Managed investment schemes: definition, exclusions and registration

What is excluded

Some arrangements are excluded from the definition, even if they would otherwise qualify. These exclusions appear in paragraphs (c) to (n).

Excluded arrangements include a body corporate (unless it runs a time sharing scheme), a franchise, and certain superannuation funds. They also include schemes run by an authorised deposit-taking institution as part of normal banking business, debenture or convertible note issues, certain retirement village schemes, and crowd-funding services.

Other paragraphs cover narrower situations, so you must check the specific facts against them.

Paragraph (n) is different: it excludes any scheme the regulations declare not to be a managed investment scheme. This is how the Corporations Regulations exclude litigation funding schemes, covered later in the article.

How a scheme is registered

To register a scheme, someone applies to ASIC. They must name the proposed responsible entity and someone who has agreed to audit the compliance plan (s 601EA).[^cite:corporations-act-s601ea-applying-for-registration]

The applicant also lodges the scheme’s constitution and compliance plan. They must include a signed statement from the proposed responsible entity’s directors, confirming compliance with ss 601GA, 601GB and 601HA.

The proposed responsible entity must be a public company. It must also hold an Australian financial services licence authorising it to run the scheme (s 601FA).[^cite:corporations-act-s601fa-responsible-entity-eligibility]

ASIC must register the scheme within 14 days of lodgment. This duty is not absolute, though.

ASIC need not register if the application, the proposed entity, the constitution, or the compliance plan fails to meet the Act’s requirements. This includes failures in signing the compliance plan under s 601HC, or in audit arrangements under s 601HG.

If ASIC does register the scheme, it gives the scheme an ARSN (s 601EB).[^cite:corporations-act-s601eb-registration]

Litigation funding: a definition that has moved

Whether litigation funding counts as a managed investment scheme has changed over time.

In Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v International Litigation Funding Partners Pte Ltd [2009] FCAFC 147, most judges (Sundberg and Dowsett JJ) held that litigation funding arrangements were a managed investment scheme. They found the group members and the funder had made “contributions” (promises to pay). Since neither the funder nor the solicitors were registered to run such a scheme, the scheme was unregistered and unlawful. Jacobson J disagreed and would have dismissed the appeal.

In 2020, new regulations changed this position. The Corporations Amendment (Litigation Funding) Regulations 2020 declared that most litigation funding schemes are not managed investment schemes. However, a specific kind of scheme described in regulation 7.1.04N(3) was excluded from this exemption; interests in that kind of scheme are instead treated as “financial products.” These changes applied only to schemes entered into on or after 22 August 2020.

In LCM Funding Pty Ltd v Stanwell Corporation Ltd [2022] FCAFC 103, the Full Court revisited Brookfield. The scheme involved predated the 2020 regulations, so the “grandfathering” clause applied, meaning the old exemption rule covered it. The Court held that Brookfield’s reasoning was “plainly wrong.” It found that a litigation funding scheme does not meet the statutory definition’s requirements, because the claimant’s right to relief exists independently of, and before, the funding arrangement — so the scheme does not “produce” the benefit. The Court also noted that several provisions dealing with scheme registration and investor interests could not sensibly apply to a typical litigation funding arrangement.

Applying this in a problem question

This is Commonwealth law. Say which section and compilation date you are using.

Check the facts against s 9(a). Ask who contributed what, and for what rights. Ask whether members intended, before contributing, to pool their contributions or use them in a common enterprise for their benefit. Ask whether members as a whole actually control the scheme day-to-day.

Also check paragraphs (c) to (n), including any regulation made under paragraph (n).

If it is a scheme, apply s 601ED(1) and (4). Then check the exceptions in s 601ED(2) and (2A).

If registration was required but missing, identify who operated the scheme. Consider the consequences: the offence and civil penalty, winding up under s 601EE, and a subscriber’s right to avoid the scheme under s 601MB. These are subject to s 601ED(6) and (7).

For litigation funding, work out which version of regulation 5C.11.01 applies to the funding agreement. Confirm every listed feature in that version is present.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →