Presumptions that ease proof of documents and machine output
The presumptions in Part 4.3 of the uniform Evidence Acts that ease proof of machine output, business records, attestation, seals and documents more than 20 years old, the two different strengths of presumption, and the court’s power to examine a document under s 183.
Learning outcomes
- Identify which Part 4.3 presumption a document or machine output engages and check each statutory condition.
- Distinguish presumptions displaced by evidence sufficient to raise doubt (ss 146, 147) from those displaced only by proof of the contrary (ss 148, 150, 152).
- Apply the s 147(3) exclusion for documents produced for proceedings or criminal investigations.
- Use s 183 to decide a condition by examining the document, keeping relevance and hearsay as separate questions.
Proving what a document says is one step, governed by s 48 of the uniform Evidence Acts. A party relying on a document or on the output of a machine often has to prove something more: that a photocopier copied the whole page, that a business’s computer recorded a transaction correctly, that a seal or signature is genuine, or that an old deed is what it purports to be. Part 4.3 of the uniform Acts eases that proof with a set of presumptions. The prior question for a student is which presumption the facts engage, and what it takes to displace it, because the Act uses two different formulas and they put different burdens on the opponent.
This article states Part 4.3 Division 1 and s 183 of the Commonwealth Act. Sections 146, 147, 148, 149, 152 and 183 are enacted to the same effect in New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory, with the differences noted below.12 For proving the contents of a document, see Proving the contents of a document.
Two strengths of presumption
Read the words after “it is presumed”. Sections 146 and 147 say the presumption operates unless evidence sufficient to raise doubt about the presumption is adduced. Sections 148, 150 and 152 say it operates unless the contrary is proved.
The difference matters. Against a s 146 or s 147 presumption the opponent need only adduce evidence sufficient to raise doubt about it. Against a s 148, s 150 or s 152 presumption, the words require the contrary to be proved. An answer that treats every Part 4.3 presumption as rebuttable in the same way has misread the section it is applying.
Devices and processes: s 146
Section 146 applies to a document or thing produced wholly or partly by a device or process, and tendered by a party who asserts that, in producing it, the device or process produced a particular outcome. If it is reasonably open to find that the device or process is one that, or is of a kind that, if properly used, ordinarily produces that outcome, it is presumed that on the occasion in question it produced that outcome.
The statutory example is a photocopier: it would not be necessary to call evidence that a photocopier normally produced complete copies of documents and was working properly when it copied a particular document. The section reaches a “document or thing”, so it is not confined to paper.
Note what the party must still establish. The court must be able to find that the device or process is one that, if properly used, ordinarily produces the outcome asserted. The presumption then supplies the proof that it did so on the occasion in question.
Business devices and processes: s 147
Section 147 applies to a document produced wholly or partly by a device or process and tendered by a party asserting that the device or process produced a particular outcome. If the document is, or was when produced, part of the records of, or kept for the purposes of, a business (whether or not the business still exists), and the device or process was used for the purposes of the business, it is presumed that the device or process produced that outcome. There is no requirement here of a finding about what the device ordinarily does.
Section 147(3) removes the presumption for the contents of a document produced for the purpose of, or in contemplation of or in connection with, an Australian or overseas proceeding, or in connection with an investigation relating or leading to a criminal proceeding. A record generated in the ordinary course of a business can attract s 147; a report a business generates for litigation, or in connection with an investigation leading to a criminal proceeding, cannot.
Attestation, seals and old documents
Attesting witnesses (s 149). It is not necessary to adduce the evidence of an attesting witness to prove that a document was signed or attested as it purports to have been, unless the document is testamentary.
Justices, lawyers and notaries (s 148). Where an Australian law requires, authorises or permits a document to be attested, verified, signed or acknowledged by a justice of the peace, Australian lawyer or notary public, and it purports to have been so attested, verified, signed or acknowledged, it is presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that it was attested or verified by, or signed or acknowledged before, that person. The Northern Territory Act adds a Commissioner of Oaths to the list.
Seals and signatures (s 150). Where a document bears what purports to be the imprint of a listed seal, or the seal or signature of an office holder in an official capacity, it is presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that the seal or signature is genuine and, for an office holder, that the person held the office at the time. The lists of seals differ between the Acts: the New South Wales and Tasmanian Acts begin with the Public Seal of the State, and the New South Wales Act notes that the Commonwealth Act has a different subsection (1). By s 5 of the Commonwealth Act, its s 150 applies to proceedings in all Australian courts.
Old documents (s 152). If a document that is, or purports to be, more than 20 years old is produced from proper custody, it is presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that the document is what it purports to be and, if it purports to have been executed or attested by a person, that it was duly executed or attested by that person.
The court may look at the document: s 183
If a question arises about the application of a provision of the Act in relation to a document or thing, s 183 allows the court to examine the document or thing and draw any reasonable inferences from it, as well as from other matters from which inferences may properly be drawn. So whether a printout is part of a business’s records for s 147, or whether a deed is more than 20 years old for s 152, can be decided in part by looking at the document itself.
What the presumptions do not do
A presumption under Part 4.3 supplies proof of the fact it describes, such as that the device produced the outcome or that the seal is genuine, until it is displaced. Nothing in these sections makes a document relevant or answers the hearsay rule where the document is tendered to prove the truth of what it asserts. Those questions are asked separately, as they are for proof of contents under s 48.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify what the party needs to prove about the document or thing beyond its contents: the output of a device, its business origin, a seal or signature, attestation, or age and custody.
- Choose the presumption that fits, and check each condition in the section’s words.
- For s 146, ask whether the evidence allows a finding that the device, properly used, ordinarily produces the asserted outcome.
- For s 147, check that the document is a business record and the device was used for the business, and test it against the litigation and investigation exclusion in s 147(3).
- State what displaces the presumption: evidence sufficient to raise doubt (ss 146, 147) or proof of the contrary (ss 148, 150, 152).
- Use s 183 where a condition can be decided by examining the document, then turn to relevance and hearsay.
Self-check
- Can I say which presumptions yield to evidence raising doubt and which require proof of the contrary?
- Do I know what a party must still establish before s 146 operates?
- Can I apply the s 147(3) exclusion to a document prepared for litigation?
- Do I know what s 152 presumes about a document more than 20 years old from proper custody?
- Have I kept the presumptions separate from relevance and hearsay?
Where the authority sits
In the Commonwealth Act the presumptions are in Part 4.3 Division 1, and s 183 is in Chapter 5. Sections 146, 147, 148, 149, 152 and 183 are enacted to the same effect in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Victorian, Tasmanian, ACT and Northern Territory Acts: the ACT says “presented” for “adduced” and “completely” for “wholly”, the Tasmanian s 146 has no example, and the Northern Territory s 148 adds a Commissioner of Oaths. Section 150 lists different seals in different Acts. Section 182 of the Commonwealth Act gives ss 147, 149 and 152, among others, a wider application to Commonwealth records.3 Western Australia’s Evidence Act 2025 (WA) contains counterparts, ss 341, 342 and 344 to 346 and s 367, in Parts that commence on 18 September 2027; its s 346(2) extends the old-documents presumption to an admitted copy, and s 343 adds a provision about findings on the accuracy of copies.4 Queensland and South Australia are not stated here.