GST: taxable supply and consideration

Explains how a taxable supply is identified under the GST Act, and how the High Court in MBI Properties, Reliance Carpet and Qantas treated multiple supplies, forfeited deposits and unused airfares through the words supply and consideration.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
taxation-and-revenue-law
Topics
gst-fundamentals

Learning outcomes

  • State the elements of a taxable supply in s 9-5 of the GST Act and explain why supply and taxable supply are different ideas.
  • Explain, using Qantas, why consideration for GST requires a connection with a supply and does not depend on contractual principles.
  • Apply ss 29-5, 99-5 and 99-10 to decide when GST on a supply is attributable to a tax period.

The rules for when goods and services tax is payable are in a Commonwealth statute, A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth) (“the GST Act”); the note to s 2-1 says the tax itself is imposed by separate Commonwealth Acts. This article states the GST Act as Commonwealth law, read through three High Court decisions. Before asking who ultimately bears GST or who can claim a credit, a student must ask a prior question: has the entity made a taxable supply at all? The answer turns on the statutory words “supply” and “consideration” and on how the Act times them, not on what the customer hoped to receive, which is how an airline came to owe GST on fares for flights that passengers did not take.

What GST taxes

Economists call GST a consumption tax, and the article on GST fundamentals explains how input tax credits move its burden to the final consumer. As a matter of legal analysis, liability is generated by a transaction. In Commissioner of Taxation v Reliance Carpet Co Pty Ltd (2008) 236 CLR 342; [2008] HCA 22, the High Court set out, as “an important point respecting the nature of the GST”, a Full Federal Court statement that what is taxed “is not consumption but a particular form of transaction, namely supply”.1

The statutory test

Section 7-1 provides that GST is payable on taxable supplies, and s 9-5 states when a person makes one. On the compilation current to January 2026, a person makes a taxable supply if the person makes the supply for consideration, the supply is made in the course or furtherance of an enterprise the person carries on, the supply is connected with the indirect tax zone, and the person is registered or required to be registered. The supply is not a taxable supply to the extent that it is GST-free or input taxed.5 The Qantas reasons discussed below set out the third limb as “connected with Australia”. The Treasury Legislation Amendment (Repeal Day) Act 2015 (Cth) replaced those words with “the indirect tax zone” from its commencement on 25 February 2015, applying to tax periods that begin on or after 1 July 2015,7 and the Dictionary defines the indirect tax zone as Australia, subject to listed exclusions. None of the three cases turned on that limb, and this article does not state it further.

Two definitions do most of the work in this article:

  • Supply. Section 9-10(1) says a supply “is any form of supply whatsoever”. Section 9-10(2) lists, without limiting that, a supply of services, a creation, grant, transfer, assignment or surrender of any right, and an entry into an obligation to do anything.
  • Consideration. Section 9-15(1) says consideration includes any payment, or any act or forbearance, in connection with a supply of anything, and any payment, act or forbearance in response to or for the inducement of a supply. Under s 9-15(2) it does not matter whether the payment, act or forbearance was voluntary, or whether it was made by the recipient of the supply.

One transaction can involve more than one supply

In Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd [2014] HCA 49 a purchaser of apartments took them subject to existing leases, and the question was whether it made a supply by observing the lessor’s obligations after the sale. In joint reasons, five Justices held that it did. They said that Qantas “shows that it is wrong to consider that one transaction must always involve the making of just one supply”. Absent a special rule, there is a supply whenever one entity provides something of value to another, and a supplier who enters into and performs an executory contract will in general make at least two supplies: one when it creates the contractual right and enters into the obligation, and one when it performs. The rent was therefore the price of the later supply, whether or not it was also payable in connection with the earlier one.3 In a later Federal Court decision about container deposit refunds, IQ Renew Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia [2026] FCA 1393, Jackman J read the High Court’s reference to a supply involving “some action” by the supplier as a reference to some physical act, as distinct from an act in law such as entering into a contract, and said that complete inactivity as a matter of fact and law cannot be a supply (at [66]-[68]). That is one judge’s explanation of MBI Properties in a different setting, not a change to what the High Court decided about the lease.4

A deposit: supply first, consideration later

In Reliance Carpet a Victorian company contracted to sell land and received a deposit of ten per cent of the price. The purchaser failed to complete, and the company terminated the contract for that default and forfeited the deposit. The Commissioner assessed GST on the deposit for the period of forfeiture. All five Justices, in joint reasons, allowed the Commissioner’s appeal.

The Court held that the company made a supply when the contract was made, because it entered into obligations under the contract (s 9-10(2)(g)) and granted the purchaser contractual rights over land, which the Dictionary’s definition of real property includes (s 9-10(2)(d)). The Full Federal Court’s description of the contract as one for the supply of land, “nothing more and nothing less”, gave insufficient weight to those definitions. A taxpayer cannot select some characteristics of the deposit to show there was no taxable supply; it is enough for the Commissioner’s case that one of its characteristics satisfies the statutory criterion of consideration.

Timing explains why the supply was not taxable at once. Section 99-5 provides that a deposit held as security for performance is not treated as consideration unless it is forfeited because of a failure to perform or is applied as all or part of the consideration for a supply. Section 99-10 attributes the GST to the tax period in which that happens. On forfeiture, the supply represented by making the contract became a taxable supply, and the GST was attributable to the period of forfeiture.6 MBI Properties later said that the Court’s earlier observations in Reliance Carpet were directed to these special deposit rules and not to the general operation of the GST Act (at [44]).

Qantas: what the fare was paid for

In Commissioner of Taxation v Qantas Airways Ltd (2012) 247 CLR 286; [2012] HCA 41 the question was whether GST was payable on domestic fares paid by passengers who did not take their flights, where the fare was forfeited or was refundable but no refund was claimed. The Full Federal Court had held for the airline, reasoning that what a customer pays for is carriage by air, so that no flight meant no taxable supply.2

The High Court allowed the Commissioner’s appeal. Gummow, Hayne, Kiefel and Bell JJ, in joint reasons, made three points.

  1. The word “for” in “supply for consideration” in s 9-5 is “not used to adopt contractual principles”. Rather, “it requires a connection or relationship between the supply and the consideration” (at [14]). The statutory test therefore does not adopt the contract-law principles of consideration examined in the article on consideration in contract.
  2. Reliance Carpet gave no support to extracting the “essence” and “sole purpose” of a transaction and treating that alone as the supply (at [27]).
  3. The conditions of carriage did not contain an unconditional promise to carry the passenger on a particular flight. They contained “at least a promise to use best endeavours to carry the passenger and baggage, having regard to the circumstances of the business operations of the airline”. That was a taxable supply for which the fare was the consideration (at [33]).

The joint reasons also state that one consideration may be received for more than one supply, but that the GST is payable once and is attributable to the first tax period in which any of the consideration is received or invoiced (at [19]). MBI Properties restated that explanation of s 29-5, which it said Qantas had adopted, and added that it holds “subject to the operation of any applicable special rule” (at [43]-[44]); Division 99 is one such rule.

Heydon J dissented. His Honour reasoned that what the passenger paid for was an actual air journey, and that a reservation and a conditional promise were preparatory to it. That reasoning is not the Court’s holding. The refund rules were not in issue: the joint reasons record that the dispute was about fares for which no refund was claimed or available, not about adjustment events under Division 19 on a refund.

Reading the cases together

This section is a way of organising the cases, not a test any case states. The decisions start from the breadth of s 9-10 and not from the customer’s purpose. They treat a payment’s connection to a supply as a matter of the statute’s words. Section 29-5 attributes the GST payable on a taxable supply to a tax period. Division 99 deals both with when a deposit held as security counts as consideration (s 99-5) and with attribution (s 99-10); in Reliance Carpet that separated the time of the supply from the time at which it became taxable, so that the supply made on entry into the contract became a taxable supply on forfeiture, with the GST attributable to the period of forfeiture. The decisions of the High Court bind lower Australian courts; the High Court can reconsider its own decisions. Qantas rests on the conditions of carriage the Court read, so a different contract could promise something different.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify what the supplier promised or did, using the list in s 9-10(2) and not the end the customer wanted. Include any entry into an obligation or grant of a right, and ask whether performance is a further supply (MBI Properties).
  2. Ask whether a payment, act or forbearance is in connection with, or in response to or for the inducement of, a supply (s 9-15). Do not import contract-law consideration; Qantas at [14] says “for” requires a connection, not contractual principles.
  3. Check for a special rule that moves the time at which a payment counts as consideration, such as s 99-5 for a deposit held as security, before applying the general attribution rule in s 29-5(1).
  4. Check the remaining limbs of s 9-5 (enterprise, the indirect tax zone, registration) and whether the supply is GST-free or input taxed, as the article on GST fundamentals explains.
  5. Where a refund is available, remember that the refund rules were outside Qantas.
  6. State the conclusion from the contract’s actual terms, identify the Qantas conditions as the limit of that decision, and do not state a GST rate or threshold from memory.

Self-check

  • Have I asked whether one transaction involves more than one supply, and when consideration arises?
  • Have I treated “consideration” as a statutory connection and not as contractual consideration?
  • Have I attributed the Qantas holding to the joint reasons and described Heydon J’s reasoning as a dissent?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.