Presumptions that ease proof of documents and machine output

Two strengths of presumption

Not all presumptions are rebutted the same way.

Sections 146 and 147 are weaker. The opponent only needs to adduce evidence sufficient to raise doubt about the presumption.

Sections 148, 150 and 152 are stronger. Here the opponent must actually prove the contrary.

Treating all these presumptions as equally easy to rebut misreads the section involved.

Devices and processes: s 146

Section 146 deals with a document or thing made wholly or partly by a device or process. A party tenders it and claims the device or process produced a particular outcome.

If the court can reasonably find the device or process, when properly used, ordinarily produces that outcome, a presumption applies. The presumption is that it produced that outcome on the occasion in question.

The example given is a photocopier. A party need not call evidence that the photocopier normally makes complete copies and was working properly that day.

The section covers a “document or thing”, so it is not limited to paper.

The party must still show the device or process ordinarily produces that outcome when properly used. Once that is shown, the presumption proves it happened on the occasion in question.

Business devices and processes: s 147

Section 147 helps prove documents made by a device or process, like a business machine or system. A party can rely on it if they say the device or process produced a certain outcome.

This applies when the document is, or was, part of a business’s records, or kept for business purposes. The business does not need to still exist. If the device or process was used for that business, the law presumes it produced that outcome. The party does not need to show what the device normally does.

Section 147(3) creates an exception. The presumption does not apply to a document made for use in a court proceeding, or in connection with a criminal investigation. This covers documents made in contemplation of, or connected with, such a proceeding or investigation.

So an ordinary business record can use this presumption. A report made for litigation, or for an investigation leading to a criminal case, cannot.

Attestation, seals and old documents

These rules make it easier to prove documents are genuine, without needing extra witnesses in court.

Under s 149, you don’t need an attesting witness to prove a document was signed or attested properly. This exception doesn’t apply to testamentary documents (like wills).

Under s 148, if a law allows a justice of the peace, lawyer or notary public to attest, verify, sign or acknowledge a document, and it looks like they did so, courts presume this is true. This presumption can be disproved by contrary evidence. The Northern Territory Act also includes a Commissioner of Oaths in this list.

Under s 150, if a document bears what looks like an official seal or an office holder’s signature, courts presume it’s genuine. They also presume the office holder held that position at the time, unless proven otherwise. Different Acts list different seals; for example, New South Wales and Tasmania both start with the Public Seal of the State. The Commonwealth Act’s version of this section applies to all Australian courts.

Under s 152, documents over 20 years old are presumed genuine if they come from proper custody (meaning a plausible, expected storage location). If the document appears executed or attested by someone, courts presume this was done properly too, unless proven otherwise.

The court may look at the document: s 183

Section 183 lets the court examine a document or thing itself. This applies when a question arises about how a provision of the Act applies to that document or thing.

The court may draw reasonable inferences from the document or thing. It may also draw inferences from other matters, where inferences can properly be drawn from them.

For example, looking at a printout can help decide if it is a business record under s 147. Looking at a deed can help decide if it is over 20 years old under s 152.

What the presumptions do not do

A presumption under Part 4.3 only proves the specific fact it covers. For example, it may prove a device produced the outcome, or that a seal is genuine. This lasts until the presumption is displaced, meaning rebutted by evidence.

These presumptions do not make a document relevant to the case. They also do not deal with the hearsay rule. This matters when a document is tendered to prove the truth of what it says.

Relevance and hearsay are separate questions. They must be considered on their own, just like proof of contents under s 48.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out what you must prove about the document beyond its contents. This could be a device’s output, business origin, a seal, signature, attestation, or age and custody.

Then pick the presumption that matches, and check it against the exact wording of that section.

For s 146, ask if the evidence supports finding the device usually produces this kind of result when properly used. For s 147, confirm it is a business record and the device was used for the business. Also check the exclusion in s 147(3) for documents made for litigation or investigation.

Remember how each presumption can be displaced. Sections 146 and 147 need only evidence raising doubt. Sections 148, 150 and 152 need proof of the contrary, a stricter standard.

Finally, use s 183 when a condition can be settled just by examining the document itself. After that, still consider relevance and hearsay separately.

Self-check

Before moving on, check you understand the key points.

Some presumptions fall away once evidence raises doubt. Others need actual proof to the contrary. Make sure you can tell these two types apart.

Check you know what a party must prove before s 146 even applies. The presumption does not start working on its own.

Can you apply the s 147(3) exclusion? This rule stops the presumption applying to a document made for use in litigation.

Remember what s 152 presumes. It concerns a document over 20 years old, kept in proper custody.

Finally, keep these presumptions separate from relevance and hearsay. They are different legal ideas, even though they often arise in the same case.

Where the authority sits

In the Commonwealth Act, these presumptions sit in Part 4.3 Division 1. Section 183 is separate, in Chapter 5.

Sections 146, 147, 148, 149, 152 and 183 work the same way in the Commonwealth, NSW, Victorian, Tasmanian, ACT and Northern Territory Acts. The ACT uses “presented” instead of “adduced”, and “completely” instead of “wholly”. Tasmania’s s 146 has no example. The Northern Territory’s s 148 also covers a Commissioner of Oaths.

Section 150 is different: each Act lists different seals. Section 182 of the Commonwealth Act widens some of these rules (including ss 147, 149 and 152) so they apply more broadly to Commonwealth records.

Western Australia’s Evidence Act 2025 (WA) has similar provisions: ss 341, 342, 344 to 346, and s 367. These sit in Parts that don’t start until 18 September 2027. Section 346(2) extends the presumption about old documents to cover an admitted copy. Section 343 adds a rule about findings on whether a copy is accurate.

The passage does not cover Queensland or South Australia.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.