Business records and the hearsay exception
Start with the representation and its purpose
Section 59 lets a previous representation (an earlier statement) prove a fact the speaker meant to assert. Identify that fact before checking the exception. “Ten boxes received” can prove receipt of ten boxes. But if the issue is notice of a complaint, the fact a message was sent matters, not its truth.
Section 69 sits in the “other exceptions” division. Its knowledge requirement is separate, found in ss 69(2) and (5). Don’t treat s 62’s first-hand hearsay rule as banning a chain of information here. Section 69(2)(b) allows information passed on directly or indirectly from someone with personal knowledge.
Keep the application provisions distinct. The Commonwealth Act mainly applies to federal court proceedings, subject to s 4’s qualifications and its extensions beyond those courts. A business operating nationally doesn’t itself mean the Commonwealth Act governs the case.
The two business connections in s 69(1)
Section 69(1) sets two conditions a document must meet.
First, the document must be, or have been, part of business records. It can be current or former records — losing current status alone doesn’t disqualify it. The other conditions still have to be met.
Second, the document must contain a representation made or recorded for the business. Just owning the paper isn’t enough. For example, a personal email stored on a work server doesn’t automatically qualify — you must show the actual link to the business activity.
“Business” is defined broadly. It includes professions, government bodies, non-profits, and businesses based overseas, not just trading companies. But this wide definition doesn’t remove the need to still satisfy both the record and representation conditions.
Trace the information to personal knowledge
Section 69(2) only removes the hearsay rule for the part of a document containing the qualifying representation. The rest of the document is not automatically covered.
There are two ways to satisfy this. First, the person who made the representation may have had personal knowledge of the fact, or might reasonably be supposed to have had it. Second, the representation may be based on information from someone else with that actual or reasonably supposed personal knowledge.
Section 69(5) defines personal knowledge. It means knowledge based, or reasonably supposed to be based, on something the person saw, heard or otherwise perceived. This excludes knowledge based only on someone else’s earlier representation about the fact. Information can pass through intermediaries, but it must trace back to someone’s actual perception.
For example, a clerk might record a driver’s report of delivering a parcel. The driver’s own perception supports this, even though the clerk was not there. But an entry based on an unidentified rumour needs some evidence that a source had personal knowledge. Simply reaching a database does not provide that evidence.
Different assertions in the same document must be checked separately. A maintenance record might include a mechanic’s observation of tyre wear and a customer’s explanation of its cause. Proving the mechanic’s knowledge does not prove the customer’s knowledge. The words “so far as” mean the whole record is not automatically admissible as one package.
A missing entry can have evidentiary significance
Section 69(4) is a different pathway for proving a record is missing. It applies when a business has a system of recording every event of a certain kind, and the question is whether that kind of event happened.
If the system was followed, hearsay rules don’t block evidence that no record exists. This evidence can then suggest the event didn’t happen.
But a failed search isn’t enough on its own. You must show what the system records, and that the business actually followed it.
A database that only logs expensive repairs can’t use this section to prove a cheap repair never happened. The missing record must relate to the kind of event the system actually tracks.
Even then, the missing record is just evidence to weigh. It doesn’t conclusively prove the event never occurred.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.