Graham v The Queen

High Court of Australia · 1998

EvidenceHearsay

Graham v The Queen (1998) 195 CLR 606; [1998] HCA 61

A woman told a friend about abuse she said she suffered as a child, six years after the last alleged act. The Act lets her friend repeat it if the events were “fresh in the memory” when she spoke. Were they?

Superseded by legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), from 1 January 2009

A multifactor freshness test was inserted in response to this decision, and it is that test, not any explanatory note, that displaces the narrow reading. In the Commonwealth Act it is s 66(2A): in determining whether the occurrence of the asserted fact was fresh in the memory, “the court may take into account all matters that it considers are relevant to the question”, including the nature of the event, the age and health of the person, and the period of time between the occurrence and the representation. The Act’s note to s 66 says that subsection (2A) was inserted as a response to this decision. The Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), under which the case was decided, now contains the same subsection with the same note. A student applying a Commonwealth, or equivalent, provision therefore applies s 66(2A) and not the reading of Gaudron, Gummow and Hayne JJ.

What happened?

The appellant was convicted in the District Court of New South Wales of three counts of indecent assault by a person in authority and three counts of sexual intercourse with a person under the age of ten, all against his daughter, K ([14]). The offences were alleged to have occurred between June 1987 and July 1988, when she was nine and ten ([15]). Charges were laid after she told a girlfriend, N, in August 1994 that she had been sexually abused by her father as a child ([15], [24]). That was about six years after the last of the acts alleged ([24]).

At the trial the evidence of K’s complaint to N was admitted, and the trial was conducted as if the common law applied, unaffected by the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) ([10], [26]). The Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed the appellant’s appeal, holding that the evidence satisfied the statutory requirement of freshness; Levine J had said that freshness is concerned with the quality of the memory and is not determined simply by notions of lapse of time ([27]-[28]).

What did the Court decide?

The High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of the Court of Criminal Appeal, quashed the convictions and ordered a new trial on all counts on which the appellant was convicted. The Justices were Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, Gummow, Hayne and Callinan JJ. Gleeson CJ agreed with the reasons of Callinan J, and Gaudron, Gummow and Hayne JJ gave joint reasons agreeing that the appeal should be allowed ([1]-[2]).

The grounds for allowing the appeal are in the joint reasons at [3]-[10] and in Callinan J’s reasons at [32]-[46].

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Gaudron, Gummow and Hayne JJ. Their Honours held that the complaint was made six years after the last of the acts alleged, and that “Too long had elapsed between the events and the complaint” ([3]). The word “fresh”, in its context in s 66, means “recent” or “immediate” ([4]). It “may also carry with it a connotation that describes the quality of the memory (as being ‘not deteriorated or changed by lapse of time’)”, but the core of the meaning intended is the temporal relationship between the occurrence of the asserted fact and the making of the representation, and “the temporal relationship required will very likely be measured in hours or days, not, as was the case here, in years” ([4]).

They gave three reasons: the section applies only where the maker of the representation is called to give evidence, so that tendering earlier statements on the strength of the vividness of the recollection would distract attention from the evidence given in court; the memory of events changes as time passes; and the exception should be limited to cases where the earlier statement is likely to add to the useful material before the court ([5]).

Callinan J and Gleeson CJ. Callinan J said that while “the quality or vividness of a recollection will generally be relevant in an assessment of its freshness, its contemporaneity or near contemporaneity, or otherwise will almost always be the most important consideration” ([34]). There may be cases in which evidence of an event relatively remote in time will be admissible under s 66, “but such cases will necessarily be rare and requiring of some special circumstance or feature” ([34]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Gaudron, Gummow and Hayne JJ

Read judgment: [3]–[4] (opens in a new tab), [10] (opens in a new tab)

The temporal construction of freshness was necessary to the joint reasons: it excluded the complaint made six years after the alleged acts from s 66. Since admission under s 108 was not inevitable, that error left a significant chance of acquittal and required the appeal to be allowed. The reference to hours or days describes the likely application of the test; it does not prescribe a fixed numerical cutoff.

Separate reasoning · Callinan J (Gleeson CJ agreeing)

Read judgment: [1] (opens in a new tab), [34] (opens in a new tab), [46] (opens in a new tab)

Callinan J concurred in allowing the appeal, and Gleeson CJ adopted his reasons. His distinct formulation allowed the quality or vividness of memory to be relevant but treated contemporaneity as almost always the most important consideration. He relied on the misconstruction of s 66 and the resulting lost chance of acquittal. His suggestion that a remote event might exceptionally qualify did not decide that any particular special circumstance would suffice.

Why does this case matter?

Questions on complaint evidence usually ask whether a witness’s earlier account can be repeated by someone else, and a student who has the section’s words but not the case has nothing to say about how long is too long. Graham is also a case a student must date: it describes the section as the Justices read it before the amendment that responded to it.

Exam and application relevance

State the reading of s 66 that the Justices gave, attributing each view to the Justices who held it, and then say that a provision containing the amendment is applied as amended.

Keep the limits in view. The case was decided on the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) as it stood before s 66(2A) existed. The Court did not decide how the combined operation of ss 60 and 66 otherwise alters the common law, saying that the question did not arise ([12]).

Check your understanding

1. At [4] the joint reasons say what “fresh” means and how long the relevant relationship will very likely be measured in. What are those statements, and what did Callinan J say at [34] about contemporaneity?

2. Why did the Court say that the evidence of complaint could not be admitted under s 66, and what other provision did it say might have admitted it if the court gave leave ([3], [6]-[7])?

3. The joint reasons give three reasons for the construction they adopt ([5]). What are they?