Misleading conduct about financial products and services

Where the provisions stop

Some misleading conduct laws have carve-outs. Section 1041H, s 12DA and s 12DB step back where other specific rules already cover the document. Section 1041E has no such carve-out.

If conduct breaches the misleading takeover or fundraising document rules (ss 670A, 728, 738Y), or s 1021NA or 1021NB, it does not also breach s 1041H(1) (s 1041H(3)). The same applies to conduct covered by s 953A or s 1022A, which deals with Product Disclosure Statements.

Section 12DA(1A) and s 12DB(2) copy this carve-out, but leave out ss 1021NA and 1021NB. So conduct breaching those two sections can still contravene s 12DA(1) or s 12DB.

There is a further technical exception. Sometimes conduct does not breach s 674A(2) or s 675A(2) only because of how those sections are worded, but would breach them if worded like the matching paragraph in s 674(2) or s 675(2). In that situation, the conduct is not treated as breaching s 1041H(1) or s 12DA(1) either (s 1041H(4); s 12DA(3)).

What the cases show

In Forrest v Australian Securities and Investments Commission; Fortescue Metals Group Ltd v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2012] HCA 39, ASIC said Fortescue’s announcements of “binding contracts” with Chinese state-owned companies were misleading or deceptive under s 1041H. The High Court, whose decisions bind lower Australian courts, allowed the appeals.

The joint reasons ask what the statements conveyed to their intended audience. That is judged by the ordinary or reasonable member of that audience. The announcements conveyed what the parties had done and said they had done. They did not convey that an Australian court would enforce the agreements, and ASIC showed no further message.

The inquiry is hypothetical, so it answers both whether conduct is misleading and whether it is likely to mislead. What matters is what the statement conveyed, not what the maker says was intended. The Court laid down no general proposition about what a public statement of a contract conveys.

The Court also held that alleging a person knew a statement was false is an allegation of fraud. It must be pleaded specifically and kept separate from the misleading conduct case, which must identify what the statements conveyed.

ASIC’s continuous disclosure claim was decided on s 674 as it stood before 14 August 2021. From that date, Schedule 2 to the Treasury Laws Amendment (2021 Measures No. 1) Act 2021 (Cth) removed s 674(2) from the civil penalty provisions. It placed civil penalty liability in s 674A, which requires that the entity knows, or is reckless or negligent as to whether, the information would have a material effect on price. It also added s 1041H(4).

In Wingecarribee Shire Council v Lehman Brothers Australia Ltd (in liq) [2012] FCA 1028, Rares J, sitting alone at first instance in the Federal Court, held that the respondent (then Grange Securities) contravened s 12DA(1). It had represented to councils that synthetic collateralised debt obligations suited conservative investors, and that it followed prudent, conservative practices. He remarked on the differences in wording between the two provisions.

The respondent also ran the defences attaching to these claims. It argued that rating agencies were concurrent wrongdoers and that damages should be reduced under s 12GF(1B). On the facts, Rares J declined to attribute any share of responsibility to the rating agencies.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying what was said or done, and who heard it. Then ask what impression this created for an ordinary or reasonable listener, following Forrest. Focus on the impression given, not what the speaker actually meant.

Next, check if the conduct relates to a financial product or service. If it does, don’t rely on the Australian Consumer Law’s Commonwealth application. Instead use ss 1041H and 12DA, and add s 12DB if a specific listed representation was made.

Check the carve-outs, meaning the exceptions that may apply. These include disclosure documents under s 953A or s 1022A, the takeover and fundraising document provisions, and overlap with continuous disclosure rules.

If the statement predicts something, apply s 769C and s 12BB. Consider who carries the onus, meaning the burden of proving the point, once there’s evidence of reasonable grounds.

Then ask whether fault can be shown. This means asking if the maker didn’t care, or knew or should have known, that the statement was false in a material particular or materially misleading. It must also have been likely to induce dealing or affect price, as s 1041E(1)(b) requires. If so, apply s 1041E, which carries criminal consequences.

Finally, identify the claimant and the remedy available. This may be damages under s 1041I or s 12GF, claimed within six years, subject to limits like reasonable care, proportionate liability, and professional standards. Alternatively, ASIC may seek declarations and orders. Note that no pecuniary penalty applies to ss 1041H and 12DA.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →