division 2 of Part 7.9 applied to the interests at that time”.8 Whether a Product Disclosure Statement would have been required is a Part 7.9 question that this article does not cover. A notified foreign passport fund also does not have to be registered (s 601ED(2A)).

How a scheme is registered

A person applies to ASIC, naming the proposed responsible entity and a person who has consented to audit the compliance plan, and lodges the scheme’s constitution, its compliance plan and a statement signed by the proposed responsible entity’s directors that they comply with ss 601GA, 601GB and 601HA (s 601EA).2 The proposed responsible entity must be a public company that holds an Australian financial services licence authorising it to operate a managed investment scheme (s 601FA).4

ASIC must register the scheme within 14 days of lodgment unless it appears that the application, the proposed responsible entity, the constitution, the compliance plan (including its signing under s 601HC) or the audit arrangements under s 601HG do not meet the Act’s requirements, and then gives it an ARSN (s 601EB).3

Operating a scheme that should have been registered

A person must not operate in this jurisdiction a managed investment scheme that s 601ED requires to be registered unless it is registered (s 601ED(5)). Failure to comply is an offence under s 1311(1), and contravening subsection (5) also contravenes subsection (8), a civil penalty provision. A person is not operating a scheme merely because they act as an agent or employee of another, or are taking steps to wind the scheme up or to remedy a defect that led to deregistration (s 601ED(6)). A person who would otherwise contravene subsection (5) because an interest is held on trust for two or more beneficiaries does not do so if they prove they did not know, and had no reason to suspect, that it was held that way (s 601ED(7)).

“Operate” has its ordinary meaning: McLure JA in Burton described it as referring not to ownership or proprietorship but to acts that constitute the management or carrying out of the activities of the scheme (at [2]). Buss JA added that a scheme may begin without the three features and acquire them later, and that a scheme which has them at any time and is operated unregistered is liable to be wound up (at [84]).

Two further consequences follow. First, ASIC, the person operating the scheme or a member may apply to the Court to have the scheme wound up, and the Court may make any orders it considers appropriate (s 601EE).6 In Burton Buss JA considered it just and equitable to wind up an unregistered contributory mortgage scheme and appoint a receiver to sell the land (at [147]-[148]). Second, a person who contracts to subscribe for an interest in a scheme operated in contravention of s 601ED(5), in response to an offer or invitation from the offeror, may avoid the contract by written notice to the offeror. The notice takes effect after 21 days or, if the offeror applies within that time for a declaration that it had no effect, when that application and any appeals are finally determined; the Court may make the declaration if satisfied that it is just and equitable (s 601MB).7

Litigation funding: a definition that has moved

Whether a litigation funding arrangement is a managed investment scheme shows the definition being contested and then reshaped by regulation. The position has changed, and the current regulation governs the schemes it describes.

Brookfield (2009). In Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v International Litigation Funding Partners Pte Ltd [2009] FCAFC 147, a majority of the Full Court of the Federal Court (Sundberg and Dowsett JJ) held that the litigation funding arrangements and solicitors’ retainers for two representative proceedings satisfied the definition (at [82] and [103]). The contributions were the promises of the group members and of the funder (at [100]), and the funder and the solicitors, neither qualified to be a responsible entity under s 601FA, were together operating an unregistered scheme (at [104]). Jacobson J would have dismissed the appeal (at [304]).13

The 2020 regulations. The Corporations Amendment (Litigation Funding) Regulations 2020 replaced regulation 5C.11.01 with a version that declared not to be managed investment schemes an approved benefit fund, an insolvency litigation funding scheme and the arrangements in subregulations (4) and (5), but not a litigation funding scheme of the kind in new regulation 7.1.04N(3), whose interests it declared to be financial products. The amendments applied to schemes entered into on or after 22 August 2020 (regulation 10.38.01).9

Stanwell (2022). In Stanwell14 the primary judge had applied the grandfathering provision in regulation 10.38.01, so that the scheme was declared not to be a managed investment scheme (at [66]); the Full Court was asked whether Brookfield was correct. Reading the definition by its text, its context and the purpose of Chapter 5C, which Anderson J described as adequate and effective protection for investors (at [100], [103]), it held the majority’s reasoning plainly wrong and a scheme relevantly identical to the one in Brookfield plainly without the features in s 9(a)(i) and (ii) (Anderson J at [96], [166]-[167]; Middleton J at [2]; Lee J at [6]). The reasons included that the claim for relief exists separately from, and before, the funding scheme, so the benefit is not produced by it (Lee J at [15]), and that the register of interests, the identification of a responsible entity and provisions such as ss 601FM, 601GA(4), 601GC, 601KA and 601KB could not operate for a typical funding scheme (Anderson J at [158]-[165]). Stanwell is a decision of a Full Court of the Federal Court, not of the High Court. A student should not present Brookfield as the current position.

The 2022 regulations and today. The Corporations Amendment (Litigation Funding) Regulations 2022, in force from 10 December 2022, inserted regulation 5C.11.01(2A).10 A “litigation funding scheme” with all the listed features is declared not to be a managed investment scheme. Its dominant purpose must be for each general member to seek remedies to which they may be legally entitled, on claims that share a common issue or can appropriately be dealt with together; a lawyer must provide services in relation to the claims; a funder must provide funds or indemnities under a funding agreement; and the funder must not be a lawyer or legal practice providing a service for which some or all of the fees or disbursements are payable only on success. The regulation also declares an approved benefit fund, a funding scheme for a Chapter 5 body corporate and the arrangements in subregulations (4) and (5) not to be managed investment schemes. As compiled to 1 September 2026, subregulation (2A) is repealed on 1 December 2032 (reg 5C.11.01(7)), and what applies afterwards is not established by the sources cited here. Regulation 7.1.04N(2) declares an interest in a litigation funding scheme or litigation funding arrangement mentioned in regulation 5C.11.01 to be a financial product; the consequences of that declaration are outside this article.8

Whether third-party funding is lawful at all is a different question. In Campbells Cash and Carry Pty Ltd v Fostif Pty Ltd (2006) 229 CLR 386 the High Court said that it is not contrary to public policy and not an abuse of process merely because the funder controls the litigation and takes a share of the proceeds. The appeals were allowed because the representative-proceeding requirements were not met, and the Court went on to consider the funding questions after that (at [60]). The Fostif case note records the questions the Court left open.15

Applying this in a problem question

  1. State that this is Commonwealth law, with the section and compilation date relied on.
  2. Test each feature of s 9(a) against the facts: who contributes what, for what rights; whether there was an intention, formed before the contributions were made, to pool them or use them in a common enterprise for the members’ benefit; and whether the members as a whole have day-to-day control in fact.
  3. Check paragraphs (c) to (n), and any regulation made under paragraph (n).
  4. If it is a scheme, apply s 601ED(1) and (4), then the exceptions in s 601ED(2) and (2A).
  5. If registration was required and absent, identify who operated the scheme and the consequences: the offence and civil penalty, winding up under s 601EE, and a subscriber’s right to avoid under s 601MB, subject to s 601ED(6) and (7).
  6. For litigation funding, identify which version of regulation 5C.11.01 applies to the funding agreement and check that every listed feature is present.