State taxes and the excise limit

Explains the limit s 90 of the Constitution places on state taxes, through Ha v New South Wales (tobacco licence fees) and Vanderstock v Victoria (a per-kilometre charge on zero and low emission vehicles), and the question of whether a state charge is a tax on goods.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic
Subjects
taxation-and-revenue-law
Topics
state-and-territory-revenue

Learning outcomes

  • State what s 90 of the Constitution provides and why a state law imposing a duty of excise has no effect.
  • Explain how Ha and Vanderstock treat a licence fee or a charge on use as a possible tax on goods, attributing each majority and dissent correctly.
  • Work through the questions a state charge raises under s 90 without assuming that every state tax is, or is not, an excise.

States and territories raise their own revenue from duty, payroll tax and land tax under their own legislation, as the article on state and territory revenue explains. One limit on that power comes from the Commonwealth Constitution and not from any state Act: s 90 makes the Commonwealth Parliament’s power to impose duties of excise exclusive, so a state law imposing a duty of excise has no effect, whatever the law calls the charge. A student must therefore ask a prior question about a state charge: is it a tax on goods? This article states the limit through two High Court decisions on one New South Wales and one Victorian law. It does not state the position under any other state or territory law.1

Section 90

Section 90 provides that, on the imposition of uniform duties of customs, “the power of the Parliament to impose duties of customs and of excise, and to grant bounties on the production or export of goods, shall become exclusive”. Its second paragraph provides that, on that imposition, all State laws imposing duties of customs or of excise “shall cease to have effect”. The Constitution does not define excise, so the content of the term is the High Court’s. As the Court described its earlier decisions in Capital Duplicators [No 2] and Ha, each by a majority of four to three, “duties of customs and of excise” exhaust the categories of taxes on goods: duties of customs are border taxes, imposed on importation or exportation, and duties of excise are inland taxes on goods.3

Ha v New South Wales: a licence fee that was a tax on goods

Ha v New South Wales (1997) 189 CLR 465 concerned New South Wales legislation that prohibited selling tobacco without a licence. The fee for a licence was a small fixed sum plus a percentage of the value of tobacco the applicant had sold in an earlier month, and a person who sold without a licence was liable for the amount of the fee and a penalty. New South Wales, supported by the other States and the Territories, argued that excise meant only a tax on goods produced in Australia and that the charge was a mere fee for a licence to carry on business.

Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ, in joint reasons, rejected both arguments and held the provisions invalid. They reaffirmed that “duties of excise are taxes on the production, manufacture, sale or distribution of goods, whether of foreign or domestic origin”, and that a statute is examined for its practical operation, not only its form. The charge was “manifestly” a revenue-raising tax on the sale of tobacco, and the licensing system was no more than “an adjunct to a revenue statute”. The Court also said it has no power to overrule cases prospectively. Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ dissented, and would have confined excise to duties on goods produced or manufactured. The majority said it was unnecessary to decide whether a tax on the consumption of goods is an excise; Vanderstock, below, decided that a tax on goods imposed at consumption can be.2

Vanderstock v Victoria: a charge on use

Vanderstock v Victoria [2023] HCA 30 decided that question. Section 7(1) of the Zero and Low Emission Vehicle Distance-based Charge Act 2021 (Vic), as the Court set it out, required the registered operator of a zero or low emission vehicle (an electric, hydrogen or plug-in hybrid electric vehicle that is not an excluded vehicle) to pay a charge for use of the vehicle on specified roads, at a rate per kilometre travelled. Every State and Territory other than Victoria supported Victoria, and the Commonwealth supported the vehicle operators who challenged the charge.

By four Justices to three the Court held that s 7(1) imposed a duty of excise and was invalid. Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Gleeson JJ, in joint reasons, took the steps below. Jagot J, in separate reasons, also held the charge invalid, would overrule Dickenson’s Arcade, and agreed with the joint reasons’ proposition about uniform national legislation.

  1. The Court unanimously refused Victoria leave to reopen Capital Duplicators [No 2] and Ha. The joint reasons gave as a reason that those decisions underpin Commonwealth and State revenue arrangements that include the GST settlement (see GST fundamentals).
  2. The joint reasons reopened and overruled Dickenson’s Arcade to the extent that it held a tax on goods at the stage of consumption could not be an excise, calling that holding “an anomalous and unsustainable exception”.
  3. They held the charge was “a tax on ZLEVs”: it bore a close relation to the use of those vehicles, and it affected them as articles of commerce.

The joint reasons said that any tax on goods, at any stage including use, “can be imposed only by uniform national legislation”, and that a new tax on goods can be imposed only by the Commonwealth Parliament; Jagot J agreed. Gordon, Edelman and Steward JJ dissented and would have held the charge valid. Gordon J said the new rule “marks a departure from long established and fundamental principle and authority”.3

What the cases leave open

This section is a way of organising the cases, not a test any case states. Neither decision decides whether duty, payroll tax or land tax is a tax on goods. Jagot J said that “[m]any taxes may impose a burden on a good but not be a tax on the good and therefore not an excise”, and treated whether a tax is on goods as a question of characterisation by substance and not by label. Decisions of the High Court bind lower Australian courts; the High Court can reconsider its own decisions, as Vanderstock itself shows. Later decisions applying Vanderstock are not stated here.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the state or territory law and the High Court decision that addressed it. This article states only the New South Wales tobacco licence fees in Ha and the Victorian vehicle charge in Vanderstock, and does not assume the same result for another law.
  2. Ask whether the exaction is a tax and not a fee for a service or a regulatory fee. A label such as “licence fee” or “charge” does not decide this (Ha; Vanderstock, joint reasons and Jagot J).
  3. Ask whether it is a tax on goods: whether it bears a close relation to a step in dealing with goods, whether that step is production, sale or distribution (Ha) or use (Vanderstock), and whether it affects the goods as articles of commerce.
  4. If it is, s 90 applies and a state law imposing it is invalid, even though the Commonwealth may impose it by uniform legislation.
  5. If the facts do not show a tax on goods, do not conclude that every state tax is safe or invalid. State which question the facts raise, and note that Vanderstock was decided four to three.

Self-check

  • Have I asked whether the charge is a tax on goods before asking what the statute calls it?
  • Have I attributed the Ha and Vanderstock majorities and dissents to the right Justices?
  • Have I said that only a New South Wales and a Victorian law are stated here?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.