Business records and the hearsay exception
Separate proof of a business document from the s 69 hearsay exception, its knowledge requirements, exclusions and missing-record route.
Learning outcomes
- Apply each condition of the business-records hearsay exception to particular representations.
- Distinguish an information chain grounded in personal knowledge from unsupported business gossip.
- Analyse litigation records and evidence of an absent entry without treating a database as automatically reliable.
A business record may preserve information long after the person who supplied it has left. Before treating a ledger or database entry as evidence of what happened, ask what representation it contains and whose knowledge supports it. Section 69 of the uniform Evidence Acts supplies a hearsay exception with specific conditions, rather than a general assurance that organisations keep accurate records.
This article compares s 69 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) and Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT). Each enacts the substantive conditions described below. The ACT uses “entity” and “happening” where other texts refer to a person, body or organisation and an event’s “occurrence”; those drafting differences do not remove any knowledge or purpose condition.123456
Start with the representation and its purpose
Section 59 concerns a previous representation used to prove a fact the maker can reasonably be supposed to have intended to assert. Identify that fact before asking about the exception. A delivery entry saying “ten boxes received” may be tendered to prove receipt of ten boxes. If the issue is instead whether the customer was notified of a complaint, the fact that a message was sent may matter independently of its truth.
Section 69 belongs to the “other exceptions” division. Its knowledge requirement is its own, in ss 69(2) and (5). Do not import the first-hand-hearsay requirement in s 62 as if it prohibited an information chain here: s 69(2)(b) expressly permits information supplied directly or indirectly from a person with the necessary personal knowledge.
Keep the application provisions separate. The Commonwealth Act principally applies to proceedings in federal courts, subject to s 4’s qualifications and the provisions extended beyond those courts. Choosing the Commonwealth text because the business operates nationally does not establish that it governs the proceeding.
The two business connections in s 69(1)
The document must satisfy two conditions. First, it is or forms part of records belonging to or kept by the relevant person, body or organisation in the course of, or for the purposes of, a business; alternatively, it formerly formed part of those records. That temporal wording supports the inference that closure alone does not defeat the record condition; the remaining requirements still apply.
Second, the document must contain a previous representation made or recorded in the course of, or for the purposes of, the business. Ownership of the paper is insufficient. A personal message incidentally stored on an employer’s server is not shown to meet this condition merely by its storage location. Explain the connection between the particular representation and the business activity.
The Acts use an extended conception of business. The Commonwealth Dictionary includes professions, occupations and undertakings, government activities, non-profit businesses and businesses outside Australia. The counterparts likewise extend beyond profit-making companies. Thus the exception is not confined to invoices issued by incorporated trading enterprises. Equally, the broad definition does not dispense with the record and representation conditions.
Trace the information to personal knowledge
Section 69(2) removes the hearsay rule only so far as the document contains the qualifying representation. There are two routes:
- The representation was made by someone who had, or might reasonably be supposed to have had, personal knowledge of the asserted fact.
- It was based on information supplied directly or indirectly by someone with that actual or reasonably supposed personal knowledge.
Section 69(5) explains personal knowledge: the knowledge was, or might reasonably be supposed to have been, based on something the person saw, heard or otherwise perceived, excluding another person’s previous representation about the fact. The information chain can include intermediaries, but it still needs a foundation in the relevant person’s perception.
For example, a clerk may enter a driver’s report that the driver delivered a parcel. The driver’s perception can supply the relevant foundation even though the clerk did not attend the delivery. By contrast, an entry repeating an unidentified rumour needs an evidentiary basis for reasonably supposing a source had personal knowledge. The fact that the rumour reached a database does not supply that basis by itself.
Analyse separate assertions separately. A maintenance record may contain the mechanic’s observation of a worn tyre and a customer’s explanation of when it was damaged. Establishing the mechanic’s knowledge of wear does not establish the customer’s knowledge of its cause. The statutory words “so far as” resist treating the entire record as a single admissible package.
The proceedings and investigation exclusions
Section 69(3) withdraws subsection (2) where the representation was prepared or obtained for conducting, in contemplation of, or in connection with an Australian or overseas proceeding. It also withdraws it where the representation was made in connection with an investigation relating or leading to a criminal proceeding.
The object of this inquiry is the representation, not simply the later decision to tender a document. Ask why and in what connection the representation was prepared, obtained or made. An ordinary transaction entry and a later account compiled for litigation require separate analysis, even if both sit in the same company file.
Failure under s 69(3) means this particular exception is unavailable. It does not prove that no other hearsay exception could apply. Conversely, a later litigation purpose does not relieve the proponent of establishing the original record’s conditions. Follow the evidence rather than assuming either “business document” or “lawyer’s file” settles every representation within it.
A missing entry can have evidentiary significance
Section 69(4) supplies a separate route for absence of a record. It requires an event of a particular kind to be in question and a business system that has been followed of making and keeping records of all events of that kind. The hearsay rule then does not apply to evidence tending to prove that no record of the event is kept in accordance with that system.
A failed search alone is not the statutory foundation. Establish what events the system records and that the business followed it. A database recording only expensive repairs cannot, through this provision alone, establish that no inexpensive repair occurred. Even a qualifying absence remains evidence to assess; it is not a conclusive statutory declaration that the event never happened.
Proving the record and testing its use
Section 48 addresses proof of contents, while s 69 addresses hearsay. A printout may meet a method of proving contents without satisfying s 69’s knowledge condition. Device presumptions may assist with what a computer produced without establishing that a human informant’s account was true. See documents and devices for those separate inquiries.
Relevant business records remain subject to other admissibility rules and exclusions. In particular, prosecution evidence in criminal proceedings engages s 137’s mandatory comparison of probative value and danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant. Section 135 has its own discretionary threshold and grounds, including Victoria’s additional homicide ground. Neither the business label nor successful reliance on s 69 ends the admissibility analysis.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify each representation, its asserted fact and the purpose for which it is tendered.
- Apply both s 69(1) connections: the business record and the business making or recording of the representation.
- Trace actual or reasonably supposed personal knowledge under ss 69(2) and (5), allowing an indirect chain but requiring its perceptual foundation.
- Test the particular representation against both s 69(3) exclusions; assess another exception separately if needed.
- For an absent entry, establish the followed system of recording all events of that kind before relying on s 69(4).
- Prove contents by the appropriate route, address remaining admissibility objections and distinguish admissibility from evidentiary weight.