Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd

High Court of Australia · 2014

Taxation And Revenue LawGst Fundamentals

Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd [2014] HCA 49

A purchaser acquired apartments already leased to an operator. What did the purchaser supply after completion, and what was the price?

Clarified by IQ Renew Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia [2026] FCA 1393

Jackman J of the Federal Court, reading MBI Properties at [33]-[35] with its statutory discussion, understood the High Court’s statement that making a supply need not involve the taking of some action by the supplier as a reference to some physical act, as distinct from an act in law such as entering into a contract, because a supply made by doing absolutely nothing, factually or legally, would leave the word supply without meaningful content ([66]). His Honour did not read [34] as treating complete inactivity by the supplier as a supply, and noted that the High Court concluded that in observing the covenant of quiet enjoyment the lessor was engaged in an activity ([68]); he put the point as “complete inactivity as a matter of fact and law cannot constitute the making of a supply” ([83](g)). That is one Federal Court judge’s explanation of MBI Properties in a different setting, a container deposit scheme, and it does not question the High Court’s holding about the lessor’s continuing obligations under the lease.

What happened?

South Steyne leased apartments in a Manly hotel complex to its operator. The leases required the owner to permit the operator’s use and occupation without interruption. MBI bought three apartments subject to those leases and elected to participate in the management arrangements ([15]-[17]).

The acquisition was treated as a GST-free supply of a going concern. The Commissioner assessed MBI to an increasing adjustment under s 135-5. The dispute concerned the supplies MBI intended to make through the acquired enterprise, and whether those supplies had a price. MBI lost at first instance but succeeded in the Full Court ([19], [22], [25]-[32]).

What did the Court decide?

The High Court allowed the Commissioner’s appeal, set aside orders 1 to 4 of the Full Court’s orders and substituted dismissal of MBI’s appeal to that Court. French CJ, Hayne, Kiefel, Gageler and Keane JJ gave joint reasons. The Commissioner paid MBI’s High Court costs under an undertaking, despite succeeding ([46]-[47] and the order).

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

The joint reasons rejected a view of supply confined to the original grant of the lease: the Full Court in this case was wrong to reason that the only relevant supply was on the grant, and the Full Court in South Steyne was wrong to conclude that MBI made no supply ([41]). The Commissioner had abandoned the argument he put at earlier stages and now argued that the continuation of each lease resulted in an input taxed supply, and the litigious history did not preclude it ([26]); MBI did not dispute that the s 135-5 conditions were met if its observance of the obligation was sufficient to give rise to a supply ([30]).

A contract may involve a supply when rights and obligations are created and a further supply when the contract is performed. Performance can include observing an obligation to refrain from interference rather than doing a fresh physical act ([33]-[36]).

MBI succeeded to the owner’s obligation to provide use and occupation. By continuing to observe that obligation, it made a supply through an enterprise. The supply was input taxed residential leasing, rather than a taxable supply. That classification mattered because the acquired going concern was intended to be used to make supplies that were neither taxable nor GST-free, attracting the increasing adjustment ([37]-[41], [46]). The decision does not classify every form of accommodation or every property acquisition in the same way.

MBI’s alternative argument was that rent could only be the price of the original grant. The Court rejected an exclusive payment-to-supply connection under the general definitions. The rent was the price of MBI’s intended supply, whether or not it was also payable in connection with the original grant. Its explanation of avoiding double taxation relied on attribution under s 29-5 and expressly preserved applicable special rules, including the deposit regime considered in Reliance Carpet ([42]-[45]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Proposition 1

Ratio · French CJ, Hayne, Kiefel, Gageler and Keane JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: [33]–[41] (PDF p 15) (opens in a new tab)

The joint reasons explain that one transaction need not involve one supply and that a supply need not involve action by the supplier ([33]-[34]), how contractual performance supplies continuing use and occupation under a lease ([35]-[38]), why the Full Court was wrong to focus exclusively on the grant ([39], [41]), and apply that reasoning to MBI’s succession to the lessor’s obligations ([40]). This resolves the contested supply issue necessary to the adjustment, rather than making every passive situation a supply. The range runs from physical page 15 to page 17.

Proposition 2

Ratio · French CJ, Hayne, Kiefel, Gageler and Keane JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: [42] (PDF p 17) (opens in a new tab), [43]–[45] (PDF p 18) (opens in a new tab)

MBI’s alternative argument denied a price for its intended supply and would have prevented calculating the adjustment. These passages reject that argument and identify the rent as the price. The special-rule qualification limits the explanation of attribution.

Why does this case matter?

MBI Properties is useful when a purchaser acquires property subject to an existing lease and the question is what the purchaser supplies afterwards.

Exam and application relevance

Identify the supplier, recipient and relevant period. Explain the rights or obligations created and the performance occurring later, then classify the particular supply under the applicable provisions. Keep the acquisition of the going concern distinct from the supplies made through it.

Address the consideration and any adjustment calculation separately. Where a timing issue arises, identify the applicable attribution rule and any special rule. For a problem framed as passive conduct, examine the legal obligations and any continuing performance.

Check your understanding

1. What did MBI provide after it acquired apartments whose leases had already been granted?

2. Why could an input taxed supply matter to an increasing adjustment following a GST-free acquisition?

3. How did the Court answer the argument that rent could only be the price of the original grant?