State taxes and the excise limit
Section 90
Section 90 deals with customs and excise duties. Once Parliament imposes uniform customs duties, its power to impose customs duties, excise duties, and bounties (payments encouraging production or export) becomes exclusive.
At that same point, State laws imposing customs or excise duties stop having effect.
The Constitution doesn’t define “excise”. So the High Court decides what it means. Drawing on earlier decisions (Capital Duplicators [No 2] and Ha, both decided four to three), the Court said customs and excise duties cover all taxes on goods. Customs duties are border taxes, charged on importing or exporting goods. Excise duties are inland taxes on goods, charged within a State.[^cite:vanderstock-v-victoria-excise-and-consumption-tax]
*Ha v New South Wales*: a licence fee that was a tax on goods
In Ha v New South Wales, New South Wales law banned selling tobacco without a licence. The licence fee was a fixed sum plus a percentage of past tobacco sales. Selling without a licence meant paying the fee plus a penalty.
New South Wales argued excise only taxes goods made in Australia, and that this was just a fee for a business licence. The majority (Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Kirby JJ) rejected both arguments and held the law invalid.
They reasoned that excise duties tax the production, manufacture, sale or distribution of goods, whether made here or overseas. Courts examine how a law actually works, not just its wording. On this basis, the charge was really a revenue-raising tax on selling tobacco, with the licensing system merely supporting that tax.
The Court also said it has no power to overrule past cases only from now on, leaving past decisions untouched (prospective overruling).
Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ dissented. They would have limited excise to taxes on goods that are produced or manufactured.
The majority did not decide whether a tax on consuming goods counts as excise. Vanderstock, discussed later, held that it can.
*Vanderstock v Victoria*: a charge on use
Vanderstock v Victoria [2023] HCA 30 decided whether a Victorian charge was an excise. Section 7(1) of the Act made registered operators of zero or low emission vehicles pay a per-kilometre charge for using the vehicle on certain roads. All other States and Territories backed Victoria; the Commonwealth backed the challengers.
By four to three, the Court held s 7(1) was a duty of excise (a tax on goods) and invalid. Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Gleeson JJ gave joint reasons. Jagot J agreed the charge was invalid, in separate reasons, and would also overrule Dickenson’s Arcade.
The Court unanimously refused Victoria leave to reopen two earlier decisions, Capital Duplicators [No 2] and Ha. The joint reasons said those cases support existing Commonwealth and State revenue arrangements, including the GST settlement.
The joint reasons also overruled Dickenson’s Arcade, which had said a tax on goods at the point of consumption could never be an excise. They called that old exception “anomalous and unsustainable.”
They held the Victorian charge was really a tax on the vehicles themselves. It closely related to using them, and affected them as articles of commerce.
The joint reasons said any tax on goods, at any stage including use, can only be imposed through uniform national legislation. They added that only the Commonwealth Parliament can impose a new tax on goods; Jagot J agreed.
Gordon, Edelman and Steward JJ dissented, holding the charge was valid. Gordon J said the majority’s new rule departed from long-established principle and authority.
What the cases leave open
This is just a way to organise the cases. It is not a legal test the courts actually set out.
The cases do not decide whether duty, payroll tax or land tax count as a tax on goods. That question stays open.
Justice Jagot said many taxes burden goods without being a tax on goods. She treated this as a question of substance, not of what the tax is called.
High Court decisions bind lower courts. But the High Court can later change its own rulings, as Vanderstock itself demonstrates.
Cases applying Vanderstock after this one are not covered here.
Applying this in a problem question
When answering a problem question, first identify the relevant state or territory law and the High Court case on point. This passage only covers two examples: the New South Wales tobacco licence fees in Ha, and the Victorian vehicle charge in Vanderstock. Do not assume another law gets the same result.
Next, ask whether the exaction is actually a tax, rather than a fee for a service or a regulatory fee. Calling it a “licence fee” or “charge” does not settle this question (Ha; Vanderstock, joint reasons and Jagot J).
Then ask whether it is a tax on goods. This means checking whether it closely relates to a step in dealing with goods — production, sale, distribution (Ha), or use (Vanderstock) — and whether it affects the goods as articles of commerce.
If it is a tax on goods, s 90 applies and the state law is invalid, even though the Commonwealth could impose the same tax through uniform legislation.
If the facts don’t clearly show a tax on goods, don’t assume every state tax is automatically valid or invalid. Instead, identify which question the facts actually raise. Remember Vanderstock was a close decision, four justices to three.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.