Associated Newspapers Ltd v Bancks

High Court of Australia · 1951

ContractDischarge And Remedies

Associated Newspapers Ltd v Bancks (1951) 83 CLR 322

A comic artist was promised the front page of the comic section every Sunday. For three Sundays his strip ran on the third page, and he ended his ten-year contract. Could he?

Qualified by Koompahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 61

Not overruled. In Koompahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 61 at [48], the joint reasons of Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Heydon and Crennan JJ said that Jordan CJ’s statement on substantial performance and substantial breach, which Bancks quotes, is now to be read in the light of later developments in the law, and at [49]-[53] recognised the intermediate term beside the essential term.

What happened?

Mr Bancks drew the comic strip “Us Fellers”, whose principal character is “Ginger Meggs”. On 22 September 1948 he made a contract with Associated Newspapers Ltd for ten years from 27 March 1949, for a substantial weekly salary. He agreed to devote the whole of his time and attention to the company’s affairs and to prepare and furnish each week a full-page drawing of “Us Fellers”. By clause 5 the company undertook that each weekly drawing would be presented on the front page of the comic section of its weekly newspaper, the “Sunday Sun and Guardian”.

The company kept that undertaking until February 1951. A shortage of newsprint then led it to print the comic section as an inset in its colour magazine, and in the issues of 11, 18 and 25 February 1951 his drawing appeared on the third page of the comic section; that page became the front page only if the reader reverse-folded the inset. The artist told the company’s editor that he was dissatisfied, and on 26 February 1951 he wrote that the company had “repeatedly, without his consent and in face of his protest, broken its undertaking contained in cl. 5” and that he was no longer bound by the contract.

The company sued in the Supreme Court of New South Wales for injunctions enforcing negative covenants in the contract. The suit was dismissed because the artist’s rescission was held effective, and the company appealed to the High Court.

What did the Court decide?

The High Court dismissed the appeal with costs. In a single written judgment delivered on 11 May 1951, Dixon, Williams, Webb, Fullagar and Kitto JJ held that the artist’s letter of 26 February 1951 was an effective ending of the contract, so that the company had no ground for the injunctions it sought.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

The Court asked whether the company’s undertaking to present the artist’s weekly drawing on the front page of the comic section was “a condition or essential term of the contract going to its very root, the breach of which would immediately entitle the defendant at his option to rescind the contract and sue for damages for the loss of the contract”, or “a mere warranty or non-essential and subsidiary term the breach of which would entitle the defendant to damages”.

It said that “[v]arious tests have been advanced by the courts from time to time”, took from Blackburn J in Bettini v Gye that the court “must ascertain the intention of the parties to be collected from the instrument and the circumstances legally admissible with reference to which it is to be construed”, and offered as perhaps a better formulation that of Morison: “You look at the stipulation broken from the point of view of its probable effect or importance as an inducement to enter into the contract.”

It then set out, as “succinctly stated” by Jordan CJ in Tramways Advertising Pty Ltd v Luna Park (NSW) Ltd, the test of essentiality: “whether it appears from the general nature of the contract considered as a whole, or from some particular term or terms, that the promise is of such importance to the promisee that he would not have entered into the contract unless he had been assured of a strict or a substantial performance of the promise, as the case may be, and that this ought to have been apparent to the promisor”.

Applying that approach, the Court said that the artist’s obligation to supply the weekly drawing and the company’s undertaking to present it were “concurrent and correlative promises”, that “[i]t is impossible to attach different values to the defendant’s obligation and the plaintiff’s undertaking”, and that “[o]bviously it was of prime importance to the defendant that there should be continuity of publication so that his work should be kept continuously before the public, that his work should be published as a whole and not mutilated, and that it should be published on the most conspicuous page of the comic section”.

The undertaking “formed a condition a substantial failure in the performance of which would enable the defendant to treat the contract as at an end”, and three successive breaches “went to the root of the contract and gave the defendant as the injured party the right immediately to treat the contract as at an end”. The Court added that the company’s conduct also “points and points only to a refusal by the plaintiff to perform cl. 5 of the contract and satisfies the test laid down by Lord Selborne” in Mersey Steel and Iron Co Ltd v Naylor, Benzon & Co.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Dixon, Williams, Webb, Fullagar and Kitto JJ (joint judgment)

Read judgment: pp 336–339 (opens in a new tab)

The joint judgment uses the essentiality test quoted from Jordan CJ in Tramways Advertising to construe the front-page undertaking. Its importance to Bancks and its correlation with his promise to supply drawings support the conclusion that it was a condition. The three successive breaches entitled him to end the contract, making this reasoning necessary to the stated ground for dismissing the company’s appeal.

Obiter · Dixon, Williams, Webb, Fullagar and Kitto JJ (joint judgment)

Read judgment: p 340 (opens in a new tab)

Having held that breach of the condition entitled Bancks to terminate, the joint judgment expressly says he did not have to prove a refusal to be bound. Its further observation that the company’s conduct nevertheless satisfied Lord Selborne’s renunciation test was unnecessary to that ground of decision. The quoted test is Lord Selborne’s; the assessment of the company’s conduct is the joint judgment’s own.

Why does this case matter?

The clause in dispute concerned where in the newspaper the artist’s work would appear, not whether it would appear or how much he would be paid, and a clause of that kind is easy to dismiss as a detail. That is the shortcut the case is used to warn against.

It also shows why an answer should not end when a term is found not to be a condition, because Koompahtoo later explained that termination for breach has a second route that does not depend on the term being essential.

Exam and application relevance

Begin with the contract as a whole: say what each party was engaged to do and what the promisee was paying for, then ask of the term in dispute the question the Court asked. State the test in the Court’s words and say that the Court took it from Jordan CJ.

Then apply the later High Court decision in Koompahtoo. If the term is not found to be essential, it treats a sufficiently serious breach of a term that is not essential as a separate ground for termination, so the analysis does not stop at the classification.

Check your understanding

1. What did clause 5 require the company to do, and where did the artist’s drawing appear in the issues of 11, 18 and 25 February 1951?

2. Whose statement of the test of essentiality did the Court set out, and what two things about the promise must appear from the contract?

3. Why did the Court treat the artist’s obligation and the company’s undertaking as promises of equal importance?

4. What did the joint reasons in Koompahtoo say about how Jordan CJ’s statement about substantial performance and substantial breach is now to be read?