Ha v New South Wales

High Court of Australia · 1997

Taxation And Revenue LawState And Territory Revenue

Ha v New South Wales (1997) 189 CLR 465; [1997] HCA 34

New South Wales charged tobacco sellers a small fee plus a percentage of their earlier sales and called it a licence fee. Was it really a licence fee, and could a State tax goods in that way at all?

Clarified by Vanderstock v Victoria [2023] HCA 30

Vanderstock v Victoria [2023] HCA 30 clarified Ha and did not overrule it. The joint reasons of Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Gleeson JJ recorded that Ha and Capital Duplicators [No 2] held, each by a majority of four to three, that duties of customs and of excise exhaust the categories of taxes on goods, and that the question whether a tax on goods imposed at the stage of consumption is a duty of excise was expressly left undecided ([5]-[6]). Leave to reopen Ha was unanimously refused ([8]). The Court then answered the reserved question: a tax on goods at the stage of consumption can be a duty of excise, and Dickenson’s Arcade was reopened and overruled to the extent that it stood in the way ([10]).

What happened?

Two retailers who ran duty free stores in suburban Sydney in 1994 sold tobacco by retail without holding a retailer’s licence under the Business Franchise Licences (Tobacco) Act 1987 (NSW). A company that sold tobacco for resale in New South Wales in 1996 appears to have held a wholesaler’s licence. The Act prohibited selling tobacco, by retail or wholesale, without a licence. A licence ran for a period of not more than a month. Its fee was $10 together with an amount equal to a stated percentage of the value of the tobacco the applicant sold in an earlier “relevant period”, and the percentage had risen over the years to 100 per cent.

The Chief Commissioner’s delegate issued notices of assessment demanding payment of moneys allegedly payable under the Act, under s 47 in the first matter and under s 46 in the second: $1,422,174.90 and $927,548 from the two plaintiffs in the first matter and $20,432,928.39 from the plaintiff in the second. A case was stated in each matter for the opinion of the Full Court on whether the Act’s provisions were invalid as imposing duties of excise within s 90 of the Constitution. New South Wales argued that they were not, with the support of the other State and Territory Attorneys-General, because local production was not a criterion of liability and because the amounts were only fees for a licence to carry on a business.

What did the Court decide?

The Court, sitting as seven Justices, answered the questions reserved in both matters in the plaintiffs’ favour, by a majority of four to three, and ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs’ costs. Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ gave joint reasons for the majority. Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ gave joint reasons in dissent.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

In Ha, a Court of seven Justices divided four to three on questions reserved in two matters about the Business Franchise Licences (Tobacco) Act 1987 (NSW). The joint reasons of Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ held that the provisions requiring a licence to sell tobacco and fixing the licence fee as $10 together with a percentage of the value of tobacco sold in an earlier period, and the related provisions on unlicensed sellers, were invalid as imposing duties of excise within the meaning of s 90 of the Constitution.

They rejected the defendants’ argument that local production or manufacture must be a criterion of liability, and reaffirmed that duties of excise are taxes on the production, manufacture, sale or distribution of goods, whether of foreign or domestic origin, and are inland taxes in contradistinction from duties of customs, which are taxes on the importation of goods (at 499-500). They said it was unnecessary to consider whether a tax on the consumption of goods would be a duty of excise (at 499-500).

They held that the amounts were not mere fees for a licence: the licence fee was manifestly a revenue-raising tax imposed on the sale of tobacco, the licensing system being an adjunct to a revenue statute, and the Dennis Hotels formula could not support it. Philip Morris and Coastace were wrongly decided, while Dennis Hotels and Dickenson’s Arcade could stand as authorities for the validity of the imposts they considered. The joint reasons also said that the Court has no power to overrule cases prospectively.

Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ, in joint dissent, would have reopened Parton and confined duties of excise to taxes falling selectively on goods of local production or manufacture, and agreed that the Court cannot overrule prospectively.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: pp 499–500 (opens in a new tab)

The joint reasons reaffirm that duties of excise are inland taxes on the production, manufacture, sale or distribution of goods, whether of foreign or domestic origin; this is the basis on which the defendants’ local-production argument fails and the imposts are characterised as excise.

Classification unresolved · Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: pp 499–500 (opens in a new tab)

The joint reasons say it was unnecessary to consider whether a tax on the consumption of goods would be a duty of excise. That is neither a holding nor an observation of principle either way, and the question was later decided in Vanderstock.

Why does this case matter?

Tax problems about a State licence or franchise fee are often attempted by asking only what the Act calls the payment. An examiner looks for a student who asks what is being taxed and how the exaction is actually calculated, and who knows that Ha is a decision on a particular statute, given by a divided Court.

Exam and application relevance

Use Ha for the characterisation of a State impost on goods as a duty of excise under s 90. Set out the facts about the impost that the joint reasons treated as important: the amount fixed by reference to the value of sales, the length of the licence period and how close the earlier sales period was to it, and the regulatory content of the licensing scheme. Name the Justices for each view rather than writing of the Court as a whole.

The consumption question that the joint reasons set aside was later taken up in Vanderstock ([2023] HCA 30).

Check your understanding

1. Which Justices gave the joint reasons for the majority in Ha, and which three Justices dissented?

2. What did the defendants argue about local production or manufacture, and how did the joint reasons deal with that argument?

3. Why did the joint reasons say the amounts payable under the Act were not mere fees for a licence?

4. What did the joint reasons say about the Court’s power to overrule earlier decisions prospectively?