Furphy v Nixon
Furphy v Nixon (1925) 37 CLR 161; [1925] HCA 34
Purchasers of farmland paid what the vendors demanded, part of it not due, because the vendors threatened to cancel the contract. They then asked for the overpayment back. Had they paid voluntarily?
What happened?
Under a contract of 1 July 1913 the vendors, Furphy and others, sold 1,920 acres of conditionally purchased land to the purchasers, Nixon and another, for £8,112 15s on the footing that the land would be transferred as freehold. The contract allowed the purchasers to elect to take a transfer as conditionally purchased land, in which case the amount owing to the Crown was to be deducted from the purchase-money (Knox CJ, Isaacs J). The land was not transferred until September 1924 (Knox CJ).
A dispute arose about the amount payable to complete the purchase. On 30 August 1924 the purchasers took out an originating summons asking for the amount properly payable to be determined. On 12 September 1924, before the time for appearance had expired, they paid the sum the vendors demanded, under a threat of cancellation of the contract if it was not paid on or before that day (Knox CJ). It was admitted that they were entitled to a credit of £32 and that the vendors were not entitled to charge interest on interest. The vendors disputed the purchasers’ right to reopen the payment of 12 September, and Long Innes J, who heard the summons in equity, ruled for the purchasers. The vendors appealed to the High Court.
What did the Court decide?
The High Court dismissed the vendors’ appeal with costs. Knox CJ, Isaacs J and Higgins J each gave reasons. Knox CJ and Higgins J upheld the construction of the contract on which interest ran on the reduced purchase-money, and Isaacs J would have allowed the appeal as to the first declaration made by Long Innes J.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
All three Justices held that the purchasers’ payment of 12 September 1924 was not voluntary. Knox CJ said that Long Innes J was “clearly right in deciding that the payment in question was not voluntary”. Isaacs J said that “the vendors exerted pressure under a threat which, having regard to clause 16 of the contract, was sufficient to alarm a reasonable man in the position of the purchasers and thereby to coerce his will”, that the purchasers “genuinely felt and yielded to the coercion”, and that the vendors could not “be heard to say that their own threat was negligible and should have been disregarded”.
In his view the purchasers “relinquished nothing except the actual possession of so much money”: they “made no new contract which would be voidable until avoided” and did not abandon “their right to a judicial decision on the pending summons”. Higgins J described the payment as “an involuntary payment under unfair pressure” and said that the vendors’ refusal to accept it with a protest “will avail the defendants nothing”. Higgins J held that the payment was “no bar to the declaration made or to the order for inquiries” on the vendor and purchaser summons.
Why does this case matter?
The case is cited where a threat to cancel a contract is said to be pressure. Its question was the recovery of an overpayment on a vendor and purchaser summons, and the word duress does not appear in the reasons.
Exam and application relevance
State what the purchasers asked the court to do, and use the case for that question. Attribute the formulation about a reasonable man in the purchasers’ position to Isaacs J; Knox CJ added nothing to the reasons of Long Innes J on the payment.
The case was decided in 1925 on a vendor and purchaser summons in New South Wales equity; check for later authority before relying on it for a current problem.
Check your understanding
1. What did the vendors threaten, and what did the purchasers pay on 12 September 1924?
2. In Isaacs J’s words, what was the threat sufficient to do to a reasonable man in the purchasers’ position?
3. What did Isaacs J say the purchasers had and had not given up by paying?
4. On the construction of the contract, where did Isaacs J differ from Knox CJ and Higgins J?