IQ Renew Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia

Federal Court of Australia · 2026

Taxation And Revenue LawGst Fundamentals

IQ Renew Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia [2026] FCA 1393

A recycler receives ten cents for each eligible drink container in the waste it sorts, from a scheme it did not set up and for work it says it was doing anyway. Has it made a supply to anyone?

What happened?

IQ Renew Pty Ltd runs a material recovery facility in New South Wales. It collects, sorts and processes mixed recyclables from household and business recycling bins, about 95 per cent of it under agreements with local councils, and sells the sorted materials to recyclers ([33], [37]). The New South Wales Container Deposit Scheme (CDS) began on 1 December 2017. Under it a holder of an eligible beverage container is entitled to a 10 cent refund, and where containers arrive through kerbside recycling it is the material recovery facility operator that claims the refund, passing an agreed proportion to the council under a refund sharing agreement ([16]). Exchange for Change (NSW) Pty Ltd (EFC) was the Scheme Coordinator, and IQ Renew had no part in its appointment or in the Scheme Coordinator Agreement it made with the Minister ([28], [30], [48]).

IQ Renew claimed refunds quarterly, estimating the number of eligible containers by the weight of the material multiplied by an eligible container factor ([53]-[57]). For the quarter July to September 2024 EFC issued an invoice for $1,771,878.20, stated to include GST of $161,079.84, and paid it on 9 December 2024 ([59]). IQ Renew included that GST in its business activity statement under protest and objected. The Commissioner of Taxation disallowed the objection on 3 October 2025, and IQ Renew appealed to the Federal Court on 17 October 2025 ([61]-[63]). The central question was whether IQ Renew made a supply for consideration to EFC or to the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) in relation to the refund ([4]). It said it had not changed what it did when the scheme began, and that the refund was like a bounty that fell from the sky ([100], [122]).

What did the Court decide?

Jackman J, sitting alone, dismissed the appeal ([134]). He did not reach the alternative question whether Division 142 of the GST Act stopped IQ Renew from recovering excess GST, because that question arose only if there had been no taxable supply ([133]). The parties asked to be heard on costs after the judgment, and he set a timetable for that ([135]). The judgment was delivered on 22 September 2026.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Jackman J drew from the earlier cases and the language of ss 9-5, 9-10 and 9-15 of the GST Act a set of propositions about making a “supply for consideration” under s 9-5(a) ([83]). The word “for” means “in order to obtain”, not a looser connective such as “with the result that”, and a mere temporal connection or satisfaction of a “but for” test is not enough. The term does not depend on contractual principles, there can be more than one supply in relation to a particular transaction, and it does not matter that the payment is made by an entity other than the recipient of the supply.

A supply need not involve a physical act, but complete inactivity as a matter of fact and law cannot constitute the making of a supply. In his formulation there is a supply “whenever one entity (the supplier) provides something of value to another entity (the recipient)”, absent modification of the general operation of the GST Act by a special rule. The question is determined from the supplier’s perspective but not by its subjective state of mind. It is relevant, and may be determinative, to ask whether the supplier would have acted in the same way even if the consideration were not promised or provided. The fact that a government entity provides the consideration does not mean the supply is outside the GST Act.

Applying those propositions, he held that IQ Renew made a supply for consideration to EFC and the EPA by recycling eligible containers in a way that complied with the CDS, the consideration being the refunds ([126], [132]). He accepted that there was no material change in its collection, sorting, processing and recycling activities as a result of the scheme ([122]). But he found other changes in its conduct that were brought about by the scheme and the prospect of the refunds: facilitating EFC’s sampling, cooperating with its auditors, and entering into refund sharing agreements with councils.

Those were of benefit to EFC and the EPA in helping them achieve the scheme’s objectives, and were sufficiently substantial for there to be a new supply for consideration that overlapped with IQ Renew’s supplies to councils ([123]). The benefit did not have to be capable of being characterised in a commercial or pecuniary way where a government entity provides consideration to achieve a policy objective ([124]). The question had to be approached having regard to all the circumstances in their totality, so the supply included the recycling that IQ Renew was undertaking in any event ([125]). He did not rely on the entering of data into the EFC portal as a supply in itself ([127]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Proposition 1

Classification unresolved · Jackman J

Read judgment: [83] (opens in a new tab)

This list is the framework Jackman J applied to reach his conclusion, and several items, such as the meaning of for, the possibility of more than one supply, the supplier’s perspective and the relevance of government consideration, were applied in the reasoning. Others, such as the statements about legal acts and about complete inactivity, were not needed because IQ Renew did act, so a single label would conceal that difference.

Proposition 2

Ratio · Jackman J

Read judgment: [122]–[126] (opens in a new tab), [132] (opens in a new tab)

These paragraphs state why the CDS-compliant recycling and the associated changes in conduct amounted to a supply for consideration to EFC and the EPA, which is the ground on which the appeal was dismissed ([134]).

Why does this case matter?

A payment that looks like a subsidy invites a quick answer in either direction. This case shows how much of the answer sits in what the recipient actually did.

Exam and application relevance

Begin with the words of s 9-5(a). Ask what the payee supplied, to whom, and what connects that supply to the payment; the payer and the recipient of the supply can be different entities ([83(e)]). Keep that question about the supply apart from the question why the payer made the payment, which Jackman J said the Commissioner’s rulings sometimes reframe ([90], [94], [96]).

Where the High Court’s own statements in MBI Properties, Qantas or Reliance Carpet are available for a point, state those as the High Court’s. Check whether an appeal has been brought against this decision before relying on it.

Check your understanding

1. What did Jackman J find about changes in IQ Renew’s physical activities and in its other conduct after the scheme began ([122]-[123])?

2. What did he say about whether the benefit to the scheme had to be commercial or pecuniary ([124])?

3. Which question did he not reach, and why ([133])?

4. List two of the propositions in [83] and the authority he cites for each.