GST: taxable supply and consideration

What GST taxes

Economists describe GST as a consumption tax. Input tax credits shift its real cost to the final consumer, as explained in the GST fundamentals article.

But legally, GST liability comes from a transaction, not from consumption itself. In Commissioner of Taxation v Reliance Carpet Co Pty Ltd (2008) 236 CLR 342, the High Court addressed this point.

The Court endorsed a Full Federal Court statement on this. GST taxes “a particular form of transaction, namely supply”, not consumption directly.

The statutory test

Section 7-1 says GST is payable on taxable supplies. Section 9-5 sets out four things that make a supply taxable: the person supplies it for consideration, it happens in the course of an enterprise they run, it is connected with the indirect tax zone, and the person is registered or required to be registered. Even then, a supply is not taxable to the extent it is GST-free or input taxed.

The Qantas reasons discussed later call the third element “connected with Australia”. The Treasury Legislation Amendment (Repeal Day) Act 2015 (Cth) changed that wording to “the indirect tax zone” from 25 February 2015, applying to tax periods starting on or after 1 July 2015. The Dictionary defines the indirect tax zone as Australia, with some listed exclusions. None of the three cases in this article depended on this element, so it is not discussed further.

Two definitions matter most here: supply and consideration.

Supply is defined very broadly. Section 9-10(1) says it “is any form of supply whatsoever”. Section 9-10(2) gives examples without limiting that broad meaning: supplying services, creating, granting, transferring, assigning or surrendering a right, or entering an obligation to do something.

Consideration is also defined broadly. Section 9-15(1) says it includes any payment, act or forbearance connected with a supply, and any payment, act or forbearance made in response to or to induce a supply. Section 9-15(2) adds that it does not matter whether this was voluntary, or made by the person who actually received the supply.

One transaction can involve more than one supply

One transaction can sometimes involve more than one supply.

In Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd, a buyer took apartments subject to existing leases. The issue was whether the buyer made a supply just by honouring the lessor’s obligations after settlement.

Five judges held that it did. They said Qantas shows a single transaction need not mean just one supply.

A supply happens whenever one party gives something of value to another, unless a special rule says otherwise. Someone who signs and then carries out an “executory contract” (a contract with obligations still to be performed) usually makes at least two supplies: one on entering it, one on performing it.

So the rent paid was for the later supply, whether or not it was also payment for the earlier one.

In a later Federal Court case on container deposit refunds, IQ Renew Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation, Jackman J read the High Court’s words “some action” as meaning a physical act, not a legal act like signing a contract. He said complete inactivity, in fact and law, cannot be a supply.

That was one judge’s reading of MBI Properties in a different setting. It does not change what the High Court actually decided about the lease.

A deposit: supply first, consideration later

In Reliance Carpet, a Victorian company sold land and took a ten per cent deposit. The purchaser defaulted, so the company ended the contract and kept the deposit. The Commissioner assessed GST on the deposit for the period of forfeiture, and all five High Court Justices allowed the Commissioner’s appeal.

The Court held the supply happened when the contract was made. The company took on contractual obligations (s 9-10(2)(g)) and gave the purchaser rights over land, which counts as real property (s 9-10(2)(d)). The Full Federal Court’s view that this was simply a supply of land “nothing more and nothing less” ignored these provisions. A taxpayer cannot pick only favourable features of a deposit; it is enough that one feature meets the statutory test for consideration.

Timing rules explain why GST wasn’t payable immediately. Under s 99-5, a security deposit isn’t treated as consideration unless it’s forfeited for non-performance or applied toward the price. Section 99-10 attributes the GST to the period when that occurs. Here, forfeiture made the earlier supply taxable, so GST applied in the forfeiture period.

MBI Properties later clarified that these comments in Reliance Carpet concerned only these special deposit rules, not the GST Act’s general operation (at [44]).

*Qantas*: what the fare was paid for

In Commissioner of Taxation v Qantas Airways Ltd the High Court asked whether GST applied to domestic fares where passengers did not fly. This covered fares that were forfeited, and fares that were refundable but where no refund was claimed. The Full Federal Court had sided with the airline, reasoning that customers pay for carriage by air, so no flight meant no taxable supply (a supply the GST law treats as taxed).

The High Court disagreed and allowed the Commissioner’s appeal. The majority judges made three points. First, “for” in “supply for consideration” does not import contract-law ideas of consideration. It only needs a connection between the supply and the consideration.

Second, an earlier case did not support reducing a transaction to its “essence” or “sole purpose” and calling that the supply.

Third, the airline’s conditions of carriage did not promise to fly the passenger on a specific flight. They promised best endeavours to carry the passenger, given the airline’s operations. That promise was itself a taxable supply, and the fare was the consideration for it.

The majority also noted that one payment can cover several supplies. GST is still payable only once, attributed to the first period when any consideration is received or invoiced.

Justice Heydon dissented. He reasoned that passengers paid for an actual flight, with the booking and promise merely preparatory. This dissenting view is not the Court’s holding.

The case did not decide anything about refund rules. The majority noted the dispute concerned fares where no refund was claimed or available, not adjustments following an actual refund.

Reading the cases together

This section just organises the cases. It is not a legal test in itself.

The cases start from the broad scope of s 9-10 (taxable supply), not from why the customer paid. Whether a payment connects to a supply is decided by reading the statute’s words.

Section 29-5 says GST payable on a taxable supply belongs to a tax period. Division 99 covers deposits held as security: s 99-5 says when such a deposit counts as consideration, and s 99-10 deals with attribution (which tax period the GST belongs to).

In Reliance Carpet, the Court separated two things: when the supply happened, and when it became taxable. The supply happened when the parties entered the contract. It only became a taxable supply when the deposit was forfeited. So the GST was attributed to the period of forfeiture, not the period of the contract.

High Court decisions bind lower Australian courts. However, the High Court may later reconsider its own earlier decisions.

Qantas depended on the specific conditions of carriage the Court interpreted in that case. A different contract, with different terms, could produce a different outcome.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying what the supplier actually promised or did, using the list in s 9-10(2). Focus on this, not what the customer ultimately wanted. Include any obligation entered or right granted, and ask whether performing it is a further supply, as in MBI Properties.

Next, ask whether a payment, act or forbearance is in connection with, in response to, or made to induce a supply, under s 9-15. Don’t import contract-law consideration here; Qantas at [14] says “for” only needs a connection, not contract principles.

Check whether a special rule shifts when a payment counts as consideration, such as s 99-5 for a deposit held as security. Apply this before the general attribution rule in s 29-5(1).

Then check the remaining elements of s 9-5 (enterprise, indirect tax zone, registration), and whether the supply is GST-free or input taxed, as the GST fundamentals article explains.

If a refund is available, remember the refund rules fell outside Qantas.

Finally, state your conclusion based on the contract’s actual terms. Treat the Qantas conditions as limiting that decision’s reach, and never state a GST rate or threshold from memory.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.